What is the significance of the 1/3 factor in the derivation of PV=nRT?

  • Thread starter Thread starter kidsasd987
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Derivation Pv=nrt
AI Thread Summary
The significance of the 1/3 factor in the derivation of PV=nRT arises from the isotropic nature of gas particles, where their velocity components in three dimensions are equal on average. This equality leads to the conclusion that the average of the squared velocity in one direction is one-third of the total average squared velocity. The pressure is related to this factor, as it reflects the distribution of particle collisions against the walls of a container. The choice of the 1/3 factor is essential for maintaining consistency in the kinetic energy equations and ensuring no numerical prefactor appears in the final equation. Understanding this concept is crucial for grasping the behavior of ideal gases in thermodynamics.
kidsasd987
Messages
142
Reaction score
4
http://quantumfreak.com/derivation-of-pvnrt-the-equation-of-ideal-gas/



here is the link.


so we assume the particle hits two surfaces of the cube, thus pressure is 1/3.




combine the equation #11 and #12 we solve kinetic energy equation #12 for mv2.

13. mv^2=2E_{kinetic}\Rightarrow\frac{mv^2}{3}=\frac{2E_{kinetic}}{3}



My question is, I don't understand where 1/3 comes from. is this because the pressure is 1/3?


Thanks for all your help:)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Well at that point it is just the same equation written in a more complicated way (both sides get divided by 3). The definition of k is arbitrary here, it is chosen in such a way that the final equation does not have a numerical prefactor, and this requires the 1/3 in the intermediate steps.
 
Equation 8
N is the particles moving only in the x-direction.
It should have been written as Nx, to avoid confusion
and we take the velocity only in the x-direction Vx
We also have Ny = Nz = Nx
Similarily Vy = Vz = Vx


Equation 11
N is all the particles
( = Nx + Ny + Nz, see the previous logic in the statement before equation 7 )
The velocity is that of the particle along its path, and not parallel to any particular coordinate axis.
Here though, it is the velocity of the particle that is split into components Vx=Vy=Vz, rather than thinking about the number of particles that are moving in the x, y or z directions.
 
kidsasd987 said:
http://quantumfreak.com/derivation-of-pvnrt-the-equation-of-ideal-gas/

My question is, I don't understand where 1/3 comes from. is this because the pressure is 1/3?
Thanks for all your help:)

The 1/3 comes from expressing the average of the x component (squared) in terms of the total velocity squared.
You have
v^2=v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2
When we take the average
<v^2>=<v_x^2>+<v_y^2>+<v_z^2>
(I use brackets for "average")
For an isotropic gas, the average is the same for each component (the three terms on the right are equal). So any of the averages on the right hand side is 1/3 of the average of v^2.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
nasu said:
The 1/3 comes from expressing the average of the x component (squared) in terms of the total velocity squared.
You have
v^2=v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2
When we take the average
<v^2>=<v_x^2>+<v_y^2>+<v_z^2>
(I use brackets for "average")
For an isotropic gas, the average is the same for each component (the three terms on the right are equal). So any of the averages on the right hand side is 1/3 of the average of v^2.

Can u give a good explanation why for an isotropic gas those 3 averages are equal?
 
Symmetry. There is no reason why one coordinate should look different from the others (and the definition of those coordinates is arbitrary anyway).
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Delta² said:
Can u give a good explanation why for an isotropic gas those 3 averages are equal?

Because it is isotropic?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Delta² said:
Can u give a good explanation why for an isotropic gas those 3 averages are equal?

That's what isotropic mean. Any quantity measured along any direction - say the x-axis, will give the same result as any other direction - say the y-axis or the z-axis.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Back
Top