What is the vertical velocity of the rope just as it slides off the peg?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SenatorAstro
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Rope Sliding
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the vertical velocity of a limp rope sliding off a frictionless peg. The initial attempt used conservation of energy, assuming the center of mass falls 0.48 meters, leading to a calculated velocity of approximately 3.07 m/s. However, this approach was challenged as it did not account for the work done lifting part of the rope while some of it falls. Participants emphasized that the system's behavior is not purely kinematic due to non-constant acceleration. The conversation highlights the need for a more nuanced application of energy conservation or Newton's laws to accurately model the situation.
SenatorAstro
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A limp rope with a mass of 2.4 kg and a length of 1.5 m is hung, initially at rest, on a frictionless peg that has a negligible radius, as shown in the Figure. y1 is equal to 0.48 m. What is the vertical velocity of the rope just as the end slides off the peg?

Homework Equations


PE = mgh
KE = 1/2mv^2

The Attempt at a Solution


Because the kinematics of this system seemed incredibly complicated, I figured it best to use conservation of energy in the system. Knowing that the center of mass will fall 0.48 meters, I assumed:

mgΔH = 1/2mv^2
2.4*9.81*0.48 = 1/2*2.4*v^2
v = 3.06881084461 m/s

Unfortunately, this seems to be incorrect.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF;
How do you know the answer is incorrect?
Some of the rope is falling, but some of the rope is lifting. How did you account for the work done lifting part of the rope?

The behavior is not kinematic - since the acceleration will not be constant.
You can, however, use Newton's laws or conservation of energy to set up a differential equation.
 
Last edited:
SenatorAstro said:

Homework Statement


A limp rope with a mass of 2.4 kg and a length of 1.5 m is hung, initially at rest, on a frictionless peg that has a negligible radius, as shown in the Figure. y1 is equal to 0.48 m. What is the vertical velocity of the rope just as the end slides off the peg?
I do not see any figure.

ehild
 
Simon Bridge said:
The behavior is not kinematic - since the acceleration will not be constant.
As I understand the term, kinematics concerns the geometry of motion, such as the movement of linkages. It does not concern itself with forces, energy, etc.
 
Fersure - constant acceleration is a subset of kinematics, which is, strictly, the geometry of motion.

Kinematics at the secondary education level, is usually given as the geometry of motion where acceleration is a constant.
That is the level I was answering at - leaving OP to contradict me if I got it wrong. I suspected that OP did not want to use the suvat (or kinematic) equations. Probably should have been more careful.
 
kinematics,
branch of physics and a subdivision of classical mechanics concerned with the geometrically possible motion of a body or system of bodies without consideration of the forces involved (i.e., causes and effects of the motions).

from Encyclopedia Britannica.ehild
 
My apologies. Here's the image.
 

Attachments

  • Rope.jpg
    Rope.jpg
    9.2 KB · Views: 671
Cool - that's what I figured: what about the questions in post #2?
 
Back
Top