Textbooks that cover momentum before force?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the sequence in which momentum and force are introduced in physics textbooks, specifically questioning the approach of presenting momentum first and then defining force as the rate of change of momentum (F = dp/dt). Concerns are raised about the applicability of this definition, particularly since it is only valid for systems with constant mass, which may limit its effectiveness as a foundational concept. The conversation references the complexities involved in scenarios like the rocket problem, where mass changes over time. Additionally, there is curiosity about whether most physics texts typically introduce force before momentum, suggesting a preference for a more generalizable approach in teaching these concepts.
Geremia
Messages
150
Reaction score
0
Which textbooks cover momentum first and then study force F=\dot{p} as it relates to momentum? Cf. this Physics StackExchange post and thread. Thanks
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Since that form of Newton's second law is only valid for constant mass systems, I would think its not a great starting point. Is there any good reason to use this definition despite the loss of generality?
 
madness said:
Since that form of Newton's second law is only valid for constant mass systems, I would think its not a great starting point.
Are you referring to issues like the rocket problem?
madness said:
Is there any good reason to use this definition despite the loss of generality?
Do most texts introduce force first?

Thanks
 
For the following four books, has anyone used them in a course or for self study? Compiler Construction Principles and Practice 1st Edition by Kenneth C Louden Programming Languages Principles and Practices 3rd Edition by Kenneth C Louden, and Kenneth A Lambert Programming Languages 2nd Edition by Allen B Tucker, Robert E Noonan Concepts of Programming Languages 9th Edition by Robert W Sebesta If yes to either, can you share your opinions about your personal experience using them. I...
Hi, I have notice that Ashcroft, Mermin and Wei worked at a revised edition of the original solid state physics book (here). The book, however, seems to be never available. I have also read that the reason is related to some disputes related to copyright. Do you have any further information about it? Did you have the opportunity to get your hands on this revised edition? I am really curious about it, also considering that I am planning to buy the book in the near future... Thanks!
This is part 2 of my thread Collection of Free Online Math Books and Lecture Notes Here, we will consider physics and mathematical methods for physics resources. Now, this is a work in progress. Please feel free comment regarding items you want to be included, or if a link is broken etc. Note: I will not post links to other collections, each link will point you to a single item. :book:📚📒 [FONT=trebuchet ms]Introductory college/university physics College Physics, Openstax...

Similar threads

Replies
47
Views
5K
Replies
34
Views
6K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
7K
Back
Top