Why is diamond stronger than metals?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TT0
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Diamond Metals
AI Thread Summary
Diamonds are stronger than metallic and ionic compounds due to their strong covalent bonds, which are directional and create a rigid tetrahedral structure. In contrast, metallic bonding involves a delocalized electron cloud that allows for greater ductility, meaning metals can deform more easily without breaking. While ionic bonds can be strong, they are less effective under pressure, making ionic compounds brittle. The discussion highlights that while diamonds are hard, they are also brittle, as they can shatter under impact. Transition metals, like tungsten, exhibit both hardness and brittleness due to their directed d-orbital bonds, distinguishing them from other metals. Overall, the strength and behavior of materials depend significantly on their atomic bonding and structure.
TT0
Messages
210
Reaction score
3
I know the reasons that diamonds are stronger than covalent materials and ionic compounds. The former is weaker because there are intermolecular forces and the latter is weaker because if pressure is applied like charged ions would be forced together making it brittle. However, I cannot think why metal substances are weaker than diamonds other than that metallic bonding is a weak bond. Can someone explain this to me?

I think that ionic bonds are as strong as covalent bonds, is this true?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
The covalent bond in diamond is not only strong but also directed while the cohesive forces in metals and ionic compounds depend little on the relative positions of the atoms.
 
  • Like
Likes TT0
Could you explain a bit more about the relative positions? and also about the direction? cheers!
 
"Strong" is a rather dangerous word to be used here. Diamonds are hard, bur relatively brittle. You can scratch any metal with a diamond, but diamond hit with a hammer will break.
 
  • Like
Likes TT0
I see, I meant hard. Apologies
 
In diamond, each carbon atom is surrounded tetrahedrally by other carbon atoms. If you try to move an atom keeping its distance from its bond partner constant, this would greatly weaken the bond and requires therefore a strong force. In contrast to this, in metals the ionic cores are embedded into the electron gas formed by the valence electrons like raisins in honey. Moving the ions sidewards will therefore cost little energy. Therefore metals are much more ductile than diamond. However, this is not true for transition metals, as the d-orbitals also form directed bonds. Hence metals like Tungsten are very hard and brittle, too.
 
  • Like
Likes TT0
I see thank you. That was a very clear explanation :smile::smile::smile::smile::smile:
 
You are welcome!
 
Back
Top