coverband
- 170
- 1
speed = distance/time
v=s/t
Acceleration = dv/dt = -s/t^2 ?
v=s/t
Acceleration = dv/dt = -s/t^2 ?
The discussion revolves around the concepts of velocity and acceleration, focusing on their definitions, relationships, and the conditions under which certain equations apply. Participants explore the implications of using average versus instantaneous speed and the validity of differentiation in the context of motion equations.
Participants express differing views on the treatment of variables in the equations for velocity and acceleration. There is no consensus on the validity of certain mathematical approaches or the implications of treating acceleration as constant.
The discussion highlights limitations regarding assumptions about the constancy of variables and the conditions under which certain mathematical operations are valid. Specific mathematical steps and definitions are also points of contention.
DrGreg said:Another thing to add is that the differentiation in post #1 would be valid only if ##s## were a constant and ##t## were a variable. Does that make sense?
I said constant ##s##, not constant ##a##. My comments refer specifically to $$coverband said:No because when deriving an equation for v we start with a = dv/dt -> dv = a dt -> v=[int]a dt -> v = u + at. This is how Wikipedia derives the first equation of motion. They treat a as a constant. Thanks for your first answer though