KFC
- 477
- 4
I am trying to deduce the expression for pressure of perfect gas when the momentum distribution n(p) is given.
Here is how I did. First we assume a box with side length L_x, L_y, L_z, when a particle , say moving a long x direction, collide with one side of the wall, the total change of momentum would be
\Delta p_x = -2m v_x
Assume it takes time t for one round-trip (from one wall to the oppsite and come back), hence
t = \frac{2L_x}{v_x}
and 1/t is the rate of colliding.
Now consider the average impact per unit time,
\overline{f} = \Delta p_x \times (\textnormal{rate of colliding}) = 2mv_x \frac{v_x}{2L_x} = \frac{mv_x^2}{L_x}
For N particles, the total average impact per unit time would be
\overline{F} = \sum_i^Nf_i = \sum_i^N \frac{mv_{ix}^2}{L_x}
Hence, the pressure on the side A=L_yL_z woule be
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \frac{\overline{F}}{L_yL_z}
For continuous case, the average impact becomes
\overline{F} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_x}dp
So, the pressure becomes
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_xL_yL_z}dp
In unit volume, L_xL_yL_z=1, wehave
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \int pvn(p)dp
I know there is something wrong here. The correct answer should be
P = \frac{1}{3}\int pvn(p)dp
Well, I don't know where my reasoning is going wrong. From \overline{F} = \sum_i^N \frac{mv_{ix}^2}{L_x} to \overline{F} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_x}dp, I feel that there is something missing?
Here is how I did. First we assume a box with side length L_x, L_y, L_z, when a particle , say moving a long x direction, collide with one side of the wall, the total change of momentum would be
\Delta p_x = -2m v_x
Assume it takes time t for one round-trip (from one wall to the oppsite and come back), hence
t = \frac{2L_x}{v_x}
and 1/t is the rate of colliding.
Now consider the average impact per unit time,
\overline{f} = \Delta p_x \times (\textnormal{rate of colliding}) = 2mv_x \frac{v_x}{2L_x} = \frac{mv_x^2}{L_x}
For N particles, the total average impact per unit time would be
\overline{F} = \sum_i^Nf_i = \sum_i^N \frac{mv_{ix}^2}{L_x}
Hence, the pressure on the side A=L_yL_z woule be
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \frac{\overline{F}}{L_yL_z}
For continuous case, the average impact becomes
\overline{F} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_x}dp
So, the pressure becomes
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_xL_yL_z}dp
In unit volume, L_xL_yL_z=1, wehave
P = \frac{\overline{F}}{A} = \int pvn(p)dp
I know there is something wrong here. The correct answer should be
P = \frac{1}{3}\int pvn(p)dp
Well, I don't know where my reasoning is going wrong. From \overline{F} = \sum_i^N \frac{mv_{ix}^2}{L_x} to \overline{F} = \int \frac{pvn(p)}{L_x}dp, I feel that there is something missing?