Speed of car related to momentum

[songoku]

Homework Statement

A 1000 kg car with 4 people on it, each 75 kg, is at rest. The people jump off the car with speed 2 ms^-1 relative to the car. Find the speed of the car if the people jump off :

a. simultaneously
b. one by one

Homework Equations

conservation of momentum

The Attempt at a Solution

a.
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 300 * 2 - 1000 * v₂

v₂ = 0.6 ms^-1b.
(i) when person 1 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * 2 - 1225 * v₂

v₂ = 6/49 ms^-1

(ii) when person 2 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 6/49) - 1150 * v₂

v₂ = 156/1127 ms^-1

(iii) when person 3 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 156/1127) - 1075 * v₂

v₂ = 7230/48461 ms^-1

(iv) when person 4 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 7230/48461) - 1000*v₂

v₂ = 0.161 ms^-1

I calculated this with respect to the car. Do I get it right? For this kind of question, what should be taken as the reference, the car or the ground?

ThanksEDIT : I just realized my mistake. The reference should be ground and when person 2, 3 and 4 jump off one by one, there should be initial momentum relative to the ground. I'll amend my calculation in the next post

 

[songoku]

a. the answer is still the same

b. assume the car moves to the left and the person jumps off to the right
(i) when person 1 jumps off :
0 = 75 * 2 - 1225 * v₂

v₂ = 6/49 ms^-1

(ii) when person 2 jumps off :
-(75 * 6/49) - 1225 * 6/49 = 75 * (2 + 6/49) - 1150 * v₂

v₂ = 312/1127 ms^-1

(iii)when person 3 jumps off :
- 75*312/1127 - 1150 * 312/1127 = 75*(2 + 312/1127) - 1075 * v₂

v₂ = 0.474 ms^-1

(iv)when person 4 jumps off :
- 75 * 0.474 - 1075 * 0.474 = 75 * (2 + 0.474) - 1000 * v₂

v₂ = 0.73 ms^-1

So the final speed of the car = 0.73 ms^-1

Do I get it right? Thanks

 

[songoku]

Sorry fo bumping...

Can someone please check my work? Thanks

 

[dr_k]

b. assume the car moves to the left and the person jumps off to the right
(i) when person 1 jumps off :
0 = 75 * 2 - 1225 * v₂

v₂ = 6/49 ms^-1

I agree with this part. Here's my picture (jumping off to the left):
http://img695.imageshack.us/img695/9197/mv1.jpg

(ii) when person 2 jumps off :
-(75 * 6/49) - 1225 * 6/49 = 75 * (2 + 6/49) - 1150 * v₂

v₂ = 312/1127 ms^-1

(iii)when person 3 jumps off :
- 75*312/1127 - 1150 * 312/1127 = 75*(2 + 312/1127) - 1075 * v₂

v₂ = 0.474 ms^-1

(iv)when person 4 jumps off :
- 75 * 0.474 - 1075 * 0.474 = 75 * (2 + 0.474) - 1000 * v₂

v₂ = 0.73 ms^-1

So the final speed of the car = 0.73 ms^-1

Do I get it right? Thanks

I don't agree with these. My picture, for part (ii) is,
http://img246.imageshack.us/img246/6475/mv2q.jpg

when I use a frame at rest, although, it would be easier to make a new inertial frame for each jump, that moves at the constant speed of the previous jump. Basically, you can use a frame at rest to get \rm V_1, then a frame moving at \rm V_1 to get \rm V_2,...etc.

The jumpers each give \rm \frac{mv}{3m+M}, \rm \frac{mv}{2m+M}, \rm \frac{mv}{m+M}, and \rm \frac{mv}{M} respectiviely, which can be summed to find the final speed.

 

[songoku]

Hi dr_k

So for the case when person 2 jumps off, the equation should be (based on your picture):

(3*75 + 1000) * 6/49 = - (2 - 6/49) * 75 + 1150 * V₂ ??


And I don't understand about this part "it would be easier to make a new inertial frame for each jump, that moves at the constant speed of the previous jump. Basically, you can use a frame at rest to get V₁ , then a frame moving at V₁ to get V₂, ... etc"

Can you please explain more? Thanks

 

[dr_k]

Hi dr_k

So for the case when person 2 jumps off, the equation should be (based on your picture):

(3*75 + 1000) * 6/49 = - (2 - 6/49) * 75 + 1150 * V₂ ??

Yep. Drawing the picture is 1/2 the problem.

And I don't understand about this part "it would be easier to make a new inertial frame for each jump, that moves at the constant speed of the previous jump. Basically, you can use a frame at rest to get V₁ , then a frame moving at V₁ to get V₂, ... etc"

Can you please explain more? Thanks

Well, solving for \rm V_2, in the second picture, gives \rm V_2 = V_1 + \frac{m v}{2 m + M}, where \rm V_1 = \frac{m v}{3 m + M}. Basically the objects in the the (i) initial and (f) final picture are all traveling at \rm V_1. Instead of carrying these terms, you could just make an inertial frame moving at constant speed \rm V_1, and then remember to sum up the speed of the frames at the end. For example, the second picture above now looks like

http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/4534/frames1.jpg

This frame says \rm V' = \frac{m v}{2 m + M}. To get the speed for an observer at rest, just add \rm V_1 + V' . Now do this as many times as required to get all four masses off.

 

[songoku]

Hi dr_k

Maybe I get your point. I'll try it first. Thanks a lot !

 

[dr_k]

Homework Statement

A 1000 kg car with 4 people on it, each 75 kg, is at rest. The people jump off the car with speed 2 ms^-1 relative to the car. Find the speed of the car if the people jump off :

a. simultaneously
b. one by one

Homework Equations

conservation of momentum

The Attempt at a Solution

a.
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 300 * 2 - 1000 * v₂

v₂ = 0.6 ms^-1


b.
(i) when person 1 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * 2 - 1225 * v₂

v₂ = 6/49 ms^-1

(ii) when person 2 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 6/49) - 1150 * v₂

v₂ = 156/1127 ms^-1

(iii) when person 3 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 156/1127) - 1075 * v₂

v₂ = 7230/48461 ms^-1

(iv) when person 4 jumps off :
m₁u₁ + m₂u₂ = m₁V₁ + m₂V₂

0 = 75 * (2 + 7230/48461) - 1000*v₂

v₂ = 0.161 ms^-1

I calculated this with respect to the car. Do I get it right? For this kind of question, what should be taken as the reference, the car or the ground?

Thanks


EDIT : I just realized my mistake. The reference should be ground and when person 2, 3 and 4 jump off one by one, there should be initial momentum relative to the ground. I'll amend my calculation in the next post

Good Morning Songoku,

I was just looking at this problem, and I noticed that I didn't read the problem carefully enough. There is a subtle point that I neglected. The problem states "The people jump off the car with speed 2 ms^-1 relative to the car". Relative to the car implies that I missed something. In part "(a) a. simultaneously", the picture should look like this:

http://img18.imageshack.us/img18/4534/frames1.jpg

This picture correctly shows both 4m and M moving with \rm V_1, and therefore v is "relative" to the car.

This implies

\rm 0 = M V_1 - 4m (v-V_1)

so

\rm V_1 = \frac{4mv}{M+4m} .

Putting the numbers in gives \rm V_1 = .4615 m/s for part (a).

Give me a few minutes, and I'll write something up for part (b).

 

[dr_k]

For part (b):

http://img688.imageshack.us/img688/7726/frames2.jpg

Here v is "relative" to the car, and we get

\rm V_1 = \frac{mv}{4m+M}

Now I make a new inertial frame, moving in a straight line at constant speed \rm V_1 ,

http://img708.imageshack.us/img708/8674/frames3.jpg

where

\rm V_2 = \frac{mv}{3m+M}

Do this two more times, with new inertial frames, to get the last two masses off. The final speed of the car is therefore

\rm V_{car} = V_1+V_2+V_3+V_4 = \frac{mv}{4m+M}+\frac{mv}{3m+M}+\frac{mv}{2m+M}+\frac{mv}{m+M} = .5078 m/s

 

[songoku]

Hi dr k

Ah I see my mistake for neglecting "relative" . Thanks !

 

[dr_k]

Hi dr k

Ah I see my mistake for neglecting "relative" . Thanks !

I missed it as well! But I think we've got it covered now.