Temperature Outside Without Thermometer

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the question of how to determine the temperature outside without using a thermometer. Participants explore various methods, formulas, and creative approaches to estimate temperature, touching on both theoretical and practical aspects.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that measuring other indicators, such as the color of the ground or the behavior of animals, could provide temperature estimates.
  • One participant humorously notes that using a thermometer indirectly, such as asking someone else to measure, is still a valid approach.
  • There are mentions of using crickets' chirping as a temperature indicator, referencing a specific formula related to their behavior.
  • Several participants argue that all proposed methods essentially function as thermometers, albeit unconventional ones, and emphasize the definition of a thermometer as a device for measuring temperature.
  • Creative suggestions include observing a cat's behavior as a temperature gauge and using a weather rock as a playful indicator of temperature conditions.
  • One participant raises the idea of measuring indoor temperature and calculating the temperature gradient to infer outdoor temperature, though acknowledging the limitations of this method.
  • Discussion includes a reference to the color change of cobalt chloride paper as a temperature indicator, linking chemistry to temperature measurement.
  • Some participants express skepticism about the effectiveness of the proposed methods, suggesting that they may not yield accurate results.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that determining temperature without a thermometer is challenging and that many suggested methods are unconventional thermometers. However, there is no consensus on the validity or accuracy of the various approaches discussed.

Contextual Notes

Some methods proposed rely on subjective interpretations or indirect measurements, which may introduce uncertainty. The discussion highlights the need for more specific information to refine the question posed.

Chris914
Messages
6
Reaction score
1
Is there a way to determine the temperature outside without using a thermometer? Any formulas I could use?
 
Science news on Phys.org
It's a bit like asking if there's a formula for how tall something is,

You just have to go and measure it.
(Maybe there are other things you could measure, and apply a formula to, that would tell you. I don't know much thermodynamics though. Is this what you were asking?)
 
You could look at the ground - if it is sort-of whitish, then the temperature estimate is "cold" and if it is totally white then it is "very cold". OTOH if it is glowing orange, then it is "very hot".

You could put your hand on the window for a bit, then plunge it in bioling (or freezing) water - ans so estimate the temperature on a pain pain scale. As in: "It is excruciatingly cold today... but not as excruciating as it was 10mins ago can someone call me an ambulance thanks."

I suppose: you could use a spectrometer and point it at an object outside - the spectrum is related to the temperature.

Part of the point of PF is to help people learn to talk to scientists.
In science, any device (or combination of devices) which is used to find out the temperature of something is called a "thermometer". That is what the word means.

So you have pretty much asked if there is a thermometer that is not a thermometer...

But if you mean to ask if there is a way of determining the temperature without measuring something, the answer is "no".
 
Simon Bridge said:
You mean: get someone else to use the thermometer?

I thought you pretty much covered all of the other options, and I couldn't resist.
 
Chris914 said:
Is there a way to determine the temperature outside without using a thermometer? Any formulas I could use?

Are you allowed to use a thermometer indoors? Do you know anything about the insulation properties of the building?

Perhaps you could measure the power required to keep the inside at say 20C and calculate the implied temperature gradient. It wouldn't be very accurate because heat loss also depends on wind and solar gain.
 
Chris914 said:
Is there a way to determine the temperature outside without using a thermometer? Any formulas I could use?

Do you have access to any crickets? There's a formula you could use if you have chirping crickets.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cricket_(insect)
 
Last edited:
  • #10
  • #11
TumblingDice said:
I thought you pretty much covered all of the other options, and I couldn't resist.
... I'm just amazed nobody has suggested using a barometer.

There is also watching a sleeping cat - the tighter it curls the colder it is.
Unless it's trying to psyche you out and wants you to think it's cold...

(If the cats look like Dahli clocks, then it is pretty warm.)

There is looking at a calendar and estimating the outside temperature via a table of mean seasonal variations.
That would be - taking advantage of the fact that others have used thermometers for a long time.
 
  • #12
I've heard that the colour of blotting paper soaked and dried in a solution mixture of cobalt chloride and sodium chloride, depends on temperature. Much of chemistry in gen. phy.
 
  • #13
By definition, a thermometer is a device used to measure temperatures. It is therefore impossible to determine a temperature without using a thermometer, although perhaps not a conventional one. All of the suggestions above are just different (and more or less precise) thermometers. I particularly fancy the cat-thermometer, even though it would seem to me that it would require extensive calibration before use.
 
  • #14
Orodruin said:
By definition, a thermometer is a device used to measure temperatures. It is therefore impossible to determine a temperature without using a thermometer, although perhaps not a conventional one. All of the suggestions above are just different (and more or less precise) thermometers. I particularly fancy the cat-thermometer, even though it would seem to me that it would require extensive calibration before use.

It also depends on how fat the cat is. Fat cats tend to be more content and feel less need to curl tightly, even if it is cold. They are also less reliable because they are often off at the bank counting their money.
 
  • #15
All of the suggestions above are just different (and more or less precise) thermometers.
... or a way of getting someone else to use the thermometer.

I suspect this observation will be made several more times before the thread finally peters out.
Anyone suggested turning on the radio or the TV?

There's also a varient of the weather rock - if it has snow on it, it's "cold" and if it is melting, it's "hot".

To tell the temperature outside without going outside: put the thermometer outside and watch it through a window... if you mean not to use a thermometer like you get in a store, then use a thermometer you didn;t get in a store, and if you mean not to use the thermometer yoursef then get someone else to do it.

I think that covers all the bases.

An enormous amount of science lies in asking the question - once a question is asked properly, most of them are automatically answered. As written, the problem is under-specified - more information needed. I could have just put that at the start but that would have been boring.
 
  • #16
Simon Bridge said:
if you mean not to use a thermometer like you get in a store, then use a thermometer you didn;t get in a store.

As written, the problem is under-specified - more information needed. I could have just put that at the start but that would have been boring.

:smile:
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 0 ·
Replies
0
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
866
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K