Understanding Transistor IC-Vce Graphs

  • Thread starter Thread starter reonem
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Transistor
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around understanding the behavior of transistor IC-Vce graphs, particularly why collector current (Ic) and collector-emitter voltage (Vce) change while the base current (Ib) remains constant. Participants explore various aspects of transistor operation, including saturation, output resistance, and load lines, in the context of both theoretical and practical applications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants note that the collector current (Ic) is primarily determined by the base current (Ib) and the transistor's current gain, suggesting that changes in Vce have minimal impact once the transistor is saturated.
  • Others argue that even in saturation, variations in Vce can still affect Ic due to the output resistance of the transistor, which is influenced by the Early effect.
  • A participant mentions that the collector diode is reverse biased, leading to a small leakage current that can be modeled as a resistor, affecting the slope of the Ic-Vce curve.
  • Some participants provide calculations for the output resistance based on observed changes in Ic with respect to Vce, indicating that this relationship can be approximated in the saturation region.
  • There is discussion about the load line on the Ic-Vce graph, with some clarifying that it should not be drawn through the origin but rather from the supply voltage to the short circuit current point.
  • One participant expresses confusion about why Vce changes when Ib is fixed, highlighting a need for simpler explanations.
  • Another participant explains that in practical circuits, varying the base current leads to changes in collector current and consequently affects Vce due to the load resistor.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the effects of Vce on Ic when Ib is constant, with some asserting that Vce has little effect in saturation while others emphasize the significance of output resistance and the Early effect. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the exact nature of these relationships.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various assumptions, such as the conditions under which the transistor operates in saturation and the implications of load resistance on the Ic-Vce relationship. There are also references to specific voltage values and current gains that may depend on the particular transistor model being discussed.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students preparing for exams in electronics or electrical engineering, as well as practitioners seeking to understand transistor behavior in circuit design.

reonem
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
hi
i have an exam next sunday and i really have no clue about this thing..
in an transitor IC-Vce graph(as it apear on the third page of this site - (first line and right graph) www.onsemi.com/pub_link/Collateral/2SB1204-D.PDF)

why are the Vce and Ic changing when the Ib is staying the same?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
can you try phrase it in a simple language ?
i don't speak fluent english and wikipedia use to add examples and phrases from all the levels of physics
 
The collector current, Ic, is determined mainly by the base current,Ib, and the current gain of the transistor. Once the value of Vce is greater than about 0.5 to 1.0V any further increase in Vce has little effect. The transistor is said to be 'saturated'.
The values of Ic for different values of Ib are 'more or less' horizontal showing that Vce is not having a major effect.
From the table given for this transistor you can see that the current gain (hfe) is somewhere between about 30 and 70. You can also see that the value of Vce to cause saturation is about 250mV.
hope this helps
 
The collector diode is reverse biased. But still there is a little leakage current that can be modeled as a resistor. This is refer to be something like the other resistance ( I don't want to get into the detail of the physics or exact model as that can be long).

In normal BJT, the output resistance ro is in 10MHΩ or higher easily. So if you vary the Vce, you see the collector curve slant up with increase Vce even the Ib is constant. Take two point on the straight portion of the curve ( saturation region), find the ΔIc vs ΔVce

r_o=\frac{\partial I_c}{\partial V_{CE}}

Don't challenge me on the exact equation, this is only the simplified explanation.
 
Last edited:
the published curves for the transistor in this post give dIc/dVce of about 0.5/7 = 0.07A/V = 14ohms. (I used Ib = -15mA as the average)
Do you have any references where the exact modelling and the exact equation can be followed up?
 
truesearch said:
the published curves for the transistor in this post give dIc/dVce of about 0.5/7 = 0.07A/V = 14ohms. (I used Ib = -15mA as the average)
Do you have any references where the exact modelling and the exact equation can be followed up?

I should have said that the equation is only approx AT the saturation region...The flat straight line portion of it. That's the portion that if you extrapolate to the negative voltage, it intercept the x-axis at the Va that called early voltage.

There are other effect, but for common emitter ( ground emitter), this is a good approximation. If you use this straight line and calculate of the change of collector current vs Vce, you get the output resistance in range of Mega ohms. This is to take two points on the flat line and find the ΔIc vs ΔVce to get the ro. I edit my original post already.
 
Last edited:
Transistors in amplifiers are usually operated in the saturated region (with Vce greater than about 500mV) once in this region Vce has little effect on Ic (the lines on the graph are ALMOST horizontal.
The major effect on Ic is through Ib.
In practical circuits with a collector resistor it is safe to assume that Vce will be about 1V (saturation voltage) in the same waythat it is afe to assume that Vbe is about 0.7V for silicon transistors.
The collector resistor can be shown on the Ic against Vce graph as a straight line through the origin with the appropriate slope. It is called the load line and its intersection with the Ic~Vce curves gives the operating points of the transistor.
 
In practical circuits with a collector resistor, Vce is arranged to be about half of the supply voltage.

This allows the voltage to swing equally in either direction with changes in base current.

For undistorted output, operating the amplifier in saturation must be avoided and it should not be driven into the cut-off region either.

The load line is not drawn through the origin. It is drawn from the supply voltage point on the Vc axis to the short circuit current point on the Ic axis.
 
  • #10
That is what I meant VK but didn't say it correctly. Load line is from Ic axis to Vce axis.
My mistake to say through origin.
 
  • #11
truesearch said:
Transistors in amplifiers are usually operated in the saturated region (with Vce greater than about 500mV) once in this region Vce has little effect on Ic (the lines on the graph are ALMOST horizontal.
The major effect on Ic is through Ib.
In practical circuits with a collector resistor it is safe to assume that Vce will be about 1V (saturation voltage) in the same waythat it is afe to assume that Vbe is about 0.7V for silicon transistors.
The collector resistor can be shown on the Ic against Vce graph as a straight line through the origin with the appropriate slope. It is called the load line and its intersection with the Ic~Vce curves gives the operating points of the transistor.

OP ask why why the Vce and Ic changing even Ib is constant. This is represented by the top right graph on page 3. Even in the saturation region, the lines are not horizontal. In fact if you extend all the lines towards the left side, they should all meet at the same point on the x-axis at a voltage called Early Voltage. From the slope of each line, you can find the output resistance of the transistor. That's the ro I posted in the first post. At the saturation region, the Ic still change when you change Vce, that's the output resistance effect. And this is with Ib held constant. That has nothing to do with load line.

At Vce between 0V to the saturation region, the curve is non linear and output resistance really don't mean a whole lot.
 
  • #12
thanks every one but i think it is really to profound explanation.. i don't understan (and i read comments) why should the vce change?- the ib is fixed.. how can it change?
 
  • #13
reonem said:
hi
i have an exam next sunday and i really have no clue about this thing..
in an transitor IC-Vce graph(as it apear on the third page of this site - (first line and right graph) www.onsemi.com/pub_link/Collateral/2SB1204-D.PDF)

why are the Vce and Ic changing when the Ib is staying the same?

This is just a graph of collector current vs collector voltage with different fixed base currents.

So, the base current is fixed and you can vary the collector voltage and current.

In practice, you would actually vary the base current and this would cause a change in collector current.
Because of the load resistor, this causes a change in collector voltage.

From a design point of view, you would look at this graph and see where you could place a load line which would give approximately equal changes in output voltage for the changes in base current. This would give a relatively undistorted output.

In this case, you might put a loadline from 10 volts to 4 amps, so the resistor would be 2.5 ohms, but the output would be fairly distorted because of the uneven spacing of the curves.
 
  • #14
the resistor is the divide yea?
if i will put x amper in the base.. how can i know, through the graph, the collector current?

thanks allot
 
  • #15
If there is no load, you can read it straight off the graph.

Suppose you put 15 mA in the base, then you can read the 15 mA curve to get the collector current for different collector voltages.

However if you had a 2.5 ohm load in series with the collector, you would do this:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/4222062/PNP%20curve.PNG

The base current is 15 mA with no signal, so the operating point is at the orange dot on the load line.

The collector current is about 2.4 amps and the collector voltage is about 3.9 volts.

Notice that the collector resistor is dropping about 6 volts. 2.4 amps * 2.5 ohms = 6 volts. Take this away from the 10 volt supply and you get the 4 volts on the collector.

Now, if you vary the base current from 10 mA to 20 mA, the collector current will vary from 1.75 amps to 3 amps (blue lines) and the collector voltage will vary from 5.6 volts to 3 volts (purple lines).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #16
vk6kro said:
If there is no load, you can read it straight off the graph.

Suppose you put 15 mA in the base, then you can read the 15 mA curve to get the collector current for different collector voltages.

However if you had a 2.5 ohm load in series with the collector, you would do this:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/4222062/PNP%20curve.PNG

The base current is 15 mA with no signal, so the operating point is at the orange dot on the load line.

The collector current is about 2.4 amps and the collector voltage is about 3.9 volts.

Notice that the collector resistor is dropping about 6 volts. 2.4 amps * 2.5 ohms = 6 volts. Take this away from the 10 volt supply and you get the 4 volts on the collector.

Now, if you vary the base current from 10 mA to 20 mA, the collector current will vary from 1.75 amps to 3 amps (blue lines) and the collector voltage will vary from 5.6 volts to 3 volts (purple lines).

what do you mean by "load"? "If there is no load, you can read it straight off the graph."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #17
That means that the collector is connected directly to the supply voltage without any resistor.

The load line then becomes vertical.
 

Similar threads

Replies
68
Views
7K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
15K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
5K
Replies
31
Views
5K