Refractive index- will it travel back along the same way?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the behavior of light rays as they transition between different media, specifically regarding refraction and total internal reflection. Participants clarify that when light travels from a denser medium to a less dense one at angles greater than the critical angle, it will not refract but instead reflect internally. The conversation also touches on the use of an Abbé refractometer and spectroscopy to measure the refractive index, emphasizing the importance of using a monochromatic light source for accurate results. Questions arise about how light behaves at various angles, particularly at 90 degrees, leading to insights about the nature of light rays and their paths. Overall, the thread explores the principles of light behavior in relation to refractive indices and experimental setups.
Outrageous
Messages
373
Reaction score
0
Refractive index----- will it travel back along the same way?

From the picture
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:RefractionReflextion.svg
If I travel a light ray from n2 to n1 , I think the light ray will travel in the opposite direction shown in the first picture.
But what about the second? The light that 90 degree will find the same way back? I think it should go straight? How should the light travel and why?
Thanks
 
Science news on Phys.org
Treating it is a ray, it would simply go straight since it isn't hitting the boundary and trying to move from one medium to another.
 
Drakkith said:
Treating it is a ray, it would simply go straight since it isn't hitting the boundary and trying to move from one medium to another.

I agree. There is no refraction for any angle of incidence greater than the critical angle - and that includes 90 degrees. (It goes without saying that we are starting in the more dense medium.)
 
Then is this picture correct?
This is an experiment to find the region n2 refractive index
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    46.6 KB · Views: 363
That equipment is based on the Abbé refractometer(?) which can be used to analyse tiny samples of liquids. So, yes, you could use it.
 
No, I am using spectroscopy and prism to detect the refraction index.
 
Outrageous said:
No, I am using spectroscopy and prism to detect the refraction index.

Are you using total internal reflection to find the refractive index, or what?
 
Sorry, it is spectrometer.
Yup it is use to find the refractive index of the glass cell.
My book says : a sharp boundary distinguishes the bright from the dark region because no rays are refracted with an angle of refraction larger than critical angle.
So ? I think the refraction will occur along the liquid glass interface. But I feel I still don't understand how the monochromatic light ray is seen.
 
From wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abbe_refractometer

A light source is projected through the illuminating prism, the bottom surface of which is ground (i.e., roughened like a ground-glass joint), so each point on this surface can be thought of as generating light rays traveling in all directions. A detector placed on the back side of the refracting prism would show a light and a dark region.

Is your light source illuminating the entire face of the prism, or is it a single thin beam? I'd expect it to be the former, as I don't see how a thin beam at a 90 degree angle will be refracted or reflected anywhere.
 
  • #10
Drakkith said:
Are you using total internal reflection to find the refractive index, or what?

Looking at the diagram again, it would appear that it is not using 'reflection' but just the limiting case of refraction as the critical angle. (Reflection must obey the laws of reflection and that ray is not reflecting) The incident ray must be traveling along the 'inside' of the liquid and just grazing the inside surface, to be refracted to just under the critical angle and into the prism. If you look at Abbe refractometers, the setup is pretty much the same, looking at the extinction angle. Of course you need a monochromatic light source or the critical angle is not so easy to find (refractive index is wavelength sensitive).
 
Back
Top