Trigonometry Problem Solving Question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a trigonometry problem involving a cat observing a bird across a river. Participants note that the problem lacks sufficient information, requiring assumptions about the geometry involved. One user attempts to solve it by assuming the triangle formed after the cat moves is a right triangle but encounters discrepancies in the calculated height of the tree. Another user suggests outlining equations for the unknowns, including the height of the tree, the width of the river, and the distance from the tree after the cat's movement. The correct height of the tree is indicated to be 11.37 meters, prompting users to share their calculations for clarity.
Zashmar
Messages
48
Reaction score
0
Question:
"A cat sitting on the edge of a straight river bank spots a bird sitting in a tree directly across the river's edge. The angle of elevation from the cat to the bird is 15°. The cat the moves 25m along the river bank, and now spots the same bird at an angle of elevation of 13°. How high is the tree?

What assumptions have you made in the construction of your diagram?"




There is not enough information to do this, that is why it asks for assumptions.



I have drawn the diagram, and then realized there are not enough angles or sides to work it out. I then thought that i would have to ASSUME THAT THE TRIANGLE FORMED FROM THE CAT WALKING 25m WAS A RIGHT ANGLED TRIANGLE.

However when i then calculate the size of the tree not only is the answer wrong, but for each sub-viewing-traingle i found a different value of the size of the tree. The answer in the book says that the tree is 11.37m tall.

How did they get there?

Please, Thank you :confused:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Zashmar said:
Question:
"A cat sitting on the edge of a straight river bank spots a bird sitting in a tree directly across the river's edge. The angle of elevation from the cat to the bird is 15°. The cat the moves 25m along the river bank, and now spots the same bird at an angle of elevation of 13°. How high is the tree?

What assumptions have you made in the construction of your diagram?"




There is not enough information to do this, that is why it asks for assumptions.



I have drawn the diagram, and then realized there are not enough angles or sides to work it out. I then thought that i would have to ASSUME THAT THE TRIANGLE FORMED FROM THE CAT WALKING 25m WAS A RIGHT ANGLED TRIANGLE.

However when i then calculate the size of the tree not only is the answer wrong, but for each sub-viewing-traingle i found a different value of the size of the tree. The answer in the book says that the tree is 11.37m tall.

How did they get there?

Please, Thank you :confused:

Show us what you did and what answer you got.
 
Hi Zashmar,

How did you get to the wrong solution? Show your work.

A picture can help. I show you one. You are right, there are right triangles- one horizontal, as initially, the cat sits opposite to the tree, then walks 25 m along the tree. The other triangles are vertical. Write up all equations for the unknowns: hight of tree (h), width of the river (w) distance from the tree (d) after the cat walked 25 m.

ehild
 

Attachments

  • cattree.JPG
    cattree.JPG
    14 KB · Views: 461
Last edited:
Back
Top