Put my dead hard drive in the freezer

  • Thread starter Thread starter Artman
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Drive Hard
AI Thread Summary
A mechanical failure of a hard drive, specifically a frozen spindle motor, rendered a backup partition inaccessible. To recover data, the drive was placed in a freezer overnight, which allowed it to contract and temporarily function when connected to a USB enclosure. This method enabled the retrieval of critical documents for a limited time. Concerns about moisture and condensation were addressed, noting that hard drives are well-sealed to prevent contamination. While some suggested using desiccant packs to mitigate any potential moisture issues, the drive remained dry during the process. The discussion highlighted the importance of proper backup strategies, as backing up data on the same drive does not constitute a reliable backup.
Artman
Messages
1,506
Reaction score
40
My wife's computer hard drive failed the other day. She backed up her data, but on a partition on the same drive. The failure was mechanical, the spindle motor froze up. So accessing the backup partition was also out of the question. I was afraid we were doomed, but I read about people who had this problem and put the drive in the freezer to contract and free up some of the moving metal parts.

I put the drive in my freezer overnight. The next day I placed it in a USB external hard drive enclosure, connected that to my laptop, powered it on and the drive spun up and worked for about an hour and a half before slowing to a stop again, long enough to retrieve most of my wife's critical documents.

Thought I'd share this with you all in case something similar ever happens to you.
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
Cool tip! Thanks. (oops, no pun intended)
 
Wooo...good job dude.

And yes, was it a Seagate HDD?
 
Last edited:
Would there be concerns about frost getting on the platters / heads or electronics? I guess you could just throw some dessicant packs in a big ZipLock back with the drive and not leave it for more than a day or two.
 
MATLABdude said:
Would there be concerns about frost getting on the platters / heads or electronics? I guess you could just throw some dessicant packs in a big ZipLock back with the drive and not leave it for more than a day or two.

Hard drives are air tight and very well sealed to prevent dust or other contaminants entering them so a build up of moisture due to cold temperatures isn't an issue.
 
Topher925 said:
Hard drives are air tight and very well sealed to prevent dust or other contaminants entering them so a build up of moisture due to cold temperatures isn't an issue.

I think most new hard drives now have little filtered vent or 'breather hole' to equalize pressures, along with an attendant "Do not cover this hole!" warning sticker on the outside:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_disk_drive#Integrity
 
I did not mention it, but I did put the drive in a ziplock bag, but never thought about adding some desiccant packs. That is a good suggestion.

I was concerned about condensation effecting the electronics or platters, but it seemed to stay pretty dry.

dE_logics, no, it was not a Seagate. I'm not where I can get to the drive right now, but I think it was a Toshiba.
 
Artman said:
My wife's computer hard drive failed the other day. She backed up her data, but on a partition on the same drive.

Well, that's not a backup, techincally...

The failure was mechanical, the spindle motor froze up. So accessing the backup partition was also out of the question. I was afraid we were doomed, but I read about people who had this problem and put the drive in the freezer to contract and free up some of the moving metal parts.

I put the drive in my freezer overnight. The next day I placed it in a USB external hard drive enclosure, connected that to my laptop, powered it on and the drive spun up and worked for about an hour and a half before slowing to a stop again, long enough to retrieve most of my wife's critical documents.

Thought I'd share this with you all in case something similar ever happens to you.

Nope, but I admire you ingenuity, and hope you used that time to make another copy!
 
Back
Top