Wye or delta, source side power generation and distribution

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
1 reply · 5K views
chopficaro
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
for a three phase power generator, you can have sources in series with inductances in either a wye or delta formation by designing the generator differently. from my understanding, if you choose wye instead of delta, then the power produced will be increaced by a factor of the root of 3

in addition, if the load is designed so that it is in a delta instead of wye, the power available will again be increaced by a factor of the root of 3

so why aren't all power distribution systems designed as wye to delta?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
chopficaro said:
for a three phase power generator, you can have sources in series with inductances in either a wye or delta formation by designing the generator differently. from my understanding, if you choose wye instead of delta, then the power produced will be increaced by a factor of the root of 3

in addition, if the load is designed so that it is in a delta instead of wye, the power available will again be increaced by a factor of the root of 3

so why aren't all power distribution systems designed as wye to delta?

Firstly the power ratio is 3 (not sqrt3) in each case above, meaning that for given phase voltages and given load resistances the power ratio is actually 9:1 for wye-delta (source-load) over delta-wye.

However, the above is irrelevant in power distribution. Voltage/impedance considerations are handled by transformer turns ratio and choices of delta versus wye are made for entirely different considerations.