Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the recovery of wavefunctions in periodic ab initio calculations, particularly focusing on how to obtain wavefunctions at K points not included in the irreducible K grid. Participants explore theoretical frameworks and mathematical transformations relevant to this topic.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions how to recover wavefunctions at K points outside the irreducible K grid used in ab initio calculations.
- Another participant expresses unfamiliarity with the term "irreducible K grid," later clarifying it as "irreducible K wedge" in the first Brillouin Zone.
- A participant suggests that other K wedges can be obtained by applying the elements of the point group of the crystal to the wavefunctions, referencing the orbit-stabilizer theorem from group theory.
- There is a discussion on the transformation of eigen-wavefunctions for specific K points, with a participant questioning whether the transformation depends on the choice of basis set.
- One participant provides a general expression for transforming wavefunctions, emphasizing the use of Bloch theorem and caution regarding direct and reciprocal lattice vectors.
- Another participant raises a concern about transforming spinors or other quantities that may differ from wavefunctions, particularly when dealing with arbitrary K directions.
- A response indicates that the transformation of spinors or vectors requires a transformation matrix, suggesting a more complex transformation process.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying levels of understanding and familiarity with the concepts discussed, leading to some agreement on the application of group theory and transformations, but no consensus is reached on the specifics of the transformation process or its dependence on basis sets.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include potential missing assumptions regarding the nature of the wavefunctions and the specific mathematical steps involved in the transformations discussed. The discussion does not resolve the complexities involved in transforming quantities like spinors or local orbital density matrices.