Point of Intersection of two lines

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding the coordinates of point T where two tangents to an ellipse intersect, represented by the equations involving trigonometric functions. Participants express frustration with the substitution method, particularly in simplifying the equations to find values for x and y. A more efficient approach suggested involves using linear combinations to eliminate variables. After several attempts, a participant successfully derives the coordinates using both methods, confirming that the substitution method can lead to complex results. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the importance of method selection in solving trigonometric equations effectively.
Jumpsmash
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Two tangents to an ellipse meet at a point T, find the coordinates of T.

The two equations are
(bcosΘ)x + (asinΘ)y= ab
(-bsinΘ)x + (acosΘ)y= ab


This has been really frustrating me as I feel it should be simple, but with the trigonometric parts I keep hitting a wall.

I have tried finding x in the first equation, which I worked out as X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ , and then substituting into the second equation to get a value for y, but I couldn't get it to condense to a reasonable form. I don't think this is the right approach and would appreciate someone pointing me in the right direction of how I should approach it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Jumpsmash said:
I have tried finding x in the first equation, which I worked out as X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ , and then substituting into the second equation to get a value for y, but I couldn't get it to condense to a reasonable form.
After substituting into the 2nd equation, multiply both sides by cosΘ. You'll be able to use the Pythagorean identity sin2 Θ + cos2 Θ = 1 to simplify things quite a bit.
 
If I work it through I seem to get once x has been substituted into the second equation

aby(cos^2Θ+sin^2Θ)= ab^2(cosΘ+sinΘ)
y=b(cosΘ+sinΘ)

I've quite probably lost the plot, but I have repeated this several times and come up with this. And given this result multiplying by cosΘ doesn't seem to help me. When I substitute this into the original equation I get an even more unwieldly result, and considering I have to use this point subsequently in what I'm doing I don't think it's right.
 
What you give for x simply isn't correct.
Multiply the first equation, (bcosΘ)x + (asinΘ)y= ab, by cosΘ, multiply the second equation, (-bsinΘ)x + (acosΘ)y= ab, by -sinΘ and add the two equations to eliminate y. There will be NO "b" in the result for x.
 
HallsofIvy said:
What you give for x simply isn't correct.
If you're referring to the OP:
X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ
... well, I got this too.

Jumpsmash said:
If I work it through I seem to get once x has been substituted into the second equation

aby(cos^2Θ+sin^2Θ)= ab^2(cosΘ+sinΘ)
y=b(cosΘ+sinΘ)

I've quite probably lost the plot, but I have repeated this several times and come up with this. And given this result multiplying by cosΘ doesn't seem to help me. When I substitute this into the original equation I get an even more unwieldly result, and considering I have to use this point subsequently in what I'm doing I don't think it's right.

What Halls is suggesting (linear combinations) is probably easier. But if you want to stick with substitution:
x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}

Substitute this into the second equation:
-b\sin\theta \left( \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}\right) + a\cos\theta y = ab

Cancel out the b:
-\sin\theta \left( \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{\cos \theta}\right) + a\cos\theta y = ab

This is where I'm suggesting to multiply by cosΘ:
-\sin\theta \left( ab - a \sin\theta y \right) + a\cos^2 \theta y = ab\cos\theta

From here you should be able to solve for y. It looks like you did, because you got
y = b cos Θ + b sin Θ
which is what I got.

Now substitute into
x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}
and get
x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta (b\cos\theta + b\sin\theta)}{b \cos \theta}
and simplify.
 
Last edited:
Many thanks to both of you. I see the method by Halls and got the solutions through that. It did indeed seem quicker. With regard to the substitution, my apologies I did multiply through by cosΘ without realising and in fact reached the stage you showed. It was from there that I could not simplify it and thought I must have the wrong solution. From using the other method it appears x=a(cosΘ-sinΘ); but I still don't see how to simplify the equation for x from the subsitution to this form.
 
You mean simplifying x from here?
x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta (b\cos\theta + b\sin\theta)}{b \cos \theta}

Distribute:
x = \frac{ab - ab \sin\theta \cos\theta - ab\sin^2\theta}{b \cos \theta}

Factor out an ab and cancel out the b:
x = \frac{a(1 - \sin\theta \cos\theta - \sin^2\theta)}{\cos \theta}

Use the Pythagorean identity again (sin2 θ + cos2 θ = 1 -> 1 - sin2 θ = cos2 θ):
x = \frac{a(\cos^2 \theta - \sin\theta \cos\theta)}{\cos \theta}

Can you finish from here?
 
Apologies for delay thought I sent this. Yes I can, many thanks.
 
Back
Top