Refraction of Light Wave: What Causes It?

In summary, according to this person, the speed of light does not change when it goes from one medium to another, but the wavelength does. This is because the wave's frequency stays the same, but the wave's wavelength changes because the speed changes.
  • #1
jha192001
22
2
(1)What is the real cause of refraction?
Light wave cannot possible have a change of speed in going onto diffrent medium hence what is going on inside actually that we say its a change of speed.
(2) I am notable to comprehend how a change in wavelength not always means a change in frequency. If i draw a diagram of a way of a axis a change in wavelength always results in change in frequency.
Thanks
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
jha192001 said:
Light wave cannot possible have a change of speed in going onto diffrent medium
Why do you claim this?
 
  • #3
jha192001 said:
(1)What is the real cause of refraction?
Light wave cannot possible have a change of speed in going onto diffrent medium hence what is going on inside actually that we say its a change of speed.

This is puzzling, because assuming that you are just learning about it, why would you make such an erroneous statement?

Please note that, if you want to be technical about it, the speed that we measure when light goes from one medium to another, is the group velocity of the wave. This definitely changes as exhibited by the different index of refraction.

Otherwise, you have a lot of explaining to do.

Zz.
 
  • #4
jha192001 said:
(2) I am notable to comprehend how a change in wavelength not always means a change in frequency. If i draw a diagram of a way of a axis a change in wavelength always results in change in frequency.

The change in wavelength occurs because the speed of the wave changes. The wavelength and frequency of a wave is given by the equation ##v=fλ##, where v is the speed of the wave, f is the frequency, and λ is the wavelength.

You can think of the frequency of an EM wave as being set and the wavelength changing as the speed changes. So a wave that enters a medium with a higher refractive index slows down, forcing the wavelength to change in order to keep the frequency the same. As an extreme example, if the speed of the wave is cut in half, then the wavelength is also cut in half. Otherwise the equation would be wrong.
 
  • #5
But still its not clear how does refraction occur.
A change in speed doesn't signify change in direction. What cause the light to change the direction the same everytime
 
  • #6
I stated the above statement cause i remembered a video in which they told that speed of light doesn't change in a medium infact light is absorbed and desorped by atoms and hence it appears it has slowed down tho it has it just follows a longer path. I watched the video a time ago and while i was learning about refraction i came across this doubt i had
 
  • #7
jha192001 said:
But still its not clear how does refraction occur.
A change in speed doesn't signify change in direction. What cause the light to change the direction the same everytime

If it is not clear, then you shouldn't be making such silly statement in the first place. You should simply ask why there is a direction change. Question: What do you think will happen to the wavefronts when they cross the interface?

Note: there is NO direction change if the angle of incidence is perpendicular to the interface. Yet, there will still be a change in the group velocity.

jha192001 said:
I stated the above statement cause i remembered a video in which they told that speed of light doesn't change in a medium infact light is absorbed and desorped by atoms and hence it appears it has slowed down tho it has it just follows a longer path. I watched the video a time ago and while i was learning about refraction i came across this doubt i had

This is not sufficient. You should make explicit reference to the video. After all, you could easily have misinterpreted what the video is saying. The speed of PHOTONS may not change inside the medium. But as I've stated before, this is NOT the speed of light that is being measured! You seem to not know the concept of group velocity in a medium.

Zz.
 
  • #8
jha192001 said:
But still its not clear how does refraction occur.
A change in speed doesn't signify change in direction. What cause the light to change the direction the same everytime

Think about Huygen's principle. As the wave hits the medium boundary, the source wavelets at that boundary interfere with each other to produce the new wavefront. As illustrated below, the slower speed of the wavelets in the new medium is what gives rise to the change in direction.

300px-Refraction_-_Huygens-Fresnel_principle.svg.png


jha192001 said:
I stated the above statement cause i remembered a video in which they told that speed of light doesn't change in a medium infact light is absorbed and desorped by atoms and hence it appears it has slowed down tho it has it just follows a longer path. I watched the video a time ago and while i was learning about refraction i came across this doubt i had

That's not quite correct. Near-field effects inside the medium affect the EM wave, and this can't really be explained very well as photons being absorbed and re-emitted like you normally imagine. Besides, a classical EM wave is simply the sum effect of huge numbers of photons, so we're talking about the collective effect of them all. And if they are being absorbed and re-emitted individually, then as a whole collective you will have large numbers of photons in each possible state (emitted and traveling, absorbed, etc) and the net effect is to slow down the EM wave as a whole. But please don't take my explanation of this as anything close to accurate. You would need to get into quantum electrodynamics to understand just what is going on.
 

Attachments

  • 300px-Refraction_-_Huygens-Fresnel_principle.svg.png
    300px-Refraction_-_Huygens-Fresnel_principle.svg.png
    5.6 KB · Views: 895
  • Like
Likes russ_watters and jha192001
  • #9
(1) Everybody ask a question thinking what they ready know to be correct. Thats what i did. Maybe you failed to understand this simple thing. I don't have a reference to video that's why i didnt stated it first and stated when needed. The only new thing you said were about the group velocity and i will read about them, its a.new term to me(or you can send a link if you are kind enough).
And nobody is understanding the basic ques. of what really causes Refraction.Light isn't bound to follow our rules right, so why change in medium=change in direcn. upon change in speed.
Maybe the answer is beyond my present scope to understand but when i ask questions, wise people tend to help in providing links or terms that may increase my knowledge.
Thanks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
Drakkith said:
Think about Huygen's principle. As the wave hits the medium boundary, the source wavelets at that boundary interfere with each other to produce the new wavefront. As illustrated below, the slower speed of the wavelets in the new medium is what gives rise to the change in direction.

View attachment 232076
That's not quite correct. Near-field effects inside the medium affect the EM wave, and this can't really be explained very well as photons being absorbed and re-emitted like you normally imagine. Besides, a classical EM wave is simply the sum effect of huge numbers of photons, so we're talking about the collective effect of them all. And if they are being absorbed and re-emitted individually, then as a whole collective you will have large numbers of photons in each possible state (emitted and traveling, absorbed, etc) and the net effect is to slow down the EM wave as a whole. But please don't take my explanation of this as anything close to accurate. You would need to get into quantum electrodynamics to understand just what is going on.
Thanks this is best far..Thanks all of you
 
  • #11
jha192001 said:
(1) Everybody ask a question thinking what they ready know to be correct. Thats what i did.
That's not a good strategy at the PF. Much better is to post links to the reading you have been doing so far, and ask specific questions about what is confusing you in that reading.
 
  • #12
jha192001 said:
And nobody is understanding the basic ques. of what really causes Refraction.Light isn't bound to follow our rules right, so why change in medium=change in direcn. upon change in speed.
The refraction of light at a dielectric boundary is similar in concept to the refraction of water waves as they pass from an area of one water depth to another. You can see this near the beach where the depth of the water is changing, and the waves may be coming in at an angle to the beach. Have you seen figures like the one below before?

http://www.geosci.usyd.edu.au/users/prey/Teaching/Geos-2111GIS/Tsunami/Images/Refraction-Water-Waves.gif

Refraction-Water-Waves.gif
 

Attachments

  • Refraction-Water-Waves.gif
    Refraction-Water-Waves.gif
    8 KB · Views: 823
  • #13
jha192001 said:
Everybody ask a question thinking what they ready know to be correct.
Wise men, upon encountering an apparent contradiction, begin by questioning what they think they know.

“The most difficult subjects can be explained to the most slow-witted man if he has not formed any idea of them already; but the simplest thing cannot be made clear to the most intelligent man if he is firmly persuaded that he knows already, without a shadow of a doubt, what is laid before him.”
 
  • Like
Likes DrStupid, anorlunda, russ_watters and 1 other person
  • #14
jbriggs444 said:
Wise men, upon encountering an apparent contradiction, begin by questioning what they think they know.

“The most difficult subjects can be explained to the most slow-witted man if he has not formed any idea of them already; but the simplest thing cannot be made clear to the most intelligent man if he is firmly persuaded that he knows already, without a shadow of a doubt, what is laid before him.”
yes sir, was i stubborn when any of my knowledge was corrected? Thanks for the quote.
 
  • Like
Likes Nik_2213
  • #15
jha192001 said:
And nobody is understanding the basic ques. of what really causes Refraction.
I can see what your problem is / was. You started off saying that the speed of light doesn't change in a medium. I think you have now accepted that this is not the case and that c=λf must be applied correctly and relevantly (your first post). The thing that does not (cannot) change is the frequency. So the wavelength must be the thing that changes when c changes. At any boundary, there has to be continuity of phase - which is to say that the peaks of all the waves as they traverse the boundary cannot suddenly change position. That means that the angle of the wave must change (see the diagrams above) in order to support incident and refracted waves having different wavelengths.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
  • #16
jha192001 said:
(1)What is the real cause of refraction?

As Richard Feynman states it in "The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume I": "Before we proceed with our study of how the index of refraction comes about, we should understand that all that is required to understand refraction is to understand why the apparent wave velocity is different in different materials." Have a look at chapter 31 "The Origin of the Refractive Index" in http://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_toc.html
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and jha192001
  • #17
ZapperZ said:
The speed of PHOTONS may not change inside the medium.

Even single photons behave like light waves inside the medium, including reduced speed and refraction.
 

Related to Refraction of Light Wave: What Causes It?

1. What is refraction of light wave?

Refraction of light wave is the bending of light as it passes through different mediums, such as air, water, or glass. This occurs due to a change in the speed of light as it travels from one medium to another.

2. What causes refraction of light wave?

The change in speed of light as it travels through different mediums causes refraction. This change in speed is due to the difference in density and optical properties of the mediums.

3. How does the angle of incidence affect refraction of light wave?

The angle of incidence, which is the angle at which the light ray hits the surface of the medium, affects the amount of bending that occurs during refraction. The greater the angle of incidence, the more the light ray will bend.

4. How does the refractive index of a medium affect the refraction of light wave?

The refractive index of a medium is a measure of how much the speed of light is reduced when it travels through that medium. The higher the refractive index, the more the light will bend when it enters the medium.

5. What are some real-life applications of refraction of light wave?

Refraction of light wave is used in various optical devices, such as lenses, prisms, and mirrors, which are used in cameras, microscopes, telescopes, and eyeglasses. It is also used in the phenomenon of rainbows, where sunlight is refracted by water droplets in the atmosphere, creating a spectrum of colors.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
41
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top