Relation between group velocity and phase velocity

4 replies · 7K views · last reply
unscientific
Messages
1,728
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement



Printed exam question 10 on travelling waves: parts a) and b) on light in glass with refractive index n, and surface waves with phase velocity a times the square root of wavelength, with formulas for group velocity.



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten derivation: n = c/v_p = λ0/λ, ω = v_p k, so λ = λ0/n and k = (2π/λ0)n, then assuming 2ω(k), 1/v_g = dk/dω = (dk/dn)(dn/dω) = (2π/λ0)(dn/dω) = (k/n)(dn/dω) = (2ω/v_p n)(dn/dω) = (2ω/c)(dn/dω).


Is my initial assumption wrong?
 
rude man said:
No, it's right.

But I seem to be missing out on a 1/vph term..
 
unscientific said:
But I seem to be missing out on a 1/vph term..

You asked if you initial assumption was right. I did not check all your work. Will try later.
 
You wrote dk/dw = (2pi/0)dn/dw.

However, k depends on more than w:
dk = ∂k/∂w dw + ∂k/∂n dn

So 1/vg = dk/dw = ∂k/∂w + ∂k/∂n dn/dw
= n/c + (w/c) dn/dw
Etc.