So, what is the inductor from the extension cord?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter oneamp
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Extension Inductor
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the safety concerns and electrical properties of coiled extension cords, particularly whether they function as inductors and the implications of their design on heat generation and fire risk. Participants explore the concepts of inductance, current flow in multiple conductors, and the thermal characteristics of coiled cables.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that coiling extension cords may lead to fire hazards due to heat buildup, questioning whether inductance plays a role in this phenomenon.
  • Others argue that the arrangement of hot, neutral, and ground conductors in coiled cables results in no net current flow, implying that they do not behave as inductors.
  • A participant notes that coiled cables are bi-filar wound, which they claim leads to negligible inductance.
  • There is mention of thermal cut-outs in modern extension cords, which are designed to prevent overheating when the cords are coiled.
  • Some participants discuss the definition and implications of bifilar winding, noting its use in minimizing leakage inductance in transformers but questioning its relevance to the original inquiry about inductance in extension cords.
  • One participant emphasizes that the magnetic field generated by the current in the conductors does not result in energy storage due to the balanced currents in the hot and neutral wires.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on whether coiled extension cords can be considered inductors and the role of inductance in heat generation. There is no consensus on the significance of inductance in this context, and multiple competing perspectives remain throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations in understanding the thermal dynamics of coiled cables, including the effects of coiling on heat dissipation and the specific conditions under which these cables are used. The discussion also reflects varying interpretations of electrical concepts such as bifilar winding and inductance.

oneamp
Messages
222
Reaction score
0
We used to buy these cheap outlet strips that came with really long wires, wound up. They said to unwind them before use because they caused fires. I thought it was inductance. But now that I think about it, there's not just a single conductor with AC in there. There's also ground and neutral conductors. So, wouldn't those conductors get rid of the energy that the 'hot' conductor is puting into a magnetic field? Also the 'core' of these 'inductors' was simply more extension wire, ran in a loop through the first, outside loop and perpendicularly.

Was it an inductor, or not?

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
oneamp said:
We used to buy these cheap outlet strips that came with really long wires, wound up. They said to unwind them before use because they caused fires. I thought it was inductance. But now that I think about it, there's not just a single conductor with AC in there. There's also ground and neutral conductors. So, wouldn't those conductors get rid of the energy that the 'hot' conductor is puting into a magnetic field? Also the 'core' of these 'inductors' was simply more extension wire, ran in a loop through the first, outside loop and perpendicularly.

Was it an inductor, or not?

Thanks

No, not an inductor. Because the Hot and Neutral are run together, there is no net current in one direction down the cord.

The fire warning may just have been because the wire/cable does not dissipate heat as well when it is all wound up. You shouldn't be running enough current in the cable anyway to get much of a temperature rise. That would be a bad design.
 
I've never seen one catch on fire myself, but I've seen pictures. They are the cheapest made in china stuff that sometimes literally falls apart coming out of the package. I thought it was heat from the wire resistance as well. I just wondered if there was a reactive component to that.

Thanks
 
Cables are rated for Current under free air conditions. Coiling them up in a confined space seriously limits their heat dissipation and the appropriate de-rating should be applied for tightly coiled cable. Manufacturers publish specs to deal with this sort of thing, I believe (and also for routing cables in house insulation materials, these days).
Coiled mains extensions are, effectively, bi-filar wound, so no inductance to speak of.
 
yeah,
I have personally seen several that have melted to an extent that the cable could not be uncoiled
some serious heat buildup

cheers
Dave

EDIT ...
Coiled mains extensions are, effectively, bi-filar wound, so no inductance to speak of.

thank's sophi ... that's the explanation/term I was looking for :smile:
 
davenn said:
yeah,
I have personally seen several that have melted to an extent that the cable could not be uncoiled
some serious heat buildup

cheers
Dave
They mostly have thermal cut-outs incorporated, these days. Annoying if you forget to uncoil the extension lead and plug in a heater - but a lot safer.
 
sophiecentaur said:
Coiled mains extensions are, effectively, bi-filar wound, so no inductance to speak of.

Bifalar winding is used to minimize leakage inductance in pulse/comm transformers, I believe. It does nothing to influence magnetizing inductance, which I think is what the OP's question is about.
 
berkeman said:
Bifalar winding is used to minimize leakage inductance in pulse/comm transformers, I believe. It does nothing to influence magnetizing inductance, which I think is what the OP's question is about.

Unless there is another meaning for bifilar winding, which is certainly possible. At its core, bifilar means to wind 2 conductors together in a magnetic arrangement, so I guess if the 2 conductors carry opposing currents, then your statement is correct. I'm just used to the comm transformer design context, where the 2 wires are primary and secondary windings, so they carry currents in the same direction.
 
I was using the term 'bifilar' in the way I learned it, years ago. An extension lead on a drum is not wound as a transformer. Low inductance resistors are wound ('bifilar') the same way as the conductors on a cable drum.
The transformer in an RCD is also wound 'bifilar', to cancel the effect of balanced currents in L and N.
[edit: reading around this, it's clear that bifilar winding is done to achieve either of two things so we're all correct, in our particular contexts]
 
Last edited:
  • #10
oneamp said:
We used to buy these cheap outlet strips that came with really long wires, wound up. They said to unwind them before use because they caused fires. I thought it was inductance. But now that I think about it, there's not just a single conductor with AC in there. There's also ground and neutral conductors. So, wouldn't those conductors get rid of the energy that the 'hot' conductor is puting into a magnetic field? Also the 'core' of these 'inductors' was simply more extension wire, ran in a loop through the first, outside loop and perpendicularly.

Was it an inductor, or not?

Thanks

I just spotted this and, although it could be looked upon as 'true', there is no more significance in the Field caused by current in the L conductor than that caused by the N current. As it happens, there is no 'Energy' because there is no resultant Field - and it's Fields that add vectorially and not Energies. Any current that flows in the E conductor, due to leakage, could be in either direction; the important thing is that the sum of the three currents is zero (unless there is another path to Earth) .

The material of the drum etc (what would be the 'core' material is not important because the H field is zero). Just as well, because drums and frames are often made of steel for strength.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 79 ·
3
Replies
79
Views
7K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K