Thermal Expansion of Two Holes

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of thermal expansion of solids with holes in them. The person does not understand how a hole in a metal can also expand when heated and poses an example of two slabs of concrete with a hole in between them. The response explains that the entire system expands and the hole will not expand into the metal, but rather the distance between the slabs will increase. The importance of expansion joints in preventing dangerous stress levels is also mentioned.
  • #1
Hlud
72
6
I have a problem understanding the concept of thermal expansions of solids with a hole in it. I do not want to accept face value the traditional explanation i am given that hole will increase in size because i am told to imagine if the hole was never cut. I fail to see the congruency in these two examples.

My biggest issue can be posed as this question. Imagine a metal with two holes drilled in it, with a small amount of the metal (distance x) separating the two holes. When the metal is heated, the holes presumably will expand as well. Does this mean the holes expand into the metal, shortening this distance x?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
Hlud said:
I have a problem understanding the concept of thermal expansions of solids with a hole in it. I do not want to accept face value the traditional explanation i am given that hole will increase in size because i am told to imagine if the hole was never cut. I fail to see the congruency in these two examples.

My biggest issue can be posed as this question. Imagine a metal with two holes drilled in it, with a small amount of the metal (distance x) separating the two holes. When the metal is heated, the holes presumably will expand as well. Does this mean the holes expand into the metal, shortening this distance x?
No, the holes won't expand into the metal, the entire system expands. So what this means is the distance X is also expanding.

Think about what would happen were no holes cut into the metal.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Hlud said:
I do not want to accept face value the traditional explanation i am given that hole will increase in size because i am told to imagine if the hole was never cut.
Imagine that instead of a hole there was just an outline of a hole. What would happen to that outline as the solid expands?
 
  • #4
The reason i do not accept it face value is because i do not see the congruency of those two situations. I understand the situation. Imagine if there was no hole, but actual metal. But why are they congruent?
 
  • #5
Hlud said:
The reason i do not accept it face value is because i do not see the congruency of those two situations. I understand the situation. Imagine if there was no hole, but actual metal. But why are they congruent?

Here is a good post from AlephZero:

AlephZero said:
There are materials (e.g. many crystals, and some composite matierals) where the coefficient of thermal expansion is different in different directions. In those materials, in general the hole would not expand uniformly, and would change shape.

But apart from that:
If the solid plate is at a constant temperature and the edges are free to expand, the stress in the plate will be zero everywhere, independent of the temperature.

So, imagine that you draw the circle, then change the temperature of the plate, then cut out the hole around the expanded or contracted shape of the line. Since the stress in the plate was zero everywhere before cutting, it will stay zero after cutting, and cutting the hole wll not change the shape of the plate.

Or more mathematically:
If there is no elastic stress in the plate, the strain field is ##\epsilon_{xx} = \epsilon_{yy} = \epsilon_{zz} = \alpha \Delta T## and the shear strains are all zero, where ##\alpha## is the corefficient of expansion and ##\Delta T## the temperature change.

Because the strain field is symmetrical in x y and z, this means that ANY two points that were originally a distance ##d## apart become a distance ##d(1 + \alpha \Delta T)## apart, indepedent of the shape of the object, and whether or not it contains holes.
 
  • #6
Ahh, that helps me understand it conceptually. Thanks for that!
 
  • #7
So, i am having a lot of trouble understanding conceptually that thermal expansion of a metal will also cause a hole in that metal to expand. So i put forth this example. Imagine two slabs of concrete, that are long and wide. If i put them next to each other, i would like to have an expansion joint in between them, right?

Now, imagine i put a small concrete connecter on each end of these slabs, so technically we now have one concrete slab with a really big hole in it. Previously, the separation between these two slabs decreased. With our new connecting pieces, the separation (in our case, the hole) increases.

Does this work around the need for an expansion joint? I mean, can we just have really tiny width expansion joints, since the hole will increase in size? Or am i not understanding how the expansion of holes really works? Thanks for any help.
 
Last edited:
  • #8
What actually happens with your two slabs and the links depends on details of the whole assembly .

If slabs are free to slide along then the whole assembly just gets a bit longer .

If slabs are anchored at the outer ends then inboard ends will try to move together but are prevented from doing so . In this case compressive stresses will be induced in the links and slabs .

In the real world constrained thermal expansion can generate very high and often dangerous stress levels .

The old type railway tracks had expansion joints everywhere to prevent thermally induced stresses from buckling the rails .

Expansion joints are also commonly seen on road bridges . In part these are for the same purpose as in rail tracks .

(Purely for interest their other purpose is to allow the bridge to change shape slightly under different traffic loads without inducing end loads in the structure .)
 
Last edited:
  • #9
Hlud said:
So, i am having a lot of trouble understanding conceptually that thermal expansion of a metal will also cause a hole in that metal to expand.
Here is a good way to visualize this:
http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/22436
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Hlud said:
With our new connecting pieces, the separation (in our case, the hole) increases.

Does this work around the need for an expansion joint? I mean, can we just have really tiny width expansion joints, since the hole will increase in size? Or am i not understanding how the expansion of holes really works? Thanks for any help.
Only if you think you can move the entire slab of concrete without breaking it!
 
  • #11
Nidum said:
What actually happens with your two slabs and the links depends on details of the whole assembly .

If slabs are free to slide along then the whole assembly just gets a bit longer .

So, does this mean, if the links were not there, and the slabs were still free to slide along, then the separation will get bigger as well?
 
  • #12
Hlud said:
So, does this mean, if the links were not there, and the slabs were still free to slide along, then the separation will get bigger as well?
No, it gets smaller.

The reason the hole gets bigger when there is a link is that the link expands. So in order for the link to expand without buckling, it would need to be really, really strong.
 
  • #13
Hlud said:
So, i am having a lot of trouble understanding conceptually that thermal expansion of a metal will also cause a hole in that metal to expand.
Try this. Imagine a square sheet of metal. Now divide that square into 9 smaller squares, in a 3 x 3 arrangement. So the original square is now 9 smaller squares. Do you agree that when heated each small square will expand? And thus the original square expands?

Now remove the center square and redo the thought experiment. Do you agree that when heated each small square (8 of them now) will expand? And thus the hole in the middle (the missing square) must have expanded as well?
 
  • #14
I think what might be confusing you Hlud is that the answer depends on what kind of stresses are being applied. Since you didn't mention any sort of external barriers, we assume that the metal is simply free to expand in all directions. In this case, every feature in the metal will simply expand together. The whole thing just becomes bigger.

Now if you put the metal in some kind of box that doesn't expand, then you try to heat the metal to expand it, then there will be all sorts of compressive forces keeping the metal from expanding. Then, if the box doesn't break, maybe the holes will get smaller as the material is forced inward because there is nowhere else for it to go.

When you are talking about expansion joints, those are needed because there are external constraints. Different parts of the ground expand at different rates, since the ground isn't one material and it isn't at one temperature.
 
  • #15
Just consider a ring of metal . When heat is applied metal expands and increases circumference of hole .Hole gets bigger .

Even easier consider a square ring each side expands so square gets bigger .
 
  • #16
A.T. said:
Here is a good way to visualize this:
http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/22436

Let me explain why i have trouble with this analogy, using one of mine own. Imagine nine squares, each containing a baby. In our square, the baby is given enough space for it to live in. As the baby grows into an adult, the nine squares are expanded to accommodate the bigger humans living inside. Because there is a human inside the center square, the designers of these nine squares decide to build out.

Now going back to your link. Assuming there is no hole, we see similarity to my analogy above. However, what happens if we first remove the center square, thus creating a hole. Let's map the original eight squares on top of the expanded eight squares. Clearly we can see that all of the eight squares did not just expand, but expanded outward only as if the center square was still there!

russ_watters said:
No, it gets smaller.

The reason the hole gets bigger when there is a link is that the link expands. So in order for the link to expand without buckling, it would need to be really, really strong.

So, in other words, the four squares in contact with the missing center square can be thought of as the 'links'. Ok, that is making a lot more sense. Does this mean that the four squares in contact with the missing center square have more stress on them?
 
  • #17
Hlud said:
So, in other words, the four squares in contact with the missing center square can be thought of as the 'links'. Ok, that is making a lot more sense. Does this mean that the four squares in contact with the missing center square have more stress on them?
There is more stress on them than if the center square was there, yes -- because stress is a function of area and there is less area when there is a hole. Note that in the expanding sheet of metal examples, there are no stressess because the entire sheet is allowed to expand unconstrained -- a concrete sidewalk, however, is not so free to expand.
 
  • #18
A common practice in engineering is to shrink fit components together .

Typically a shaft into a flange or pulley .

Several ways of actually doing it but simplest is to heat flange or pulley so that the hole in it increases in diameter enough to allow shaft to be easily assembled into place .

As flange or pulley cools the hole in it closes down again in diameter and a very strong interference fit on shaft is generated .
 
  • #19
russ_watters said:
There is more stress on them than if the center square was there, yes -- because stress is a function of area and there is less area when there is a hole. Note that in the expanding sheet of metal examples, there are no stressess because the entire sheet is allowed to expand unconstrained -- a concrete sidewalk, however, is not so free to expand.

Ok, then that makes a lot of sense. Now it ties in what AlephZero said. Thanks for the help!
 
  • #20
Hlud said:
Clearly we can see that all of the eight squares did not just expand, but expanded outward only as if the center square was still there!
That is the only way they can expand, while preserving their square shape and interconnection with the other squares. You should read the explanations in the link, especially the part about expanding rigid body vs. expanding fluid/dough/clay.
 

What is thermal expansion?

Thermal expansion is the tendency of matter to change in volume in response to a change in temperature. When a substance is heated, its particles move more quickly and spread out, leading to an increase in volume. When a substance is cooled, its particles move more slowly and become more compact, resulting in a decrease in volume.

How does thermal expansion affect two holes?

In the case of two holes, thermal expansion can cause the holes to change in size and shape when the material they are in is heated or cooled. This is because the material around the holes will expand or contract, while the holes themselves remain the same size. This can lead to a change in the fit or alignment of the holes, which can be problematic in certain applications.

What factors influence the thermal expansion of two holes?

The thermal expansion of two holes is influenced by several factors, including the material of the object containing the holes, the temperature change, and the size and shape of the holes. Materials with a higher coefficient of thermal expansion will expand or contract more significantly with temperature changes, while materials with a lower coefficient of thermal expansion will be less affected.

How can thermal expansion of two holes be managed?

There are several ways to manage the thermal expansion of two holes, depending on the specific application. One common method is to use materials with a similar coefficient of thermal expansion for both the object and the holes, reducing the potential for misalignment. Other techniques include using materials with lower coefficients of thermal expansion, adding expansion joints or flexible materials, or using adjustable fixtures to compensate for temperature changes.

What are some practical examples of thermal expansion of two holes?

The thermal expansion of two holes is a common occurrence in many everyday objects. For example, in a metal bridge, the expansion and contraction of the metal due to temperature changes can cause the bolt holes to shift, leading to potential structural issues. In electronic devices, thermal expansion can cause misalignment of components, affecting their performance. In construction, masonry materials expand and contract with temperature changes, leading to potential issues with the alignment of windows and doors.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
793
Replies
1
Views
449
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
18K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • Cosmology
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
78
Views
4K
Back
Top