Probability with urns and balls

  • Thread starter Thread starter mynameisfunk
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Balls Probability
AI Thread Summary
To determine the probability that the last urn contains j balls when n balls are distributed into k urns, one approach is to calculate the total number of ways to fill the urns. Initially, if all n balls are in one urn, there are k ways to choose which urn to fill. As more balls are added, the distribution can be calculated using combinations and considering the remaining urns available for the extra balls. The discussion emphasizes the need for a clear understanding of combinatorial principles, particularly the binomial coefficient, to effectively solve the problem. A comprehensive calculation of the total distributions is essential for finding the desired probability.
mynameisfunk
Messages
122
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


If n balls are distributed into k urns, what is the probability that the last urn contains j balls?


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



not really sure how to do it. This is only a review question, not HW, but with that being known, I would appreciate an explanation more than an answer.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


There are a few ways to approach this problem. That being said..

To find to number of possible outcomes (i.e. ways to fill the urns), I would start by choosing a fixed number of balls that must be in the same urn, then finding out how many ways the others can be distributed.
So initially, let's say all n balls must be in one urn (clearly only one way to choose them). There are k urns to put them in, so this can be done in k ways.

Now, (n-1) balls must be in one urn. {n\choose n-1}
so n ways to choose these n-1 balls. These can go in any urn, so k(n) ways to fill one urn with n-1 balls. The extra ball may go in any urn except the one already occupied, so it has k-1 urns to choose from. There are k(n)*(k-1) ways to fill the urns in this way.

Requiring that (n-2) balls be in one urn is similar, but the extra 2 balls may both go in any of the k-1 remaining urns, so they can be distributed in (k-1)^{2} ways.


BTW: n\choose k =\frac{n!}{k!(n-k)!}, if you aren't familiar with the notation. It's same thing as imposing an equivalence class so that order doesn't matter. I.E. (a, b) is the same thing as (b, a), which just means that you want the set {a, b}.

Does this make sense?
 


how would i calculate the total number of possible ways to put n balls in k urns?
 
Back
Top