What is the distance needed for a rocket to reach a velocity of 0 on Planet X?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of escape velocity on Planet X, highlighting that a rocket must reach a specific speed to avoid falling back. It is suggested that the question may be perceived as a trick due to its implications about velocity and distance. The professor hinted that the solution lies in recognizing the relationship between escape velocity and position. Ultimately, it is concluded that to achieve a velocity of 0, the rocket would need to be infinitely far from Planet X or potentially at the planet's center. Understanding these nuances is crucial for grasping escape velocity concepts.
scoop91
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
The escape velocity on Planet X is the speed the rocket needs in order to never fall back down again in a universe in which X is the only object. In order for the rocket to not fall back down, its velocity to never become negative, how far away does the rocket have to be when the velocity is 0?

What are the steps to solving a problem such as this one?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF!

There's nothing to solve there, it is just a matter of understanding the implications of escape velocity. I'd start by reading the wiki on it...
 
So all in all, it ends up being a trick question? Lol
 
scoop91 said:
So all in all, it ends up being a trick question? Lol

It depends if the speed is the rocket or the rocket is the speed or some weird quantum superposition of speed/rocket states.
 
bp_psy said:
It depends if the speed is the rocket or the rocket is the speed or some weird quantum superposition of speed/rocket states.

Our prof gave us a hint and told us to call the position Xf. He indicated that the answer was right under our noses.

Which led me to believe that there was some deception involved.
 
scoop91 said:
So all in all, it ends up being a trick question? Lol
I don't see it as a trick question, no. This is a common question people have/don't understand regarding escape velocity.

Did you find the answer?
 
According to the escape velocity equation, the distance from the centre of Planet X would need to be infinite to achieve a velocity of 0. It could always reverse it's thrust to achieve a velocity of 0, but the question says it can't. OR considering the definition of escape velocity and the common misconceptions, the answer is probably the rocket would have to be inside the planets centre, where r = 0.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top