Solving Basic Circuit Problem: Find Voltage Across 10 Ohm Resistor

  • Topic: Engineering 
  • Thread starter Magnawolf
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circuit
4 replies · 2K views · last reply
Magnawolf
Messages
25
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Circuit schematic with a 90 V source on the left feeding a ladder of resistors labelled 30, 60, 10, 30 and 20 ohms, with the 10 ohm resistor marked with a + and - voltage polarity.


Find voltage across 10 ohm resistor.

Homework Equations



Ohm's law

The Attempt at a Solution



20 // 30 = 12
30 // 60 = 20

That's as far as I can get. The answer is 14.286.
 
While the 20 and 30 Ohm resistors are in parallel, the 30 and 60 Ohm resistors are not (the voltage source intervenes).

You'll need to pull out some circuit analysis method. There are several choices. What methods have you studied so far?
 
Two circuit schematics with a double arrow between them: left, a 90 V source with resistors 30, 60, 10 and 20 ohms; right, a current source with 20 and 12 ohm resistors and a 10 ohm resistor, followed by worked equations 20||30 = 12 ohms, 60||30 = 20 ohms, and voltage 14.286 V.


Here's the solution to the problem.

It looks like the book did source transformation, which I didn't think was fair because this problem is before source transformation.

I know nodal analysis and mesh but I thought it was possible to do without them. I thought you could just find the R-total and then you could find the total current. I guess not?
 
Magnawolf said:
Two circuit schematics joined by a double arrow, followed by typed working: 20||30 = 12 ohms, 60||30 = 20 ohms, i_o = [20/(22+20)]3 = 60/42, v_x1 = 10i_o = 600/42 = 14.286 V.


Here's the solution to the problem.

It looks like the book did source transformation, which I didn't think was fair because this problem is before source transformation.
Yup, they did a source transformation (Norton) and then current division.

I know nodal analysis and mesh but I thought it was possible to do without them. I thought you could just find the R-total and then you could find the total current. I guess not?
You need more than simple resistor network reductions (parallel/serial) here. Nodal analysis would be a good choice.