Testing Relativity: Spinning in Space - Feasible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jreelawg
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Space Spinning
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the feasibility of testing relativity and time dilation by spinning a clock in the vacuum of space at high speeds. Participants express skepticism about whether such an experiment could yield meaningful results, noting that even extreme spinning may not exceed the speeds of rockets. Concerns about the structural integrity of the spinning object are raised, with the potential for catastrophic failure due to centrifugal forces. Some participants reference existing experiments related to relativity, suggesting that similar concepts have been explored before. Overall, the idea remains intriguing but faces significant practical challenges.
jreelawg
Messages
125
Reaction score
0
I was thinking about ways to test relativity, and time dilation.

The idea popped in my head of designing something, housing a clock, with the intention of getting it to spin in the vacuum of space, as fast as possible, and observe the difference in time.

Is this feasible? Has this been done before?

Aside from the relativity aspect, I just thought it would be cool to see how fast we could spin something.

I imagine a skinny cylinder, with receiving antennas at each end, powered by microwaves beamed into it from separate power sources. I'm not sure what type of propulsion would be used.

Has this been done before? What is the artificial RPM world record?

Also, what is the fastest know natural spinning object in space?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
hi jreelawg! :smile:
jreelawg said:
I was thinking about ways to test relativity, and time dilation.

The idea popped in my head of designing something, housing a clock, with the intention of getting it to spin in the vacuum of space, as fast as possible, and observe the difference in time.

how would this test relativity? :confused:

the only relevant parameter is the speed, and even if you could spin it 1,000 times a second with a diameter of a metre, that still wouldn't be any faster than a rocket

plus … won't very accurate clocks get dyspepsia if you treat them like that? :redface:
 
tiny-tim said:
hi jreelawg! :smile:


how would this test relativity? :confused:

the only relevant parameter is the speed, and even if you could spin it 1,000 times a second with a diameter of a metre, that still wouldn't be any faster than a rocket

plus … won't very accurate clocks get dyspepsia if you treat them like that? :redface:

I had the idea that in space, you could get an object to spin much faster than a rocket. Two things are in your favor for in this case. First, you can use a nearby power source, and observe the object. This means, that you could keep it accelerating until it becomes impossible, at which point I would guess is a very extreme velocity.

Can you tell me why you think we could not spin an object in space fast enough to test relativity?
 
jreelawg said:
an you tell me why you think we could not spin an object in space fast enough to test relativity?

i think it would fall apart :redface:
 
tiny-tim said:
i think it would fall apart :redface:

Exactly. Spinning an object too fast, in space or on earth, can and will cause catastrophic centrifugal instability and a potentially lethal environment from high velocity fragments of the breakdown.
 
jreelawg said:
I was thinking about ways to test relativity, and time dilation.

The idea popped in my head of designing something, housing a clock, with the intention of getting it to spin in the vacuum of space, as fast as possible, and observe the difference in time.

Is this feasible? Has this been done before?

Sort of:

http://einstein.stanford.edu/
 
Nice read Andy. Also nice web site. Had not been there before.
 
Back
Top