Suggestion for stickied thread in Science Book Forum

  • Thread starter Thread starter Petek
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
A suggestion has been made to create a stickied thread in the Science Book Discussion forum to compile links to free and legal science and math book downloads, specifically from sites like FreeBookCentre.net and e-booksdirectory.com. While many members support the idea, there are concerns about potential copyright violations and the need for moderation to ensure only legitimate resources are shared. Some participants propose that members could contribute their own links, but there is caution against allowing unrestricted posting to prevent spam and illegal content. The discussion highlights the importance of verifying the legality of the resources before including them in the thread. Overall, the creation of a stickied thread is seen as beneficial, provided it is managed carefully to maintain quality and legality.
Petek
Gold Member
Messages
405
Reaction score
37
I'd like to suggest the creation of a thread in the Science Book Discussion forum, which would then be stickied. I know of two sites that contain free and legal downloads of science and math books. They are FreeBookCentre.net and e-booksdirectory.com (science subsection). I'm only familiar with the math books on these sites. Most appear to be high in quality, written by professional mathematicians. Some are exact copies of published works for which the author received permission to post online. I sometimes direct other members to these sites. It would be convenient to simply have a thread on your site to point to.

If this idea has merit, I'll volunteer to create a new thread, which could then be stickied by a mod. Or, if you want to preview my post, I could post the proposed text here.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm for it if we can get some more member nominations for this. Also try to dig up a few more good resources. thanks!
 
I'm all for it. These are some great mathematics references! Maybe make a stickied thread such that all members are allowed to add their own sites with free books? Because there are much more good sites out there!
 
I'm for it. And thus, my vote is cast.
 
i'll take any help i can get.
 
micromass said:
I'm all for it. These are some great mathematics references! Maybe make a stickied thread such that all members are allowed to add their own sites with free books? Because there are much more good sites out there!
I would be against allowing *anyone* to post a link to "free downloads" due to copyright violation. I just had to delete a spammer that linked to sites with illegal free downloads.

I've only checked one site the OP listed and only checked two books, and they were legally available through a "Creative Commons license", even though they are copyrighted books. Unfortunately, the site did not provide the necessary link to CC, I had to trace them from different sources. I'm assuming the site is using CC or similarly licensed books.
 
I suppose you're right, Evo. We shouldn't of course list sites that have potential copyright violations. But there are a lot of sites out there that just link to lecture notes and would potentially be good.

For example, http://hbpms.blogspot.com/ is a site I link to a lot, it contains links to good places and good (legal) books. It are these kind of sites that I'd like to see links to.

Don't know about the sites of the OP though, the first sites looks legit, but I do have some doubts about the second site that he lists...
 
Evo said:
I would be against allowing *anyone* to post a link to "free downloads" due to copyright violation. I just had to delete a spammer that linked to sites with illegal free downloads.

micromass said:
I suppose you're right, Evo. We shouldn't of course list sites that have potential copyright violations.

I believe the Sticky is a good idea but wonder if PMing a mentor with the "book link" so they could check it out would be something the mentor would want to take on with all their other "duties".
 
Well, I wouldn't want to link to any sites that might be problematic. If a mod wishes to delete the links in my first post, please feel free to do so.
 
  • #10
Petek said:
Well, I wouldn't want to link to any sites that might be problematic. If a mod wishes to delete the links in my first post, please feel free to do so.
Your links are great, much appreciated!
 
  • #11
Can you set it so that a certain number of posts are required before you can put links in that thread? That should eliminate link spammers.
 

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
6K
Back
Top