Who Does the Work When a Ball is Kicked: The Player or the Ball?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of work and energy transfer when a football is kicked. It is established that work is done by the player when the foot applies force to the ball, resulting in energy transfer that compresses the ball's surface. Once the foot stops applying force, the ball continues to move due to inertia, not because work is being done on it. The stored energy in the ball's compressed surface contributes to its motion as it rebounds after being kicked. Ultimately, while the player does the initial work, the ball's movement is sustained by the energy stored within it.
tarak20085
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
if I shoot the football, the ball will recive a force in specific direction, and it would follow that direction.
Does the work is done by me when I shooted the ball, or the ball does work when it moves all the period after my shooting ?
the work includes force and displacement , so who does the work ? the ball or me ?
when the ball moves, the force of shooting becomes 0 ? and it stills keep moving because the inertia ? and not because of the work ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
tarak20085 said:
so who does the work ? the ball or me ?
Usually, if A does positive work on B, then B does negative work on A. But the magnitudes can differ if there is energy dissipation.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
A.T. said:
Usually, if A does positive work on B, then B does negative work on A. But the magnitudes can differ if there is energy dissipation.
can you answer all my questions please !
 
tarak20085 said:
can you answer all my questions please !
These are too many, because you use question marks as commas.

But if there is no force interaction between A & B anymore, then there is no work done between them.
 
Last edited:
tarak20085 said:
when the ball moves, the force of shooting becomes 0 ? and it stills keep moving because the inertia ? and not because of the work ?
Yes: work is only being done while the force is being applied.
 
This is a bit misleading. If there's a pair interaction in the total energy the interaction potential enters only once!
 
Work is also a transfer of energy. The transfer occurs during the contact (interaction). In the case of the football the kinetic energy of the foot gives some of its energy to the ball (does work on the ball). This energy results, during the contact, in the compression of the surface of the ball . This compression is the results of the work in stretching the surfaces and compressing the gas inside the ball heating the gas as well as heating the surface and temporarily storing energy in the stretched surface. The elastic surface returns some of the energy as the ball begins to move during the period the foot is in contact with the ball.

In the video note the initial contact and hesitation of the ball to move as it is compressed and its subsequent increase in velocity as the surface rebound converting the stored energy into the motion of the ball.

 
gleem said:
Work is also a transfer of energy. The transfer occurs during the contact (interaction). In the case of the football the kinetic energy of the foot gives some of its energy to the ball (does work on the ball). This energy results, during the contact, in the compression of the surface of the ball . This compression is the results of the work in stretching the surfaces and compressing the gas inside the ball heating the gas as well as heating the surface and temporarily storing energy in the stretched surface. The elastic surface returns some of the energy as the ball begins to move during the period the foot is in contact with the ball.

In the video note the initial contact and hesitation of the ball to move as it is compressed and its subsequent increase in velocity as the surface rebound converting the stored energy into the motion of the ball.


Thank you!
I ve understand what you wanted to explain beside the last chapter
you ve said (as the surface rebound converting the stored energy into the motion of the ball).
Did you mean that the surface stretched in the ball make a work on the total ball ?
moving of the ball when no foot is applying happens because the force of the gaz on the surface
 
Last edited:
tarak20085 said:
Did you mean that the stored energy in the ball surface make a work on the total ball ?

Basically, If you kick an uncoiled spring it will compress and store energy imparted by the kick. As the foot follow through the spring expands pushing against the foot. The other end of the spring is unhindered so the expansion produces a force in the direction of the motion of the rest of the spring. The spring (ball) bounces off the foot.
 
Back
Top