Understanding Voltage Drops and KVL in Circuit Analysis

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter mohamed el teir
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Elements
3 replies · 2K views · last reply
mohamed el teir
Messages
88
Reaction score
1
Slide titled Passive sign convention with two two-terminal element diagrams: current i enters the positive terminal, giving p = +vi; current enters the negative terminal, giving p = -vi.


p here stands to power (v in power equation is magnitude), in addition to this : is it also true that in the first one : V = RI (V upper - V lower) and in the second one : V = - RI (V lower - V upper) ?
(current is magnitude in all previous equations)
 
Attachments
  • Slide titled Passive sign convention with two two-terminal element diagrams: current i enters the positive terminal, giving p = +vi; current enters the negative terminal, giving p = -vi.
    upload_2015-10-2_13-27-26.png
    7.7 KB · Views: 623
Last edited:
mohamed el teir said:
second one : V = - RI (V lower - V upper) ?

It's not clear what your question is, but on the quoted part, no. A resistor does not generate power. You can have a voltage source with an internal resistance value, but the voltage source is what is generating the power, and the internal resistance of the power source consumes some of that power as the load current flows through it.
 
Worked example with two circuit diagrams: (a) a 20 V source in series with a 2 Ω resistor and a 3 Ω resistor, marked v1 and v2; (b) the same loop with clockwise current i. Solution text lists v1 = 2i, v2 = -3i, KVL -20 + v1 - v2 = 0, and i = 4 A, v1 = 8 V, v2 = -12 V.


so is this example wrong ? it treated v2 as -RI and v2 appeared to be negative at the end, which stated that resistance + and - ends are reversed i think
 
mohamed el teir said:
View attachment 89670

so is this example wrong ? it treated v2 as -RI and v2 appeared to be negative at the end, which stated that resistance + and - ends are reversed i think

I think they are just trying to illustrate how if you choose the voltage drops incorrectly initially when using KVL, you still get the right answers in the end (because you get a negative number which means the voltage drop is actually in the other direction).