What team, football, rugby, hokey, other, do you support, if you

  • Thread starter Thread starter wolram
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Support
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around participants' sports team affiliations, exploring whether they would continue to support these teams if they moved to a different area. Various sports are mentioned, including football, rugby, hockey, and others, with a mix of personal anecdotes and opinions on the nature of sports fandom.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express strong loyalty to specific teams regardless of location, citing personal or familial connections.
  • Others describe a more fluid approach to support, changing allegiance based on the performance of teams during matches.
  • A few participants question the emotional investment in sports fandom, expressing confusion over why fans feel a sense of victory or defeat based on their team's performance.
  • One participant mentions a method of randomly selecting teams to support in sports not played professionally in their homeland.
  • There are references to rivalries, particularly between Celtic FC and Rangers FC, highlighting cultural and familial influences on team support.
  • Some participants critique the behavior of sports fans who do not actively participate in sports themselves, suggesting a disconnect between fans and players.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants exhibit a range of views on sports fandom, with no clear consensus on the nature of support or the emotional ties to teams. Disagreements arise particularly around the reasons for supporting certain teams and the behaviors of fans.

Contextual Notes

Some statements reflect personal experiences and cultural backgrounds that influence team loyalty, while others express skepticism about the motivations behind sports fandom. The discussion includes varying degrees of emotional investment and differing perspectives on the significance of team success.

wolram
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
4,411
Reaction score
551
What team, football, rugby, hokey, other, do you support, if you moved to a different area would you still support that team.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Scientific teams!
 


Born and raised in Wisconsin, it is somehow encoded in my DNA to be a Packer's fan. It will never change. Ever.

I also am a Brewers (baseball team) fan, but I am not much of a baseball fan.

I have no favorite hockey team, but I enjoy watching the Capitals since I live within their local viewing region currently. I usually support Ireland and Scotland in the Six nations cup for rugby if I get a chance to see them. I have recently started following Everton in the Premiership since both Howard and Donovan play for them, but I don't follow too closely. Domestically, I support DC United for soccer, since I live in their local right now. We had no MLS team in Wisconsin, so I have no real close ties to anyone team.
 


I support Celtic FC and Chelsea FC no matter where I live. I will always support the Habs. The Twinks no matter what!

Basketball. . . meh.
 


Another aspect of sports that I never really got.
 


I support the team that happens to be losing the match I'm watching. If they then gain more points than their opponents, I'll switch to supporting their opponents.
 


ideasrule said:
I support the team that happens to be losing the match I'm watching. If they then gain more points than their opponents, I'll switch to supporting their opponents.

I guess you could call this 'supporting the contest'?

For my main sport, soccer (football...) I support the team from the area that I myself am originally from. Rangers FC. This won't change! For other sports I enjoy that weren't played professionally in my homeland, I rolled a dice to decide who to support.
 


TheStatutoryApe said:
Another aspect of sports that I never really got.

I would agree that its much funnier to play than sit at TV, stuff yourself to death with hamburgers and beers, for the noble purpose of putting even more fat on your belly, and later do a proclamation in front of your wife and friends " God, I love sports. We won".

But such is the human nature. One would rather watch then go down in the field and try for himself. And industry does capitalize on it.
 


Manchester City and McLaren, and moving wouldn't change that.
 
  • #10


DanP said:
I would agree that its much funnier to play than sit at TV, stuff yourself to death with hamburgers and beers, for the noble purpose of putting even more fat on your belly, and later do a proclamation in front of your wife and friends " God, I love sports. We won".

But such is the human nature. One would rather watch then go down in the field and try for himself. And industry does capitalize on it.

Though I do not really care for sports I certainly have more fun playing than watching. I occasionally watch billiards, though I prefer playing, and while I like certain players I enjoy the game itself much more. I don't ever feel like I won something if a player I like wins and if they lose a good game is still a good game. Not that I really consider billiards a sport either.
 
  • #11


TheStatutoryApe said:
Though I do not really care for sports I certainly have more fun playing than watching. I occasionally watch billiards, though I prefer playing, and while I like certain players I enjoy the game itself much more. I don't ever feel like I won something if a player I like wins and if they lose a good game is still a good game. Not that I really consider billiards a sport either.

Yeah, I was generalizing, not speaking about you. Sorry if you misunderstood, I apologize. I illustrated a behavior which seems to be prevalent in the ranks of sports fans , who never been themselves involved in sport from any other position than looking.
 
  • #12


I don't understand how someone could get so excited when a team they like wins a game. They identify themselves with the team, as if they had a hand in the success of the team, then brag to someone else that the team won. I don't get the bragging. "I told you they would win." Well what does that mean? You just proved you're psychic? Or you just proved you had a 50/50 chance of guessing which team would win and you happened to be correct?
Some people seem to get more excited than the actual players when their team wins, or more dejected than the players when the team loses. I guess that's because the players go home to their mansion and the fan goes back to his squalor with none of that empty joy they wanted from being a fan of a winning team.
 
  • #13


143gpdc.jpg
 
  • #14


fasterthanjoao said:
I guess you could call this 'supporting the contest'?

For my main sport, soccer (football...) I support the team from the area that I myself am originally from. Rangers FC. This won't change! For other sports I enjoy that weren't played professionally in my homeland, I rolled a dice to decide who to support.

You've made yourself an enemy!
 
  • #15


MotoH said:
You've made yourself an enemy!

Why on Earth do you support celtic? I thought you were from the US.
 
  • #16


My Grandpa's family is from Glasgow, and we are Catholic, which is one of the rivalries between Catholics and Protestants.

And besides, the Hu. . . erm Rangers are the worst time to ever step onto the pitch.
 
  • #17


DanP said:
Yeah, I was generalizing, not speaking about you. Sorry if you misunderstood, I apologize. I illustrated a behavior which seems to be prevalent in the ranks of sports fans , who never been themselves involved in sport from any other position than looking.

I was agreeing with you man! I know it may be hard to swallow but I do not always argue with everyone. :-p

edit: if only there were televised team debating.
 
  • #18


wolram said:
What team, football, rugby, hokey, other, do you support, if you moved to a different area would you still support that team.

I'm originally from Detroit and really enjoy when the Lions lose. After all, why should they be any better after I left? :-p
 

Similar threads

Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K