Other Textbook reviews online somewhere?

  • Thread starter Thread starter blue_leaf77
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Review Textbook
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around finding reliable online reviews for college physics textbooks. Participants suggest using Amazon for reviews, although some express frustration with the limited number of reviews for specific titles. Recommendations include consulting university reading lists for required texts and using forum search features to find discussions on particular books. Key titles mentioned include Feynman's Lectures on Physics, Kolenkow and Kleppner, and Purcell, which are considered essential for a physics library. One user notes the challenge of finding reviews for specialized topics and shares a link to a site dedicated to textbook reviews. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the importance of community input and existing resources for making informed textbook purchases.
blue_leaf77
Science Advisor
Messages
2,637
Reaction score
786
Is there some kind of online site where I can find reviews about college textbooks (preferably physics related) out there? I am considering to have my own collection of books in my field of research but I don't want to spend my savings on something I will find myself disappointed later.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Shyan said:
Thanks, but I know this since long time. However sometimes the number of reviews for a given book is too small and sometimes no review at all.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not really a particular place on school textbooks, unless your say an english major, then those books have been discussed by a lot of people. The best thing to do, is ask on this forum or look at university required books. There should be a list of reading material for a particular major.

Say you want to learn linear algebra (second course), then most schools will list Friedberg, Kenneth, or Axler.
 
I would recommended Feynmans Lectures on Physics, Kolenkow and Kleppner, and Purcell as a must have library. Not a physics major, but I own KK and Feynman, there really good stuff.
 
Have you tried the forum search feature at the top right of this page? If you have a specific book in mind, enter the author's name and see if it's been discussed here before. If you enter something like "thermodynamics", you'll get many threads about thermodynamics books.
 
For mathematics there are also MAA Reviews.
 
MidgetDwarf said:
I would recommended Feynmans Lectures on Physics, Kolenkow and Kleppner, and Purcell as a must have library.
Thanks for the recommendation, but I am planing to have a collection of textbooks in my field of interest only. I currently have no intention in collecting basic physics textbooks. Besides I think there is a free online version of Feynman's lecture series.
jtbell said:
Have you tried the forum search feature at the top right of this page? If you have a specific book in mind, enter the author's name and see if it's been discussed here before. If you enter something like "thermodynamics", you'll get many threads about thermodynamics books.
I'm afraid most of these books will be of specialized topics that it's difficult to find a member here who has had the interest on one of these books as well. I also have searched in this forum but return no result.
After some search I ended up in this link http://textbooks-online-review.toptenreviews.com/. It appears that Amazon.com is the best place to find a book's review.
 
Kolenkow and Purcell are not basics by any means.
 
Back
Top