Please check my answer. Do I have the right one?

  • Thread starter Thread starter defdek
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a mechanics problem involving two steel rods and copper supporting a load of 20 kN. The initial calculations provided were incorrect, as they mistakenly referenced three steel rods instead of the specified two. Participants emphasized the importance of listing relevant equations and following proper unit conventions, specifically using GPa instead of GN/m^2. A hint was given to consider equilibrium equations for a more accurate approach. The user acknowledged the guidance and confirmed they found the correct method.
defdek
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
The original question:
2 steel rods and copper each of 20mm diameter together support a load of 20 kN. Find the stresses in the rod. Take E for steel and copper as 2.05 GN/m^2 and 1.10 GN/m^2.

l=FL/AE

for steel
l=(20kN)(2m)/(0.0003141x3)(2.05 GN/m^2)=0.021
stress= lE/L=(0.021m)(2.05 GN/m^2)/2m=21525000

and should i do the same for copper?
 

Attachments

  • picture.png
    picture.png
    788 bytes · Views: 446
Physics news on Phys.org
defdek: Your answer is currently incorrect. What you typed would be three steel rods, which is not what the question says. You omitted the other relevant equations.

You must list the relevant equations yourself. The PF rules state we are not allowed to list relevant equations for you, nor tell you how to approach or solve your homework problem. We can only check your math, after you do all of the work to figure out how to approach the problem. Hint 1: Try an equilibrium equation.

By the way, the correct unit symbol for GN/m^2 is called GPa. Only write GPa; do not write its derivation each time. See the international standard for writing units[/color] (ISO 31-0[/color]).
 
nvn said:
defdek: Your answer is currently incorrect. What you typed would be three steel rods, which is not what the question says. You omitted the other relevant equations.

You must list the relevant equations yourself. The PF rules state we are not allowed to list relevant equations for you, nor tell you how to approach or solve your homework problem. We can only check your math, after you do all of the work to figure out how to approach the problem. Hint 1: Try an equilibrium equation.

By the way, the correct unit symbol for GN/m^2 is called GPa. Only write GPa; do not write its derivation each time. See the international standard for writing units[/color] (ISO 31-0[/color]).

I found it. thanks for the hint
 
Back
Top