Intro Physics Textbooks on Optics: Alternatives to Hetch-Zajac's "Optics"

AI Thread Summary
Students seeking alternatives to Hetch-Zajac's "Optics" often cite its verbosity and scattered information as drawbacks, making it challenging to assimilate key concepts. Recommended alternatives include Pohl's "Introduction to Physics," Guenther's "Modern Optics," and Goodman's "Fourier Optics," with many emphasizing the importance of foundational texts like Gaskill's work on linear systems. Additionally, "Vibrations and Waves" by A.P. French is noted for its clear discussions on interference and diffraction. A free online resource is also available, aimed at senior undergraduates, which includes comprehensive derivations and examples. These alternatives provide a more accessible approach to the topics of interference, diffraction, coherence, and modern optics.
Sokolov
Messages
14
Reaction score
1
I'm looking for an alternative textbook to the Hetch-Zajac's one. I am a physics undergraduate student, and this is the recommended book for the subject, so I would like to find a book that covers more or less the same topics.

There are two main problems I find at Hetch:
  1. Firstly, its extreme verbosity, which often makes it very heavy to read. It tends to wander off and get lost in the details.
  2. On the other hand, and especially, I find annoying how scattered is all the information it includes. A greater synthesis of the information would help a lot to assimilate the contents. A couple of tables summarizing the main formulas, for example, would be welcome.
I am particularly interested in themes 9, 10, 12 and 13 of the fifth edition: interference, diffraction, coherence and modern optics.

Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I had the exact same impression of Hecht's book when I was a student. Here are some recommendations - pick which ever work for you or are available.

Pohl's Introduction to Physics: Volume 2: Electrodynamics and Optics by Pohl (& Pohl)
Modern Optics by Robert D. Guenther
Handbook of Optics Volume 1 of 3rd edition
Introduction to Statistical Optics by Edward L. O'Neill
Introduction to Nonlinear Optics by Geoffrey New
 
  • Like
Likes Sokolov
Of course there's also the all-time classic by Born and Wolf.
 
  • Like
Likes PhDeezNutz and Sokolov
If this is your first foray into optics, Born and Wolf isn't the book to learn from.
 
Born and Wolf might be the hardest book to read I ever had. There's good stuff in there, but it's better as a reference when all else has failed, IMO.

If you really want to learn about diffraction and interference, I would go with Goodman's Fourier Optics book.
 
DaveE said:
Born and Wolf might be the hardest book to read I ever had. There's good stuff in there, but it's better as a reference when all else has failed, IMO.

If you really want to learn about diffraction and interference, I would go with Goodman's Fourier Optics book.
Before reading Goodman's book, read and work through Gaskill's book on Linear Systems and Optics, unless you have a very strong linear systems background.
 
  • Like
Likes deskswirl, Sokolov and DaveE
Hecht and Zajac were my professors in graduate school - they're both as scatterbrained as the book is!
 
  • Haha
Likes berkeman
DaveE said:
If you really want to learn about diffraction and interference, I would go with Goodman's Fourier Optics book.
I never really understood Fourier Optics until I read Voelz's Computational Fourier Optics.
 
alantheastronomer said:
Hecht and Zajac were my professors in graduate school - they're both as scatterbrained as the book is!
But an excellent, comprehensive and comprehensible discussion of interference and diffraction and Fourier transforms can be found in "Vibrations and Waves" by A.P. French MIT Press...
 
  • Like
Likes PhDeezNutz
  • #10
A free alternative is available here:

https://optics.byu.edu/textbook

I'm an author of the book, so I can't give unbiased assessment of the material (but I have no financial interest as we allow free use). We try to give clear derivations and examples and regularly update the book. It has a math review at the beginning, and is targeted at a senior undergraduate level.

M. Ware
 
  • Like
Likes robphy and andresB
Back
Top