Voltage Regulator Properties and Behavior

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior and properties of voltage regulators, particularly in the context of DC/DC converters and their efficiency in power conversion. Participants explore the relationship between input and output power, current draw, and the implications of conservation of energy in electrical circuits.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants inquire whether power is lost when a voltage is regulated, specifically questioning the efficiency of a charge controller converting 60V input to 48V output.
  • It is noted that the input power is the sum of the output power and the power lost due to inefficiency, with typical efficiencies for DC-DC converters being above 90%.
  • One participant asserts that a power supply can set either voltage or current, but not both, and describes how this relates to the load's interaction with the power supply.
  • Another participant provides calculations for input and output power, suggesting that if a solar panel provides 480 watts, the actual output to the battery may be less due to inefficiencies and load requirements.
  • Concerns are raised about the assumption that the charger will always draw a specific current from the photovoltaic cells, emphasizing that current draw depends on the load.
  • Participants discuss the implications of efficiency losses, with one noting that if the charger delivers 8 amps at 48 volts, it will waste some power, leading to a calculated efficiency of 80%.
  • There is a question about the possibility of converting lost power into available current, with a participant explaining that the load determines current draw based on its internal resistance.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the behavior of the charge controller and the assumptions regarding current draw from the solar panel. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the exact efficiency and power dynamics involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants reference specific scenarios and calculations, but there are unresolved assumptions regarding the efficiency of the charge controller and the behavior of the photovoltaic cells under varying loads.

Bergenheimer
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hello, simple question here!

When a voltage is regulated down or up in a circuit by, let's say a DC/DC converter, does the corresponding current increase or decrease respectively so that the system remains consistent with the laws of conservation of energy?

In other words, I want to know if i lose power when a circuit component regulates a voltage. For example, if i have 60 volts of power going into a 48V charge controller, is there any power lost here when the charge controller regulates the voltage to the batteries on the other end?

Thanks,

∫ Bergenheimer
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Bergenheimer said:
Hello, simple question here!

When a voltage is regulated down or up in a circuit by, let's say a DC/DC converter, does the corresponding current increase or decrease respectively so that the system remains consistent with the laws of conservation of energy?

In other words, I want to know if i lose power when a circuit component regulates a voltage. For example, if i have 60 volts of power going into a 48V charge controller, is there any power lost here when the charge controller regulates the voltage to the batteries on the other end?

Thanks,

∫ Bergenheimer

The output power is the regulated output voltage multiplied by the load current.

The input power is the sum of the output power plus the power lost in the regulator (due to inefficiency). For most DC-DC converters, the efficiency of conversion is in the 90%+ range.
 
Just to be crystal clear.

Any power supply can set or determine either the voltage or the current, but not both.

The second quantity is set by the load and its interaction with the power supply (psu).

So a psu provides

1) A specific voltage, whatever current the load draws.

or

2) A specific current and adjusts the voltage to force this through the specific load.

Battery chargers usually fall into category 2.

The input power is the input current times the input voltage and the output power is the output current times the output voltage.

They are independent, except that obviously there must be enough input to finance the output and the inefficiency losses.
 
Studiot said:
Just to be crystal clear.

Any power supply can set or determine either the voltage or the current, but not both.

The second quantity is set by the load and its interaction with the power supply (psu).

So a psu provides

1) A specific voltage, whatever current the load draws.

or

2) A specific current and adjusts the voltage to force this through the specific load.

Battery chargers usually fall into category 2.

The input power is the input current times the input voltage and the output power is the output current times the output voltage.

They are independent, except that obviously there must be enough input to finance the output and the inefficiency losses.

Ok, I have a 48 Volt charger in which i set the float, bulk, and equalizing voltages. It is rated up to 150 amps. The input to the system is a solar panel. The solar panel is rated at 60 volts and outputs about 8 amps. So if 480 watts is put into the charge controller, can I expect 480 watts to be provided to the battery (assuming the battery requires charge)? Or does it only get 48 volts and 8 amps (384 watts).

So i guess what I am asking here is this a norton/thevinin equivalent situation (from a circuit analysis point of view).

-Berg
 
What makes you think the charger will always draw 8 amps from the photovoltaic cells?

That would violate case 1 in my earlier post.

The photovoltaic panel offers a combination of cells that develop 60 volts at the terminals under stated lighting conditions.

The current will depend on the applied load, up to a maximum of 8 amps.

If your charger is set to deliver 8 amps to the batteries at 48 volts it will do this and draw 8amps plus its own requirements, say .2 amps from the photovoltaic panel.

So the input power is 8.2*60 = 482 watts

It will deliver

output power 8*48 = 384 watts

It will waste 98 watts

So its efficiency will be 80%

edit: If your battery charger were only delivering 6 amps to the batteries, the calculations above would use 6, instead of 8 and 6.2 instead of 8.2 in the formulae.
 
Last edited:
Studiot said:
What makes you think the charger will always draw 8 amps from the photovoltaic cells?

That would violate case 1 in my earlier post.

The photovoltaic panel offers a combination of cells that develop 60 volts at the terminals under stated lighting conditions.

The current will depend on the applied load, up to a maximum of 8 amps.

If your charger is set to deliver 8 amps to the batteries at 48 volts it will do this and draw 8amps plus its own requirements, say .2 amps from the photovoltaic panel.

So the input power is 8.2*60 = 482 watts

It will deliver

output power 8*48 = 384 watts

It will waste 98 watts

So its efficiency will be 80%

edit: If your battery charger were only delivering 6 amps to the batteries, the calculations above would use 6, instead of 8 and 6.2 instead of 8.2 in the formulae.

Ok, thanks. I was hoping that the charge controller was able to convert that lost 98 watts (which is voltage potential) into available current to the load. Why is this not possible?
 
Bergenheimer said:
Ok, thanks. I was hoping that the charge controller was able to convert that lost 98 watts (which is voltage potential) into available current to the load. Why is this not possible?

Please see my post #2. DC-DC converters are basically constant power converters (minus the efficiency loss). The load draws whatever current is defined by its internal resistance I=V/R. This determines the output power, which determines the input power.

You can draw less than the max rated current, but you cannot draw more. If the output power demand exceeds the input power available, then the output voltage will droop. If the output power demand is less than the maximum available input power from the solar panel, then less input current will be drawn from the solar panel.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
5K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K