MHB The Chain Rule for Multivariable Vector-Valued Functions .... ....

[Math Amateur]

I am reading Tom M Apostol's book "Mathematical Analysis" (Second Edition) ...I am focused on Chapter 12: Multivariable Differential Calculus ... and in particular on Section 12.9: The Chain Rule ... ...I need help in order to fully understand Theorem 12.7, Section 12.9 ...Theorem 12.7 (including its proof) reads as follows:
View attachment 8523
View attachment 8524
In the proof of Theorem 12.7 we read the following:

" ... ... Using (14) in (15) we find$$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + f'(b) [ \| y \| E_a(y) ] + \|v \| E_b(v) $$$$= f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + \| y \| E(y)$$ ... ... ... (16)Where $$E(0) = 0$$ and $$E(y) = f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v) \ \ \ \ \text{ if } y\neq 0$$ ... ... ... (17)... ... ... "

My questions are as follows:Question 1

Can someone show how Equation (16) follows ... that is ...

... how exactly does $$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + \| y \| E(y)$$

follow from

$$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + f'(b) [ \| y \| E_a(y) ] + \|v \| E_b(v)$$?

Question 2

What is $$E(0)$$ ... I know what $$E_a$$ and $$E_b$$ are ... but what is $$E$$?

Similarly ... what is $$E(y)$$ in (16) and in (17) ... shouldn't it be $$E_a(y)$$ ... ?

Further ... why (formally and rigorously) does $$E(0) = 0$$
Question 3

Can someone please demonstrate how/why

$$E(y) = f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v)$$
Help will be appreciated ...

Peter

=========================================================================================

It may help MHB readers of the above post to have access to Apostol's section on the Total Derivative ... so I am providing the same ... as follows:
View attachment 8525
View attachment 8526
Hope that helps ...

Peter

 

[Opalg]

In the proof of Theorem 12.7 we read the following:

" ... ... Using (14) in (15) we find$$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + f'(b) [ \| y \| E_a(y) ] + \|v \| E_b(v) $$$$= f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + \| y \| E(y)$$ ... ... ... (16)Where $$E(0) = 0$$ and $$E(y) = f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v) \ \ \ \ \text{ if } y\neq 0$$ ... ... ... (17)... ... ... "

My questions are as follows:Question 1

Can someone show how Equation (16) follows ... that is ...

... how exactly does $$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + \| y \| E(y)$$

follow from

$$f(b+v) - f(b) = f'(b) [ g'(a) (y) ] + f'(b) [ \| y \| E_a(y) ] + \|v \| E_b(v)$$?

Question 2

What is $$E(0)$$ ... I know what $$E_a$$ and $$E_b$$ are ... but what is $$E$$?

Similarly ... what is $$E(y)$$ in (16) and in (17) ... shouldn't it be $$E_a(y)$$ ... ?

Further ... why (formally and rigorously) does $$E(0) = 0$$
Question 3

Can someone please demonstrate how/why

$$E(y) = f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v)$$

The answer to all three of those questions is that the equations in (17) are meant to be the definition of $E(y)$. In other words, if you define \[E(y) = \begin{cases}0&\text{if }y=0,\\ f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v)&\text{if }y\ne0,\end{cases}\] then the second line of (16) follows immediately from the first line.

 

[Math Amateur]

The answer to all three of those questions is that the equations in (17) are meant to be the definition of $E(y)$. In other words, if you define \[E(y) = \begin{cases}0&\text{if }y=0,\\ f'(b) [ E_a(y) ] + \frac{ \| v \| }{ \| y \| } E_b (v)&\text{if }y\ne0,\end{cases}\] then the second line of (16) follows immediately from the first line.

Thanks Opalg ...

Indeed ... you are right, of course!

Should have seen that ...

Peter