Resistance between two points in nested squares circuit

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
Potatochip911
Messages
317
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


Hand-drawn diagram of a square rotated 45 degrees with a smaller axis-aligned square inside it. Points X and Y sit at the left and right corners of the large square. Labels show L/2 on an upper side segment, L on a lower side segment, and L/√2 on a side of the inner square.

The sides of the biggest square have resistance ##R## and length ##L## (the amount of resistance in the wire is equal to the length), the smaller square is placed so that it's corners intersect midway through the sides of the larger square. Find the resistance between points X and Y

Homework Equations


Parallel: ##\frac{1}{R_{eq}}=\frac{1}{R_1}+\frac{1}{R_2}+\cdots+\frac{1}{R_n}##
Series: ##R_{eq}=R_1+R_2+\cdots R_n##

The Attempt at a Solution



To start off I can see that at the top and bottom of the circuit the L/2 sections are in series so they add together giving L and then this is in parallel with the ##\frac{L}{\sqrt{2}}## section of the square. Then the equivalent resistance from that is $$\frac{1}{R_{eq}}=\frac{1}{R}+\frac{\sqrt{2}}{R}$$, i.e. $$R_{eq}=\frac{R}{1+\sqrt{2}}$$

Then I obtain the following circuit:

Hand-drawn circuit of a square with a diamond-shaped outer path: X on the left and Y on the right, each joined by two R/2 segments; top and bottom sides labelled R/(1+√2), and the vertical sides labelled R/√2 and R/√2.


At this point I'm currently stuck as I'm not sure how to simplify it further.
 
Use symmetry. Connect a battery to the points X and Y. As the circuit is symmetric to the XY axis, the current from X to A must be the same as from X to B. So The potential drops by the same value from X to A as from X to B. The potential of A is the same as the potential of B, there is no potential difference between A and B, so you can remove the resistor AB, it does not influence the other currents and voltages. Do the same at points C and D, and calculate the resistance of the new circuit.

Circuit schematic: points X, A, C, Y on top and X, B, D, Y below form a symmetric hexagonal network with the vertical wires AB and CD, with a battery connected between X and Y.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Potatochip911
ehild said:
Use symmetry. Connect a battery to the points X and Y. As the circuit is symmetric to the XY axis, the current from X to A must be the same as from X to B. So The potential drops by the same value from X to A as from X to B. The potential of A is the same as the potential of B, there is no potential difference between A and B, so you can remove the resistor AB, it does not influence the other currents and voltages. Do the same at points C and D, and calculate the resistance of the new circuit.

Okay I removed those resistors and then I found the total resistance for the entire circuit to be ##R_{T}=R(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{2+2\sqrt{2}})##

I'm trying to calculate the total resistance with another cube inside of it now, i.e.

Hand-drawn circuit diagram of nested squares: an outer diamond with corners f, X, g, Y, an inner axis-aligned square with corners a, h, j, b, and an innermost diamond with corners d, i, e, c. Terminals X and Y connect to a battery symbol at the bottom, marked + and -.

So we have ##V_a=V_b## and ##V_h=V_i## which allows me to obtain the following circuit:

Hand-drawn circuit schematic: a battery at the bottom connected to a resistor network, with a left and right resistor on the horizontal wires, and a nested square-within-square arrangement of resistors in the middle, with a point labelled X on the left wire.


And I'm once again stuck as to how I should simplify this. I'm not sure how to deal with the diamond of resistors since they are also connected to the resistor at the top/bottom of the box they're enclosed in.
 
What do you think about the resistor pairs
af-fh and bg-gj?
Hand-drawn circuit diagram of nested squares: an outer diamond with corners f, X, g, Y and an inner axis-aligned square with corners a, b, j, d-labelled points; inner diamond c, d, i, e; leads from X and Y go to a battery symbol marked + and - at the bottom.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Potatochip911
Circuit schematic: a resistor network in a hexagonal-looking arrangement with a blue vertical line on the left, a green vertical line in the middle and a red vertical line on the right, connected in series with resistors to a battery at the bottom.

Find more equipotential points. You can connect them with a zero-resistance wire, so they become a single node in the circuit. The colored lines represent such nodes. All four resistors between the blue and green lines are connected - how? and so are those between the green and red lines.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Potatochip911
cnh1995 said:
What do you think about the resistor pairs
af-fh and bg-gj?
Hand-drawn circuit of nested squares: an outer diamond with corners f, X, g, Y and a square with corners a, b, j, d inside it, with a smaller diamond inside labelled c, d, e, i, joined to a battery symbol with + and - at the bottom.

They're in series so they add

ehild said:
View attachment 95124
Find more equipotential points. You can connect them with a zero-resistance wire, so they become a single node in the circuit. The colored lines represent such nodes. All four resistors between the blue and green lines are connected - how? and so are those between the green and red lines.

Ok, I've thought quite a bit about how exactly these resistors are connected and I've come to the conclusion that I should split up the top and bottom resistor in the blue-green node rectangle into two resistors with half of the original resistance. (also I've placed a R/2 resistor at the front to represent the R/2 resistors in parallel at the very start and very end of the circuit).

Hand-drawn circuit schematic: a resistor labelled R/2 in series with a network of resistors R1, R1, R3 in parallel branches, with R2 in the middle branch, followed by a second network of R1, R3, R1 resistors.

In this case ##R_1## is half of the parallel combination af-fh & ah which gives ##R_1=\frac{1}{2}\frac{R}{1+\sqrt{2}}=\frac{R}{2+2\sqrt{2}}## and by symmetry ##R_1=R_3##, from trig the resistance of cd/ce is R/2 and since they're in parallel this gives R/4 for their combination which I've assigned as ##R_2## (the resistor in the middle). Since these resistors are all in parallel and it's the same resistors in parallel twice the resistance from the parallel combination is:
$$\frac{1}{R_{||}}=\frac{2(2+\sqrt{2})}{R}+\frac{4}{R}\Rightarrow R_{||}=\frac{R}{8+4\sqrt{2}}$$

Therefore the total resistance is ##R_{T}=\frac{R}{2}+\frac{R}{8+4\sqrt{2}}##, is this correct?
 
Potatochip911 said:
Therefore the total resistance is ##R_{T}=\frac{R}{2}+\frac{R}{8+4\sqrt{2}}##, is this correct?

Yes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Potatochip911