What force causes a balloon to float?

AI Thread Summary
A balloon filled with CO2 falls because it is heavier than air, demonstrating the effect of gravity. In contrast, a helium-filled balloon floats as it is lighter than air, with buoyancy being the key force at play. The upward force on the balloon arises from the difference in weight between the displaced air and the balloon's contents. This buoyant force, combined with gravity, determines whether an object rises or falls. Ultimately, buoyancy is the force that allows lighter-than-air gases to lift balloons.
timothychoi
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
When I blow a balloon with CO2, it falls as it is heavier than air. Then it is gravity that causes the balloon to fall.
When I buy a balloon filled with helium gas from a store, it floats as it is lighter than air. But what force is causing the balloon to float?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
timothychoi said:
When I blow a balloon with CO2, it falls as it is heavier than air. Then it is gravity that causes the balloon to fall.
When I buy a balloon filled with helium gas from a store, it floats as it is lighter than air. But what force is causing the balloon to float?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buoyancy

:smile:
 
  • Like
Likes davenn, russ_watters and timothychoi
timothychoi said:
I see. It is like an airplane.
No, more like a Blimp...
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
berkeman said:
No, more like a Blimp...
Oh. I noticed that an airplane floats by "lift". Thanks.
 
timothychoi said:
Oh. I noticed that an airplane floats by "lift". Thanks.

an aeroplane doesn't float by lift it flies, air must move across the wings ( above and below) to cause lift
If it doesn't keep moving, it will stall and fall from the sky
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters and vanhees71
timothychoi said:
When I blow a balloon with CO2, it falls as it is heavier than air. Then it is gravity that causes the balloon to fall.
When I buy a balloon filled with helium gas from a store, it floats as it is lighter than air. But what force is causing the balloon to float?

The force causing the balloon to rise is also gravity! It is not like an airplane. It is more like a bubble under water. Gravity is pushing the water down. As the bubble goes up, that amount of water goes down. So the bubble going up is effectively water falling. Of course gravity is pulling down on the air in the bubble too, but with less force because it is lighter than an equal volume of water. So in net the bubble rising is equivalent to something (the difference in weight between the water and the air) falling.

With your CO2 balloon the rubber+CO2 is heavier than an equal volume of air and that difference in weight falls under gravity. With helium the rubber+helium is lighter than an equal volume of air, and, again, that difference in weight falls under gravity.

That is an energy argument. The way this works in detail is that the weight of the water causes a pressure gradient. The water on top has no weight pressing down on it. Below the surface the water is being pushed down by the weight of all the water above that depth. The deeper you go the greater the weight above and the higher the pressure. That means that the bubble experiences a higher pressure on the bottom of the bubble than on the top. There is a net force upward. It can be shown that the net force upward is equal to the weight of the missing water. This is called buoyancy. If the contents of the bubble weigh less than the missing water, the net force of buoyancy + gravity is upward, and vice versa.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes nasu and anorlunda

Similar threads

Back
Top