What Are These Alloys?

  • Thread starter Thread starter madstudio
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Composition
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on identifying two specific alloys with compositions primarily of nickel, iron, chromium, and other elements. The user seeks expert help for a project involving the replacement of an electromagnetic shield, emphasizing the need for a historically accurate material. Responses highlight the difficulty in reproducing proprietary alloy recipes and suggest that mu-metal may be a superior but different alternative. The user clarifies that the shield is magnetic, not electromagnetic, and expresses concern over the resistivity differences in available substitutes. Ultimately, the original alloy remains unidentified, complicating the project.
madstudio
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hi everybody :smile: my first post here and I wonder can you recognize and name this two alloys?
first:
Ni27.5%
Fe63%
Cr5.5%

second

Ni60%
Fe25%
Mo2%
Cu3.3%
Mn1%
Cr5.5%

It looks like some soft magnetic alloys but ... :frown:
Cheers
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
madstudio said:
Hi everybody :smile: my first post here and I wonder can you recognize and name this two alloys?
first:
Ni27.5%
Fe63%
Cr5.5%

second

Ni60%
Fe25%
Mo2%
Cu3.3%
Mn1%
Cr5.5%

It looks like some soft magnetic alloys but ... :frown:
Cheers

Welcome to the PF.

What is the context of your question? Is this for schoolwork?
 
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF.

What is the context of your question? Is this for schoolwork?
Thanks. Nope, I'm not a student, I'm looking for some expert help for my project. Hope that's OK.
 
madstudio said:
Thanks. Nope, I'm not a student, I'm looking for some expert help for my project. Hope that's OK.

What kind of project? What is the remaining material in each alloy? (the percentages do not add up to 100%)
 
berkeman said:
What kind of project? What is the remaining material in each alloy? (the percentages do not add up to 100%)
Electromagnetic shield. I need this composition for broken part replacement. Unfortunately I don't know exact chemical composition, I'm looking for close "modern" material since this shield was made long time ago. I know that it's possible to substitute this composition with superior materials like mumetal but it will be nice to find "historical correct" one. At last, mumetal is my last solution.
 
madstudio said:
Electromagnetic shield. I need this composition for broken part replacement. Unfortunately I don't know exact chemical composition, I'm looking for close "modern" material since this shield was made long time ago. I know that it's possible to substitute this composition with superior materials like mumetal but it will be nice to find "historical correct" one. At last, mumetal is my last solution.

Interesting problem. Do you mean "electromagnetic" or "magnetic" shield? There is a difference.

If it is magnetic shield, the mu-metal netic+conetic shielding is your best bet. You can get lots of info and custom shield quotes from here:

http://www.magnetic-shield.com/

I've used them for several projects, and found their customer support to be very good. You can get kits to bend up your own custom shields, but as you know, you will need to get them annealed after you bend them or they lose most of their effectiveness.

If the alloy mixes you show are from analysis of the materials of the old existing shields, it may be difficult to reproduce the original recipe. Often the mixes and processing are proprietary to the company that made the shields in the first place.
 
Yes, my typo, magnetic shield. Yes, I'm familiar with mumetal and it's properties, problem is that "original" alloy has different resistivity . Unfortunately in this application it really matters. It seems that this alloy is really unknown :frown:
 
Back
Top