MHB Why Is There a Difference in Orbital Angular Momentum Calculation Methods?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the confusion surrounding different methods for calculating orbital angular momentum, particularly the expression for L_x. The user acknowledges using a determinant approach but questions the validity of an alternative formulation involving partial derivatives. There is mention of previous exercises where combining del components differently seemed appropriate. The conversation highlights the nuances in applying these formulas correctly, indicating a need for clarity in understanding the definitions involved. Ultimately, the differences in calculation methods stem from varying interpretations of the underlying mathematical principles.
ognik
Messages
626
Reaction score
2
I got to here in a simple exercise (orb. ang. momentum cords), realized I was applying something I didn't understand ...

$L = -i \begin{vmatrix}\hat{x}&\hat{y}&\hat{z}\\x&y&z\\\pd{}{x}&\pd{}{y}&\pd{}{z}\end{vmatrix}$

I 'know' it equates to $L_x =-i \left( y\pd{}{z} - z\pd{}{y} \right) $ - but I could just as well (?) have $L_x =-i \left( \pd{y}{z} - \pd{z}{y} \right) $?

(I seem also to recall other exercises where it was right to combine the del components the 2nd way above)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
by definition - answered in other post
 
Last edited: