A Solving an Equation: Overcoming the r's

  • A
  • Thread starter Thread starter mhirschb
  • Start date Start date
mhirschb
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I feel silly but I've been looking at this equation for a while and I don't fully understand the individual steps taken to go from the top line to the bottom line:
MVP theta component.png


I think I am getting caught up with all the r's in the equation. I recognize that on the second line "r" describes the point at which we are evaluating the MVP, and r' is the domain of r that we're integrating over.
I'm confused because it looks like they've taken the 1/r and changed it to r' on the other side.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The first equation obtains B_z from A_\theta bythe following steps:
  • Multiply by r.
  • Differentiate with respect to r.
  • Divide by r.

Therefore A_\theta is obtained from B_z by reversing these steps:
  • Multiply by r.
  • Integrate with respect to r. This is done as a definite integral with lower limit 0, because any other choice of lower limit would make A_\theta potentially infinite at r = 0. This definite integration requires the introduction of r' as a dummy variable of integration, because it is bad practise to use r as both a limit of the integral and the dummy variable of integration.
  • Divide by r.
 
pasmith said:
The first equation obtains B_z from A_\theta bythe following steps:
  • Multiply by r.
  • Differentiate with respect to r.
  • Divide by r.

Therefore A_\theta is obtained from B_z by reversing these steps:
  • Multiply by r.
  • Integrate with respect to r. This is done as a definite integral with lower limit 0, because any other choice of lower limit would make A_\theta potentially infinite at r = 0. This definite integration requires the introduction of r' as a dummy variable of integration, because it is bad practise to use r as both a limit of the integral and the dummy variable of integration.
  • Divide by r.
Ah! It makes so much sense now I wanna facepalm!

Thank you for the explanation. It became clear when I needed to introduce the dummy variable r'.
 
Are there any good visualization tutorials, written or video, that show graphically how separation of variables works? I particularly have the time-independent Schrodinger Equation in mind. There are hundreds of demonstrations out there which essentially distill to copies of one another. However I am trying to visualize in my mind how this process looks graphically - for example plotting t on one axis and x on the other for f(x,t). I have seen other good visual representations of...
Back
Top