What is Space: Definition and 1000 Discussions

Space is the boundless three-dimensional extent in which objects and events have relative position and direction. In classical physics, physical space is often conceived in three linear dimensions, although modern physicists usually consider it, with time, to be part of a boundless four-dimensional continuum known as spacetime. The concept of space is considered to be of fundamental importance to an understanding of the physical universe. However, disagreement continues between philosophers over whether it is itself an entity, a relationship between entities, or part of a conceptual framework.
Debates concerning the nature, essence and the mode of existence of space date back to antiquity; namely, to treatises like the Timaeus of Plato, or Socrates in his reflections on what the Greeks called khôra (i.e. "space"), or in the Physics of Aristotle (Book IV, Delta) in the definition of topos (i.e. place), or in the later "geometrical conception of place" as "space qua extension" in the Discourse on Place (Qawl fi al-Makan) of the 11th-century Arab polymath Alhazen. Many of these classical philosophical questions were discussed in the Renaissance and then reformulated in the 17th century, particularly during the early development of classical mechanics. In Isaac Newton's view, space was absolute—in the sense that it existed permanently and independently of whether there was any matter in the space. Other natural philosophers, notably Gottfried Leibniz, thought instead that space was in fact a collection of relations between objects, given by their distance and direction from one another. In the 18th century, the philosopher and theologian George Berkeley attempted to refute the "visibility of spatial depth" in his Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision. Later, the metaphysician Immanuel Kant said that the concepts of space and time are not empirical ones derived from experiences of the outside world—they are elements of an already given systematic framework that humans possess and use to structure all experiences. Kant referred to the experience of "space" in his Critique of Pure Reason as being a subjective "pure a priori form of intuition".
In the 19th and 20th centuries mathematicians began to examine geometries that are non-Euclidean, in which space is conceived as curved, rather than flat. According to Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, space around gravitational fields deviates from Euclidean space. Experimental tests of general relativity have confirmed that non-Euclidean geometries provide a better model for the shape of space.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. Thytanium

    I Aristotle's Absolute Space & Time: Explained

    Aristotle's absolute space and time can be represented as ordered pairs (s, t) but not as fibers π(s) = t of time as is the case of Galileo and Newton's space time. That is to say that the space of Galileo and Newton is the projection π(s) = t on the time axis. The time space of Galileo and...
  2. S

    I I Came Up with a CTC in Minkowski Space: Exploring To What End?

    If you viewed my most recent thread before this one, then you know that I have been studying curves in spacetime (timelike/spacelike/lightlike), and I have especially been looking into the CTCs (closed timelike curves) that the Godel metric is famous for. During my studies I found that I had to...
  3. Math Amateur

    MHB The Metric Space R^n and Sequences .... Remark by Carothers, page 47 ....

    I am reading N. L. Carothers' book: "Real Analysis". ... ... I am focused on Chapter 3: Metrics and Norms ... ... I need help with a remark by Carothers concerning convergent sequences in \mathbb{R}^n ...Now ... on page 47 Carothers writes the following: In the above text from Carothers we...
  4. Math Amateur

    MHB Understand Example 3.10 (b) Karl R. Stromberg, Chapter 3: Limits & Continuity

    I am reading Karl R. Stromberg's book: "An Introduction to Classical Real Analysis". ... ... I am focused on Chapter 3: Limits and Continuity ... ... I need help in order to fully understand Example 3.10 (b) on page 95 ... ... Example 3.10 (b) reads as follows: My question is as...
  5. Quantum Alchemy

    B A Question about space and the multiverse

    My question is about space and the multiverse. I was reading work by Max Tegmark and he sees the multiverse as Level 1-4. A Level 1 multiverse seems like it's self evident and I was wondering about the evidence against it. It's simple: Space expands faster than we can observe it so we exist in...
  6. Math Amateur

    MHB Open Balls in a Normed Vector Space .... Carothers, Exercise 32

    I am reading N. L. Carothers' book: "Real Analysis". ... ... I am focused on Chapter 3: Metrics and Norms ... ... I need help Exercise 32 on page 46 ... ... Exercise 32 reads as follows: I have not been able to make much progress ... We have ...B_r(x) = \{ y \in M \ : \ d(x, y) \lt r \}...
  7. M

    B Questions regarding expansion, the vacuum in space, and black holes

    Summary: Expansion of matter in the visible universe, total volume of space outside the visible universe, black hole mechanics, and general questions from an uneducated but extremely interested evolved monkey. Hello everyone! I do not know the rules of this forum, or any forum for that matter...
  8. M

    Water Freezing in Space: Debunking the Myth of Instant Boiling and Freezing

    There's no thermodynamics forum, so I'll post this here. Things "freezing" in space has always bothered me ever since Tim Robbins removed his helmet while in orbit around Mars...
  9. S

    Steps from state space to transfer function

    I mean the first question has derivative form and the second is linear form so what the difference here in steps of converting both to transfer function... please need some ellaboration to make sure i am solving correctly or not... is it correct to apply the same rule on both: Transfer function=...
  10. S

    Converting linear state space into a transfer function

    My questions are now... Do the steps of converting this space to transfer function include any laplace ? or just we do get [SI-A]-1 and then transfer function is = C* [SI-A]-1 * B As [1 0] * [s-1/det -0.5/det ; 0.5/det s-0.5/det] * [0; 1] = -0.5/s^2+s+0.5 I mean do we need any laplace after that...
  11. Math Amateur

    MHB Countably Dense Subsets in a Metric Space .... Stromberg, Lemma 3.44 .... ....

    I am reading Karl R. Stromberg's book: "An Introduction to Classical Real Analysis". ... ... I am focused on Chapter 3: Limits and Continuity ... ... I need help in order to fully understand the proof of Lemma 3.44 on page 105 ... ... Lemma 3.44 and its proof read as follows: In the above...
  12. M

    A Vector space (no topology) basis

    The standard definition of the basis for a vector space is that all the vectors can be defined as finite linear combinations of basis elements. Consider the vector space consisting of all sequences of field elements. Basis vectors could be defined as vectors which are zero except for one term in...
  13. Flying_Dutchman

    Electrodynamics: divergence of E in empty space

    What is the physical significance of fundamental law del.E=0 in free space ?
  14. hilbert2

    I Notation for vectors in tensor product space

    Suppose I have a system of two (possibly interacting) spins of 1/2. Then the state of each separate spin can be written as a ##\mathbb{C}^2## vector, and the spin operators are made from Pauli matrices, for instance the matrices ##\sigma_z \otimes \hat{1}## and ##\hat{1} \otimes \sigma_z##...
  15. A

    A Recent paper on QED using finite-dimensional Hilbert space - validity?

    I've been struggling with a somewhat-recent paper by Charles Francis, "A construction of full QED using finite dimensional Hilbert space," available here: https://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/0605127.pdf But also published in...
  16. I

    Basic questions about plasma and electrons in space

    If i get this right: In space when electrons leave its atoms, do they attach to something else? Or is the electrons bouncing freely in space when they get detached? Is this because of dark energy? And if so, where do they go? Do they move between atoms or are the free to go anywhere? And where...
  17. GregoryC

    I Is Space-Time Continuous or Quantized?

    A free photon can have any wavelength and energy; no discreteness there. Just because something is quantized, or fundamentally quantum in nature, doesn’t mean everything about it must be discrete. The idea that space (or space and time, since they’re inextricably linked by Einstein’s theories...
  18. Math Amateur

    MHB Open Subsets in a Metric Space .... Stromberg, Theorem 3.6 ... ....

    I am reading Karl R. Stromberg's book: "An Introduction to Classical Real Analysis". ... ... I am focused on Chapter 3: Limits and Continuity ... ... I need help in order to fully understand the proof of Theorem 3.6 on page 94 ... ... Theorem 3.6 and its proof read as follows: In the above...
  19. bluesky314

    I Question about an eigenvalue problem: range space

    A theorem from Axler's Linear Algebra Done Right says that if 𝑇 is a linear operator on a complex finite dimensional vector space 𝑉, then there exists a basis 𝐵 for 𝑉 such that the matrix of 𝑇 with respect to the basis 𝐵 is upper triangular. In the proof, he defines U=range(T-𝜆I) (as we have...
  20. QuasarBoy543298

    I Particle in free space - what happens to the wave function after measurement?

    If I'm trying to solve the problem of a particle in free space (H = P2/2m ). the eigenfunctions of the Hamiltonian cannot be normalized. now assume I have a legitimate wave function expressed in terms of the eigenfunction of H and I want to measure its energy. what will happen to the...
  21. DaniV

    A Mapping the Phase Space of Type II Superconductors

    Due to my lab work I want to try map the phase space that created with critical external magnetic field H_c and the critical current J_c through the superconductor of type II. the critical transition happen from the Abrokosov phase to the non-superconductor phase, occurred by the fact that in...
  22. G

    Ideas about centrifugal space colony habitats on high-gravity planets

    Centrifuges have long been viewed as the means to provide artificial gravity in the zero-g of deep space. Space colony structures like the O'Neill cylinder and the Stanford torus. Centrifuges could also work their magic on the surfaces of low-gravity planets. Conical or paraboloidal shaped...
  23. C

    I Can windows frost over in space?

    I thought about this pretty hard, can windows frost over in space? I'm pretty sure they don't or can't after giving it a bit of thought. This is just a curiosity of mine. So first I believe the correct question that we're trying to answer is: Can a window get colder than interior air faster...
  24. A

    I Space-Like Hypersurface: Simultaneous Events?

    If two events are occurring in a space like hypersurface...is it that the two events will appear to be simultaneous from a frame moving with velocity ##v\lt c## and will appear to be occurring at the same spatially position from a frame with velocity ##v\gt c##??
  25. seletynof

    A What it is the internal space?

    Spin in Physical Space, Internal Space, and Hilbert Space: Spin is already a great unifying principle in theoretical physics, but its potential is far from exhausted. Here I discuss – very concisely – the role of spin in particle physics, in space-time physics, and in ideas for unified field...
  26. shahbaznihal

    I Phase space density function and Probability density function

    I am reading a text which talks about the WIMP speed distribution in the galactic halo in the frame of the Sun and Earth. The point where I am stuck it is trying to explain the concept of Gravitational Focusing of WIMPs at the location of the Earth due to the gravitational well of the Sun...
  27. C

    Position to momentum space in three dimensions

    Hi! I am trying to change the hydrogen ground state wave funcion from position to momentum space, so i solved the integral Ψ(p)=(2πħ)^(-3/2) (πa^3)^(-1/2)∫∫∫e^(prcosθ/ħ) e^(-r/a) senθ r^2 dΦdθdr and got 4πħ(2πħ)^(-3/2) p^(-1) (πa^3)^(-1/2) I am [(ip/ħ-1/a)^(-2)], which according to the...
  28. E

    Nuclear explosions in deep space

    Trying to understand the effects of a deep space nuclear explosion. Starfish prime was detonated at 400km, ie still within Earth's atmosphere, and the explosion effects are well described. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-altitude_nuclear_explosion A significant outcome is the high MeV...
  29. karush

    MHB 10.2 Determine if the set of vectors form a vector space

    Determine if the set of vectors $\begin{bmatrix} x\\y\\5 \end{bmatrix}\in \Bbb{R}^3$ form a vector space ok if I follow the book example I think this is what is done $\begin{bmatrix} x_1\\y_2\\5 \end{bmatrix} +\begin{bmatrix} x_2\\y_2\\5 \end{bmatrix} +\begin{bmatrix} x_2\\y_2\\5...
  30. cianfa72

    I Full-cone as topological space

    Hello, consider a full-cone (let me say a cone including bottom half, upper half and the vertex) embedded in ##E^3##. We can endow it with the topology induced by ##E^3## defining its open sets as the intersections between ##E^3## open sets (euclidean topology) and the full-cone thought itself...
  31. Ralph Rotten

    B Juno -- Coolest space ship in the solar system?

    So Juno is on her downhill run towards Jupiter. Only doing about 8k right now, but by the time she rounds Jupiter she'll be doing 100k or more. We are going to get so much science from Juno. Personally I am eagerly awaiting the results of what Jupiter looks like under all those clouds.
  32. S

    A Is there any theory that can be modeled in any type of space?

    Is there any theory in physics that can be modeled in any type of space (Hilbert space, Euclidean, Non-Euclidean...etc)? And if yes, could that theory also contain/be compatible with all types of (physical) symmetries?
  33. Elijah Talbot

    Do big ships perform better than smaller vessels in space warfare?

    Summary: I am writing a story that features space warfare. I was wondering does a big ship perform better than smaller vessels? I'm just a writer (well wanting to be one with my poor grammar) so I don't know much about engineering or space at all. So space is massive, so battles in space will...
  34. G

    How do 3-D wormholes work/shift space compared to 2-D portals?

    Wormholes, or Einstein-Rosen bridges, are often hypothesized to be spherical in shape. The hole parts, that is. The 2007 videogame Portal gives a different take on hyperdimensional shortcuts. In the game, "portals" are these oval-shaped, planar holes in the fabric of spacetime, and they...
  35. H

    I Can empty space be considered ‘elastic’ and expandable?

    The intention of this question is to get to the heart of the geometrical properties of space-time according to GR, and to focus entirely on what the theory allows, and not so much on what we actually see. I would like to consider a perfect vacuum, in a euclidian infinite void, completely devoid...
  36. B

    Question about the permitivity of free space (from OCR paper)

    the answer is 2.16*10^-11 what i don' t understand about the question is why did they not use the constant Eo 8.85418782 × 10-12 in this case as there is a insulator occupying the area inbetween does that mean then their is no free space ?? Also in this equation the variable A is the area of...
  37. G

    Could Boarding Action in Space be a Reasonable Strategy for Capturing a Ship?

    Yes i know, with realistic space travel it is quite a stunt at best. However i wonder about a situation, when they really want to capture someone alive, and they can take a similar course disguised as a civilan cargo ship. My question is, could it be reasonable, that the attackers need to leave...
  38. T

    I Exploring the Dimension of Space: The Beauty of Cosmology and Unsolved Mysteries

    Motivated by some apparently intractible unsolved problems, I see cosmology as a beautiful mathematical description of a strongly flawed paradigm. This forum wisely does not allow laying out alternate paradigms, so I try to ask questions to guide my immature understanding , in the spirit of...
  39. Greg Bernhardt

    Excited to go to Brian Cox's "ADVENTURES IN SPACE & TIME" tonight

    Tonight I'm taking my wife and parents to Brian Cox's World Tour "ADVENTURES IN SPACE & TIME" with sidekick Robin Ince. All his European stops sold out and so far all of his US stops have been close to selling out. I've been impressed because he's not quite the household name Neil deGrasse Tyson...
  40. L

    I Does Curving Space by an Approaching Mass Do Work?

    A thought experiment. Two rigid, concentric rings, joined together by a series of lightweight elastic radial spokes. These rings and a heavy mass are approaching each other, such that in the frame of the rings, the mass is traveling along the central, perpendicular axis and will pass through the...
  41. J

    B How physics equations transform under inverse of parameters

    It is obvious that there is a one-to-one relationship between real numbers (defined to include infinity) and their multiplicative inverses (assuming we map the inverse of zero to infinity and vice versa). Thus, one should be able to replace the distance between two points in space with it's...
  42. cianfa72

    I Product Space vs Fiber Bundle: Understanding the Difference

    Hi, I'm not a really mathematician...I've a doubt about the difference between a trivial example of fiber bundle and the cartesian product space. Consider the product space ## B \times F ## : from sources I read it is an example of trivial fiber bundle with ##B## as base space and ##F## the...
  43. Z

    What does a helium balloon do on the ISS vs in open space?

    What does a helium balloon do on the ISS . most say, its a 0 g environment, but is it really the same as intercosmos travel "0g"? I saw a video of helium ballons on the vomit comet, where during the "0 g phase" the helium balloons went to the floor, while all other things floated. I would...
  44. G

    Understanding forced motion in space

    Hello, Can you please explain the analogy oft quoted to explain the concept of applied motion to objects in space, which goes as follows : 1. You are standing on a skateboard or sitting in a boat floating on the water, holding a bowling ball. 2. You throw the bowling ball towards the back of...
  45. Silvio Macedo

    I Wave function of particle / quantum field in space, also in time?

    Quantum fields have wave functions that determine a particle position in space. It solves non-locality, double-slit paradox, tunnel effect, etc. What if the wave function is also in time? Won't it solve the breaking of causality at quantum level? (Delayed Choice/Quantum Eraser/Time) Not much...
  46. Biker

    Equiprobable sample space: N Identical objects in K different containers

    So we had an exam question which was the following: Assume you have N identical balls and K different contains if there are N pre-Selected boxes and that N < k what is the probablity that none of these pre-selected boxes are empty? I answered it and it was the same as the professor's answer...
  47. N

    How would we increase the rotation rate of very large structures in deep space?

    Imagine a 400-meter-long pipe with a 1600-meter diameter, floating in inter-planetary space. It is spinning at 0.5 gravity along its major axis and there are no secondary-axes spins. We need to increase rotation to 0.85 g. Its density is a uniform 2.3 kg/m³ and it weighs 49,120,056 kg. Thanks to...
  48. C

    What is Energy Stored in Space?

    TLDR I have no idea what I am talking about . Read this if you're bored. I now realize I may have the wrong category. Please let me know what category would be best for my question. Thanks. Can energy be stored in space itself? With the equation e = mc^2 if we set the constant to c=1...
  49. Ryu

    Theoretical Higher spatial dimensions question

    So I had a topic which I would like to fact check from an informed scientific source. Basically there is an argument about whether or not an object that naturally exists in a fourth dimensional space, would by default have more than countably infinite times the energy of a 3 dimensional Object...
  50. TerranIV

    I Photon Patterns in Space: Could They Exist?

    Would it be possible for photons to form some sort of static structure, like a standing waveform, if space-time was curved enough? It seems like a structure like this exists around black holes. Is there any other distortion or phenomenon that could cause this, such as a neutron star or a galaxy?
Back
Top