Road where each section 1/10 of the last section.

  • Thread starter Thread starter andreasdagen
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Section
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a hypothetical road divided into sections, each 1/10 the size of the previous one, starting at one meter, resulting in a total length of 1.111... meters. This scenario is likened to Zeno's paradox, which suggests that one can never reach the end of a distance due to infinite subdivisions. However, participants clarify that despite the infinite sections, the total distance is finite and less than 1.2 meters. The conversation emphasizes that mathematical concepts like convergent series and calculus can resolve the paradox, confirming that one can indeed reach the end of the road. Overall, the topic highlights the intersection of philosophy and mathematics in understanding infinite processes.
andreasdagen
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Imagine having a road that's going straight forward, where each section is 1/10 the size of the last section. The sections would be blue, then red, then blue and so on.

Assuming the size of the first section is one meter, the road would be 1.111... meters repeating.

Each time you drive across a section, there would be another one 1/10 the size so you could never reach the end.

Im just wondering if this has a name and if it would be possible to reach the end of the road.

(im only 15, and I am from norway so sorry for my bad english)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi and welcome.
Of course you can get to the end of the road as it is always shorter than 1.2m, however many sections you add. (It's shorter than 1.11111112 even). Have you looked at Convergent Series in Maths yet?
Your question is like the Zeno[/PLAIN] Paradox (an ancient Greek idea with a flaw that is easy to discover)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the reply :)
 
Note, the road would be 10/9ths of a meter long (10/9 = 1.11111...).
 
Your paradox is similar (although not identical) to Zeno's "first paradox."

http://mathforum.org/isaac/problems/zeno1.html

Zeno was an ancient Greek philosopher, so this problem has a long history! Basically, in order to resolve it you need to use concepts related to calculus and the summation of infinite series. And yes, the runner does reach the end of the road (and Achilles does catch up with the tortoise, etc.).

http://www.mathcs.org/analysis/reals/history/zeno.html

http://www.iep.utm.edu/zeno-par/

A Google search for "Zeno's paradoxes" turns up many pages. Some of them might be simpler than the two listed above.

(Wow, four people got in ahead of me while I was Googling and writing. I think that's a record. :bugeye:)
 
andreasdagen said:
Assuming the size of the first section is one meter, the road would be 1.111... meters repeating.

Some fun with algebra (the mathematicians among us may wish to avert their eyes at this point):

Let ##x## be the length of the road. Now we have:
##x=1.111111...##
##10x=11.111111... ##

## 10x-x= 11.111111... -1.111111... =10 ##

##9x=10 ##
##x=10/9 ##

So the repeating decimal is just a red herring; the road has a perfectly reasonable length and you should be able to traverse it just as if it had any other length. Of course, you still have to deal with Zeno's paradox as the other posters have mentioned; it suggests (incorrectly, of course) that nohing can ever traverse any distance ever.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top