Solution of silver ions turning amber

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the creation of silver ion solutions through electrolysis with silver electrodes in distilled water. Initially clear, the solution turns amber over time, prompting inquiries into the underlying chemistry. Theories suggest that the amber color may result from the reduction of Ag+ ions to neutral silver atoms, which absorb light, or from the oxidation of silver to silver oxides. The addition of NaCl leads to AgCl precipitation, confirming the presence of Ag+ ions. The role of adding a strong base, such as NaOH, is debated, with some suggesting it could produce silver hydroxide that reacts with oxygen to form silver oxide, potentially deepening the amber color. The possibility of spontaneous reduction of cations and the formation of silver carbonate due to CO2 absorption is also mentioned. Overall, the conversation reflects a mix of practical experimentation and theoretical exploration regarding the behavior of silver ions in solution.
cnidocyte
Messages
34
Reaction score
0
I've been making solutions of silver ions by hooking 20-30V up to 2 silver electrodes in distilled water and noticed something interesting. The solution starts off as clear and by adding a bit of NaCl, AgCl precipitates out so there's definitely Ag+ ions in there. If I leave the solution for a few days it turns amber coloured. This is the colour
IMAG0177.jpg

whats going on here? I haven't bothered to retest for Ag+ ions but the only theory I've come up with is that the Ag+ ions have been reduced somehow and neutral Ag atoms absorb some light.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Hmm, I'm not sure, but it's likely that it is related to the formation of silver oxides. Add some base and see if the color deepens.
 
Photochemical reduction of the AgCl back to nanoparticles of silver, maybe?
 
Acut: I added NaOH but no color change at all.

minerva: Solutions with no AgCl turn amber.

Oxidation to Ag2O is the best theory so far IMO. I did read that silver nano particles absorb some wavelengths of light and the result is an amber color though so I wonder if the cations could be getting reduced somehow. Does that kinda thing occur? Spontaneous reduction of cations. Enough theorizing though I'll just add some NaCl and look for AgCl precipitate.
 
Hm, I think it's not Ag2O.
Addition of strong base to Ag+ solutions produces silver hydroxide, which, in turn, reacts with oxygen from the air to form the oxide. So addition of silver hydroxide would either deepen the collor or produce more of this amber-collored compound.

I'm not a silver expert, however.
 
Acut said:
Addition of strong base to Ag+ solutions produces silver hydroxide, which, in turn, reacts with oxygen from the air to form the oxide.

Try to write reaction equation.
 
I'd guess this,

2Ag(OH) + O2 -> Ag2O + 2OH-

But I've only read its description, never saw its chemical equation.
 
So you are electrolyzing in distilled water, eh? Not very efficient, at least at first. It is likely that CO2 is being absorbed into the solution and you are making small amounts of silver carbonate.
At 20 to 30 V you are certainly hydrolyzing water as well so your solution and your silver electrodes have oxygen present as well as the reducing hydrogen gas. Hydrogen gas can react with silver to produce silver hydride which can be a variety of colors from red to black.
 
Acut said:
I'd guess this,

2Ag(OH) + O2 -> Ag2O + 2OH-

Check if it can be balanced.
 
  • #10
@Borek: Hm, I never realized that!

But I'm sure I read about this reaction.

It's amazing how much I learn with your posts!
 
  • #11
In short - Ag+ was already oxidized, it doesn't change its oxidation state, so it doesn't need oxidizer.

--
 
Back
Top