Ultracapacitors - How long until the potential difference drops to 6V

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the time it takes for a 1200-F ultracapacitor, initially charged to 12.0 V, to discharge to 6.0 V while drawing current at a constant rate of 1.0 mC/s. The initial calculations suggest a time of approximately 115.52 days based on the exponential decay formula. Participants debate the appropriateness of the equations used, particularly regarding the assumption of constant current and the relationship between voltage, charge, and time. There is also discussion about the effects of connecting capacitors in series or parallel and how to calculate equivalent capacitance. The conversation highlights the need for clarity on the underlying equations and concepts related to capacitor discharge.
idk11
Messages
8
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Compact "ultracapacitors" are with capacitance values up to several thousand farads are now commercially available. One application for ultracapacitors is in providing power for electrical circuits when other sources (such as a battery) are turned off.

Assume a 1200-F ultracapacitor is initially charged to 12.0 V by a battery and is then disconnected from the battery. If charges is then drawn off the plates of this capacitor at a rate of 1.0mC/s. say, to power backup memory of some electrical gadget, how long (in days) will it takes for the potential difference across the capacitor to drop to 6.0 V?

Homework Equations



V(t)=V(0)e^(-t/t-constant)
t-constant=RC
I=Q/t
R=V/I

The Attempt at a Solution



I=0.001/1=0.001
R=12/0.001=12000
t-constant=12000*1200=14400000
ln(6/12)*14400000=-t
t=9981319.4
9981319.4 seconds = 115.52 days
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Isn't it a little simpler than that?

Qo = Vo*C

The charge is drawn at a constant rate. At Vo/2 then isn't there Qo/2 .

Isn't then ΔQ/I = (Qo - 1/2Qo)/I = Δt ?
 


Thank you.
 


Where exactly was I going wrong above then?
 


idk11 said:
Where exactly was I going wrong above then?

As it reads to me there is a constant current drain. You have so much water in the bucket and you are taking it out at a constant rate.
i.e the I is constant and not a function of t.

The equation you are using is a solution for the differential equation of

C*dV/dt + V/R = 0

But V/R in this equation is the current and is a function of t.

Except in this problem V/R is a constant Io.

Substituting Q/C for V and V/R with Io the equation reduces to a simpler statement that dQ/dt = -Io
 


If two of these capacitors are placed in a series, how long (in days) would it take? In parallel?

I can calculate the two equivalent resistances for this question, but are they even really needed?
 


idk11 said:
If two of these capacitors are placed in a series, how long (in days) would it take? In parallel?

I can calculate the two equivalent resistances for this question, but are they even really needed?

I'd say what you really want to calculate is the equivalent capacitance. That tells you how big a bucket of charge you have to draw from.
 


That's what I meant to say. Once I have the two equivalent capacitances, what equations do I plug them into?
 


idk11 said:
That's what I meant to say. Once I have the two equivalent capacitances, what equations do I plug them into?

Has Q = V*C changed to determine total charge as before?
 
  • #10


Yes, it has changed. I realize that, but what equation am I missing that relates all of these elements to time? In my notes from class, I recorded that, when something is discharging... V(t)=V(0)e(-t/t-constant)

Would I find a new initial voltage through Q=VC and plug it into that equation I just mentioned?
 
  • #11


Okay. So I got the correct answer by finding the new Q and plugging it into that equation you gave me for the first part of the question. However, I still do not know where you derived that equation from. My class is strictly algebra-based and we have not even mentioned differentials yet.

ΔQ/I = (Qo - 1/2Qo)/I = Δt
 
  • #12


idk11 said:
Okay. So I got the correct answer by finding the new Q and plugging it into that equation you gave me for the first part of the question. However, I still do not know where you derived that equation from. My class is strictly algebra-based and we have not even mentioned differentials yet.

ΔQ/I = (Qo - 1/2Qo)/I = Δt

Since I is defined to be

I = ΔQ/Δt ...

And by Q = V*C you know that when V(t) = Vo/2 , that Qo necessarily = Qo/2 ...
 
Back
Top