Tricky circular area math problem from the GRE

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around a tricky GRE math problem involving the areas of circles and their intersections. Participants analyze the equation for Quantity A, which is expressed as y + (x - 2y - z), and explore the implications of the areas x, y, and z. Some contributors suggest that the problem can be approached logically rather than algebraically, concluding that the answer is likely B. The conversation also touches on the classification of the problem as homework, with some members debating its appropriateness for the forum. Overall, the consensus leans towards understanding the relationships between the areas rather than performing complex calculations.
mgier001
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
Hey guys, I was wondering if anyone could help me out with this problem from the GRE practice exam:

image.jpg


I honestly don't know how to go about solving it. I'm guessing that the answer is either B or D, however I know that in this GRE exam you can never guess... My friends think the answer is B but I have not been able to come up with any logical reasoning behind any of the answer choices.
This problem is tricky so if anyone can help me through it I would greatly appreciate it.
Thanks,
-Matt
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Is this thread misposted? I'm not sure if this problem would fall under a homework/coursework category since it technically is not homework or coursework... :\
 
mgier001 said:
Hey guys, I was wondering if anyone could help me out with this problem from the GRE practice exam:

image.jpg


I honestly don't know how to go about solving it. I'm guessing that the answer is either B or D, however I know that in this GRE exam you can never guess... My friends think the answer is B but I have not been able to come up with any logical reasoning behind any of the answer choices.
This problem is tricky so if anyone can help me through it I would greatly appreciate it.
Thanks,
-Matt
The area of each circle is ##x##. The intersection of two circles has area ##y##. The intersection of all three has area ##z##. Quantity A is given by ##y+(x-2y-z)##. What does this tell you?

mgier001 said:
Is this thread misposted? I'm not sure if this problem would fall under a homework/coursework category since it technically is not homework or coursework... :\
Technically, I think this goes under homework.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Mandelbroth said:
The area of each circle is ##x##. The intersection of two circles has area ##y##. The intersection of all three has area ##z##. Quantity A is given by ##y+(x-2y-z)##. What does this tell you?


Technically, I think this goes under homework.


Well the area of each circle x=40, and intersection y=15. However, z is not given. I would guess z to be 7.5, but I don't want to simply guess an answer.

Solving with 7.5 yields: 15+(40-(2x15)-7.5) = 17.5
 
mgier001 said:
Well the area of each circle x=40, and intersection y=15. However, z is not given. I would guess z to be 7.5, but I don't want to simply guess an answer.

Solving with 7.5 yields: 15+(40-(2x15)-7.5) = 17.5
All you need to know is that ##z## is nonnegative. Other than that, it doesn't really matter what ##z## is. Try it. Algebra is fun. :-p
 
Mandelbroth said:
All you need to know is that ##z## is nonnegative. Other than that, it doesn't really matter what ##z## is. Try it. Algebra is fun. :-p

Do you mind explaining the equation? I would have subtracted 3y and added 2z.
x-3y+2z
 
we have 7 regions
3A
3B
1C
each circle is made up of 1A+2B+C
so 40=a+2b+c
each intersection of two circles is made up of B+C
so 15=b+c
our shaded region is made up of A+B
so 25=a+b
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Doing all that algebra is wasting valuable test-taking time. Take the smaller shaded region, and instead shade in one of the other two regions that have the same shape. Look at the overall shaded region that results.

p.s. Mod's note: moving this to homework area.
 
Put the small shaded area in the circle that has the large shaded area , it leaves you with the intersection of two circles which is 15.

So the shaded area is 40-15 = 25.

Not sure if it's suppose to be more complicated , but the statement that all the intersections of two circles are identical intuitively suggest that each of the three small areas surrounding the triple intersection are of the same size.Do you think you had to prove that?
 
  • Like
Likes smslca
  • #10
Mandelbroth said:
The area of each circle is ##x##. The intersection of two circles has area ##y##. The intersection of all three has area ##z##. Quantity A is given by ##y+(x-2y-z)##. What does this tell you?
I can't see where you get y+(x-2y-z) from. Using your labelling:

the larger shaded area = x - 2y + z

and the smaller shaded area = y - z

so Quantity A = (x - 2y + z) + (y - z) = x - y

As a couple of of the posters have already stated, it is intuitively obvious that it is x - y if you "move" the smaller shaded area into the other circle.
 
  • #11
I agree with Red Belly, no algebra is needed. This is a logic question, no maths involved.
 
  • #12
oay said:
I can't see where you get y+(x-2y-z) from. Using your labelling:

the larger shaded area = x - 2y + z

and the smaller shaded area = y - z

so Quantity A = (x - 2y + z) + (y - z) = x - y

As a couple of of the posters have already stated, it is intuitively obvious that it is x - y if you "move" the smaller shaded area into the other circle.
I misinterpreted their meaning of intersection of 2 circles as "the intersection of 2 and only 2 circles." I apologize.

Regardless, B is correct.
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
203
Replies
10
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Back
Top