Probability and Expected value

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

This discussion revolves around a discrete math problem involving probability and expected value related to drawing cards from a deck. The scenario describes different outcomes based on the suit of the card drawn, with specific values assigned to each card and varying rewards or penalties depending on the suit.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the expected values associated with drawing hearts, diamonds, and black cards, questioning the calculations and assumptions made regarding probabilities and outcomes.

Discussion Status

There is an ongoing examination of the expected value calculations, with some participants providing corrections and clarifications on how to approach the problem. Multiple interpretations of the expected values and their calculations are being discussed, indicating a productive exchange of ideas.

Contextual Notes

Participants note confusion regarding the treatment of black cards and the application of probabilities in their calculations. There is also mention of the importance of clearly understanding the problem's definitions and conditions.

Ethers0n
Messages
27
Reaction score
0
This is for a discrete math homework set.

1. Suppose the cards in a deck are given the following values: Ace has value 1, two has value 2,..., ten has value 10, Jack has value 11, Queen has value 12, and King has value 13. A player selects a card. If it is a heart, the player receives half the value of the card. If it is a diamond, the player receives twice the value of the card. If the card is black the player loses 15 What is the player's expected value in the game?



2. I'm having issue dealing with the black cards in my attempted solution.



3. I am going about the solution in this manner
(52choose1 )* .5(13choose1)*2(13choose1)*[the value obtained from the -15 points and 26choose1]


Am I approaching this question correctly?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What you are doing looks much too complicated and I see no "probability" in your formula at all. Here's how I would do it:

First, assuming the card drawn is a diamond, what is the expected value? What is the probability of drawing a diamond?

Second, assuming the card drawn is a heart, what is the expected value? What is the probability of drawing a heart?

Finally, assuming the card drawn is black, the expected value is -15. What is the probability of drawing a black card?
 
so the probability of drawing a heart or a diamond is 1/4
the probability of drawing a black card is 1/2

The expected value once a heart is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*2
The '*2' because of the problem definition.
The expected value once a diamond is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]

The expected value once a black card is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-10
The '-10' term is from the problem definition.

would that mean then that the total expected value would then just be
.25*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*2 + [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)] + [[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-10]?
 
The expected value of a heart would not be multiplied by 2 since you are receiving half the value, divide by 2 instead. You forgot to multiply by .25 and by 2 the expected value of the diamonds and finally the expected value of the black cards has nothing to do with their actual value. Since the probability of getting a black card is 1/2 and the value you get for a black card is -15 your expected value is...?
 
Ethers0n said:
so the probability of drawing a heart or a diamond is 1/4
the probability of drawing a black card is 1/2

The expected value once a heart is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*2
The '*2' because of the problem definition.
Then you had better go back and read your problem again. You told us
" If it is a heart, the player receives half the value of the card."

The expected value once a diamond is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]
"If it is a diamond, the player receives twice the value of the card. "

The expected value once a black card is drawn is [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-10
The '-10' term is from the problem definition.

would that mean then that the total expected value would then just be
.25*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*2 + [(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)] + [[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-10]?
 
ah, it looks like I switched those.

.25*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*2 + .25*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]*.5 + .5*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-15]

is this correct then?
 
Yes. And it looks to me like you really want to know what 1+ 2+ ...+ 12+ 13 is!
 
:P
yes I could add that up, but I tend to leave things written out like that so that I can quickly see where I got it from (to double check my work)
thank you!
 
If you lose 15 points with certainty for any black card then why do you still need the expected value of a black card in your calculation:
5*[(13+12+11+...+2+1)/13)]-15]
 

Similar threads

Replies
31
Views
7K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
17K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
8K
Replies
1
Views
2K