Saturn is diminished and can be put into a PURE water container

AI Thread Summary
Saturn has a low average density of about 0.69 g/cm³, allowing it to float in water with part of its bulk above the water line. If Saturn were diminished and placed in a pure water container, it would not maintain its structure due to its gaseous nature. The discussion clarifies that Saturn's gravity would be minimal in this scenario, preventing significant interaction with the water. The thought experiment highlights the challenges of visualizing Saturn's behavior in a liquid environment. Ultimately, this concept remains theoretical, as Saturn cannot exist in a rigid form suitable for such an experiment.
lwymarie
Messages
89
Reaction score
1
Now imagine the Saturn is diminished and can be put into a PURE water container ..

Then Is that the Saturn is immersed half of itself till the centre of the Saturn ?? (Since Saturn also has gravity itself )
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
What?
.
.
.
 
do you mean Saturn's floating??
well if this is what u mean,
yes
because it has a high density
 
A_I_ said:
do you mean Saturn's floating??
well if this is what u mean,
yes
because it has a high density
No, Saturn has a low density - lower than water. If your bathtub were big enough, you could float Saturn in it.

But I don't know if that's what he/she's asking.
 
hmmm, i don't have a clue what he means but his use of 'the saturn' anoys me the most. just saturn please...
 
sorry AcEY, we don't all have the grasp of the english language that you seem to have...

lwymarie; maybe you could re-phrase your question.
 
sorry for my poor english..
what i mean is: Saturn floats on water. But does it immerse a small part in the water?
 
The question is hard to answer because your question is not clear.

If you shrink Saturn to fit in a container it will have little gravity so it would not affect things. Saturn is made out of gas and is not rigid so it would fall apart in your bathtub. For water to be liquid it needs to be at a high enough temperature to boil away your mini Saturn.

If you mean a rigid sphere with the same density as Saturn it would would on the water, with some part of it submerged.
 
thanks for correcting Dave, i just figured it out after i got back home..
hehe
 
  • #10
Saturn has an average density of about 0.69g/cm^3, which is only 7/10ths that of water. It would float with 3/10ths of its bulk above the water line.

This is, of course, a thought experiment. It can't be done - even in principle - since, as Bjorn points out, it is not a rigid object, but mostly a ball of gas with a dense core. The gravitational forces would intermingle.
 
Back
Top