(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); 1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

Find the point on the x-axis where the net electric field is zero for two particles of charges q1=1x10^-9C and q2=2x10^-9C. Assume q1 and q2 are 20cm apart. Assume q1 is located at x=0.

I solved this but it's not the same as the book's answer.. GAH! What do you guys get? Thanks.

2. Relevant equations

Enet=E1+E2, Enet=0 => |E1|=|E2|

E=kq/r² where q is the charge creating the field

3. The attempt at a solution

E1=kq1/r²

E2=kq2/(.2m - r)²

kq1/r²=kq2/(.2m - r)²

q1/r²=q2/(.2m - r)²

q1(.2m - r)²=q2r²

q1(.2m - r)²=q2r²

q1(0.4m-0.4mr+r²)-q2r²=0 <------ There's my mistake

(q1)0.4m-(q1)0.4mr+(q1)r²-q2r²=0

(q1-q2)r²-(q1)0.4mr+(q1)0.4m=0

((1E-9C)-(2E-9C))r²-(1E-9C)0.4mr+(1E-9C)0.4m=0

(-1E-9C)r²-(1E-9C)0.4mr+(1E-9C)0.4m=0

(-1E-9C)r²-(4E-10C)mr+(4E-10C)m=0

(-1E-9)r²-(4E-10)r+(4E-10)=0

r=-0.863325 or r=0.463325

The answer in the book is 8.3cm. Where did I go wrong?

------

Edit:

q1(.2m - r)²=q2r²

q1(0.04m-0.4mr+r²)-q2r²=0

(q1)0.04m-(q1)0.4mr+(q1)r²-q2r²=0

(q1-q2)r²-(q1)0.4mr+(q1)0.04m=0

((1E-9C)-(2E-9C))r²-(1E-9C)0.4mr+(1E-9C)0.04m=0

(-1E-9C)r²-(1E-9C)0.4mr+(1E-9C)0.04m=0

(-1E-9C)r²-(4E-10C)mr+(4E-11C)m=0

(-1E-9)r²-(4E-10)r+(4E-11)=0

Positive r comes out to 8.3cm

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Dismiss Notice

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Problems with Electric Field questions

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**