Why Does Air Break Up into Swirls Behind a Blunt Body in Fast Motion?

In summary, the conversation discusses the topic of fluids and the drag force, specifically focusing on cases where air is the fluid, the body is blunt, and the relative motion is fast enough for the air to become turbulent behind the body. The conversation also touches on the equation for the force of drag and the meaning of the variable A, which is the effective cross-sectional area. The explanation for the air breaking up into swirls behind the body involves viscosity and the formation of vortices. The equation for drag force is found through experiments, and the meaning of A depends on the type of drag being analyzed.
  • #1
Bashyboy
1,421
5
At the moment, I am reading about fluids and the drag force. There is one particular paragraph that I would like help with, specifically the part in red:
"Here we examine only cases in which air is the fluid, the body is blunt (like
a baseball) rather than slender (like a javelin), and the relative motion is fast
enough so that the air becomes turbulent (breaks up into swirls) behind the body."

Why does the air break up into swirls behind the body?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Also, in the next paragraph the author begins talking about an equation for the force of drag, [itex]D = 1/2C\rho Av^2[/itex]. How was the equation found? The describe the variable A as "effective cross-sectional area," what does that mean?
 
  • #3
Bashyboy said:
"Here we examine only cases in which air is the fluid, the body is blunt (like a baseball) rather than slender (like a javelin), and the relative motion is fast enough so that the air becomes turbulent (breaks up into swirls) behind the body."

Why does the air break up into swirls behind the body?

Well, because of viscosity, a fluid must have zero velocity near a surface (relative to that surface). This gives rise to what is called the boundary layer. In a simplified sense, as the air moves around the ball, the boundary layer doesn't have enough energy in it to make its way completely around the back end and ends up separating from the surface. When the boundary layer separates from the surface, it creates essentially a low pressure, recirculating bubble between it and the surface. There are essentially two vortices such as these that form for a circular cylinder (a similar but less complicated case compared to a ball). For low values of the Reynolds number (low velocities), which denotes the ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces, these vortices are stable and remain attacked to the back of the object. At a certain value of the Reynolds number, the system becomes unstable and the vortices begin shedding in an alternating pattern.

This is a fairly complicated problem and it sounds like you don't have any prior fluids experience so I will leave it at this simplified explanation for the time being.

Bashyboy said:
Also, in the next paragraph the author begins talking about an equation for the force of drag, D=1/2CρAv2. How was the equation found? The describe the variable A as "effective cross-sectional area," what does that mean?

That equation is essentially empirical where you find a value for [itex]C_D[/itex] through experiments. There are a handful of cases where it can be calculated approximately, but in general, you need to find that from experiments. The meaning of [itex]A[/itex] depends on what sort of drag you are looking at. For pressure drag, it is the frontal area of the object. For viscous drag it would be the wetted area, etc, though that equation is of limited use for viscous drag.
 
  • #4
all the equation on friction
 
  • #5
boneh3ad said:
Well, because of viscosity, a fluid must have zero velocity near a surface (relative to that surface). This gives rise to what is called the boundary layer. In a simplified sense, as the air moves around the ball, the boundary layer doesn't have enough energy in it to make its way completely around the back end and ends up separating from the surface. When the boundary layer separates from the surface, it creates essentially a low pressure, recirculating bubble between it and the surface. There are essentially two vortices such as these that form for a circular cylinder (a similar but less complicated case compared to a ball). For low values of the Reynolds number (low velocities), which denotes the ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces, these vortices are stable and remain attacked to the back of the object. At a certain value of the Reynolds number, the system becomes unstable and the vortices begin shedding in an alternating pattern.

This is a fairly complicated problem and it sounds like you don't have any prior fluids experience so I will leave it at this simplified explanation for the time being.



That equation is essentially empirical where you find a value for [itex]C_D[/itex] through experiments. There are a handful of cases where it can be calculated approximately, but in general, you need to find that from experiments. The meaning of [itex]A[/itex] depends on what sort of drag you are looking at. For pressure drag, it is the frontal area of the object. For viscous drag it would be the wetted area, etc, though that equation is of limited use for viscous drag.

Thank you for that explanation, though most of it was a bit above my understanding. You are right in supposing that have not any experience with fluids, but I'll keep this webpage saved for the time being until I have learned about them.
 

Related to Why Does Air Break Up into Swirls Behind a Blunt Body in Fast Motion?

1. What is fluid friction and turbulence?

Fluid friction and turbulence is the resistance that occurs when a fluid (such as water or air) flows over a surface. It is caused by the interaction between the fluid molecules and the surface, and can result in chaotic, irregular motion known as turbulence.

2. How is fluid friction and turbulence measured?

The most commonly used measurement for fluid friction and turbulence is the Reynolds number, which is calculated by dividing the inertial forces of the fluid by the viscous forces. A higher Reynolds number indicates a more turbulent flow.

3. What causes fluid friction and turbulence?

Fluid friction and turbulence can be caused by several factors, including the surface roughness of the object the fluid is flowing over, the velocity of the fluid, and the density and viscosity of the fluid. These factors can all affect the level of friction and turbulence in the flow.

4. How does fluid friction and turbulence affect the flow of fluids?

Fluid friction and turbulence can have a significant impact on the flow of fluids. It can increase drag, decrease the efficiency of fluid flow in pipes and channels, and affect the mixing of different fluids.

5. What are some real-world applications of studying fluid friction and turbulence?

Understanding fluid friction and turbulence is crucial in many industries, such as aviation, automotive, and marine engineering. It is also essential in the design and optimization of pipelines, pumps, and other fluid systems. Additionally, studying fluid friction and turbulence can help improve our understanding of weather patterns and ocean currents.

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
7K
Replies
1
Views
7K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
17
Views
9K
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • Earth Sciences
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
94
Views
8K
  • General Discussion
Replies
1
Views
8K
Back
Top