Volume of a partially full fuel tank

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tregg Smith
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Fuel Tank Volume
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the volume of a partially full cylindrical tank, specifically one that is oriented horizontally. The dimensions provided are a length of 6 feet and a diameter of 4 feet. The original poster is trying to determine the volume of fuel at various heights within the tank, particularly at 6 inches off the bottom, and is concerned about the implications of fuel levels on usage and waste.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to apply the formula for the volume of a cylinder to different fuel levels, questioning whether the volume scales linearly with height. They inquire about the volume when the fuel is at specific heights (1 foot and 10 inches off the bottom) and express confusion about the calculations involved.
  • Some participants suggest a more complex approach involving integral calculus, proposing to divide the fuel into layers and calculate the volume based on varying widths at different heights. They introduce the concept of using the equation of a circle to derive the necessary dimensions for volume calculation.
  • There is a repeated request for a direct answer regarding the volume at the 6-inch level, indicating a desire for clarity amidst the mathematical discussion.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants exploring different mathematical methods to address the problem. While some guidance has been offered regarding the use of calculus, there is no explicit consensus on the best approach or a definitive answer to the original poster's question about the volume at the 6-inch level.

Contextual Notes

The original poster indicates that they are not approaching this as a traditional homework problem, yet the forum's policy discourages providing direct answers to homework-like questions. There is also a concern about the practical implications of the fuel volume calculations, particularly regarding the usability of the fuel and the potential waste involved.

Tregg Smith
Messages
43
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement

Finding the volume of a partially full cylindrical tank that lies on it's length. L=6', D=4"



Homework Equations

pi r sq times L = cu ft when full. Convert to gallons 1 gal. =
.1336 cu. ft. (I think)



The Attempt at a Solution

(pi r sq times L)/2 = when half full

How about when the fuel is one foot off the bottom? Is this simply (pi r sq times L)/4 ?

How about when the fuel is 10" off the bottom?

The volume of this tank is about 560 gal. which is way too much for the application. Diesel fuel goes bad after a year or two. Only 50 gallons are used each year. If you fill it then you throw out 500 gal. each year. The intake tube from the tank to the generator motor is 6" off the bottom of the tank. I want to know how many gallons to put in the tank that would allow 75 gallons or so to be available-so you would calculate how many gallons are there at 6" then add 75 gallons. That's why I ask is this just a straight line problem where one foot off the bottom equals one fourth of the tanks total capacity etc.? If so then 6" being 1/8 total would be... 560gal/8=70gallons + another 75 gallons=145gal. :rolleyes: To put it another way does the area of a circle decrease linearly as a line touching two points on the circle gets shorter?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
No, you cannot use the formula for volume of a cylinder for part of a cylinder. In fact, this problem is not really "pre-calculus", it is a standard problem in integral calculus.

Imagine the fuel in the cylinder divided into "layers" of different heights. Each layer is a rectangle. The area of the rectangle is "length times width". We can take the length of each rectangle to be the same as the length of the cylinder: h. The width, however, varies with height. If we take x as the height and take x= 0 at the center of the circular end we can write the equation of the circle to be x^2+ y^2= r^2 so that y= \pm\sqrt{r^2- x^2}. The width of the rectangular layer is from "circle to circle"- twice y= 2\sqrt{r^2- x^2}.

The area of each rectangle, then, is "length times width"= 2h\sqrt{r^2- x^2}. If we take the thickness of the layer to be the infinitesmal dx, the volume is given by 2h\sqrt{r^2- x^2}dx. The entire volume is the integral from the bottom, at x= -r, to the height of the fuel:
V= 2h\int_{-r}^{2r} \sqrt{r^2- x^2}dx
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thx for your help. I don't quite see all of what you're saying-it's been 30 years since I had calculus. In the mean time can you give me the answer to how many gallons are at the six inch level off the tank bottom(before it starts sucking water into the engine-it's dangerously close) then I'll add 75 gal. run time to that.


HallsofIvy said:
No, you cannot use the formula for volume of a cylinder for part of a cylinder. In fact, this problem is not really "pre-calculus", it is a standard problem in integral calculus.

Imagine the fuel in the cylinder divided into "layers" of different heights. Each layer is a rectangle. The area of the rectangle is "length times width". We can take the length of each rectangle to be the same as the length of the cylinder: h. The width, however, varies with height. If we take x as the height and take x= 0 at the center of the circular end we can write the equation of the circle to be x^2+ y^2= r^2 so that y= \pm\sqrt{r^2- x^2}. The width of the rectangular layer is from "circle to circle"- twice y= 2\sqrt{r^2- x^2}.

The area of each rectangle, then, is "length times width"= 2x\sqrt{r^2- x^2}. If we take the thickness of the layer to be the infinitesmal dx, the volume is given by 2x\sqrt{r^2- x^2}dx. The entire volume is the integral from the bottom, at x= -r, to the height of the fuel:
V= \int_{-r}^h 2x\sqrt{r^2- x^2}dx
It is not difficult to integrate that- use the substitution u= r^2- x^2.
 
There was an error in what I wrote before: I had 2x\sqrt{r^2- x^2} when it should have been 2h\sqrt{r^2- x^2}- the "h" is the length of the cylinder.

You posted this in the homework section and it is the policy of this forum to not give answers to homework. Are you saying it is not homework?

With h= 6' and D= 4' (you had 4" but surely that's not right? Not if you are asking about the volume when the fuel level is at 6"!), the radius is 2' and 6" above the bottom is 1/2 '. The volume of fuel 6 inches above the bottom is
2h\int_{-2}^{-3/2}\sqrt{4- x^2}dx

The substitution x= 2sin(t) should simplify that.
 
:smile: No this isn't homework-I'm 62. I think it says homework or homework like questions. I don't understand the symbols. I would just like the answer as to how many gallons are at the 6" level. The diameter is four feet, length six feet.
You posted this in the homework section and it is the policy of this forum to not give answers to homework. Are you saying it is not homework?

With h= 6' and D= 4' (you had 4" but surely that's not right? Not if you are asking about the volume when the fuel level is at 6"!), the radius is 2' and 6" above the bottom is 1/2 '. The volume of fuel 6 inches above the bottom is
2h\int_{-2}^{-3/2}\sqrt{4- x^2}dx

The substitution x= 2sin(t) should simplify that.[/QUOTE]
 
If you let x= 2 sin(t) the 4- 4 sin^2(t)= 4(1- sin^2(t))= 4cos^2(t) so that \sqrt{4- x^2}= \sqrt{4cos^2(t)}= 2 cos(t). Also dx= 2 cos(t) dt so that \sqrt{4- x^2} dx= 4 cos^2(t) dt

When x= -2= 2sin(t), sin(t)= -1 and t= -\pi/2. When x= 3/2= 2 sin(t), sin(t)= 3/4 so that t= arcsin(3/4)
\int_{-2}^{3/2}\sqrt{4- x^2}dx= 4\int_{-\pi/2}^{arcsin(3/4)} cos^2(t)dt
= 2\int_{-\pi/2}^{arcsin(3/4)} 1+ cos(t) dt= 2\left(arcsin(3/4)+ \pi/4- 3/4+ \sqrt{2}/2\right)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K