What is Space: Definition and 1000 Discussions

Space is the boundless three-dimensional extent in which objects and events have relative position and direction. In classical physics, physical space is often conceived in three linear dimensions, although modern physicists usually consider it, with time, to be part of a boundless four-dimensional continuum known as spacetime. The concept of space is considered to be of fundamental importance to an understanding of the physical universe. However, disagreement continues between philosophers over whether it is itself an entity, a relationship between entities, or part of a conceptual framework.
Debates concerning the nature, essence and the mode of existence of space date back to antiquity; namely, to treatises like the Timaeus of Plato, or Socrates in his reflections on what the Greeks called khôra (i.e. "space"), or in the Physics of Aristotle (Book IV, Delta) in the definition of topos (i.e. place), or in the later "geometrical conception of place" as "space qua extension" in the Discourse on Place (Qawl fi al-Makan) of the 11th-century Arab polymath Alhazen. Many of these classical philosophical questions were discussed in the Renaissance and then reformulated in the 17th century, particularly during the early development of classical mechanics. In Isaac Newton's view, space was absolute—in the sense that it existed permanently and independently of whether there was any matter in the space. Other natural philosophers, notably Gottfried Leibniz, thought instead that space was in fact a collection of relations between objects, given by their distance and direction from one another. In the 18th century, the philosopher and theologian George Berkeley attempted to refute the "visibility of spatial depth" in his Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision. Later, the metaphysician Immanuel Kant said that the concepts of space and time are not empirical ones derived from experiences of the outside world—they are elements of an already given systematic framework that humans possess and use to structure all experiences. Kant referred to the experience of "space" in his Critique of Pure Reason as being a subjective "pure a priori form of intuition".
In the 19th and 20th centuries mathematicians began to examine geometries that are non-Euclidean, in which space is conceived as curved, rather than flat. According to Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, space around gravitational fields deviates from Euclidean space. Experimental tests of general relativity have confirmed that non-Euclidean geometries provide a better model for the shape of space.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. Euthan

    I Energy stored in space-time or space?

    I was talking to a graduate physics student about the issue of energy conservation in an expanding universe. I paraphrased the argument against energy conservation as follows - Suppose we have a photon in outer space that is very far from earth. The universe is expanding (by this I meant that in...
  2. cookiemnstr510510

    Calculate the electric field in all of space for a non conducting sphere

    Homework Statement A) Use Gauss's Law to derive the electric field in all space for a non-conducting sphere with volumetric charge distribution ρ=ρ0r3 and radius, R. B) Repeat when there is a concentric spherical cavity within the non conducting sphere with radius, A. Homework Equations...
  3. D

    B Space is Discrete? Argument Explored

    I be grateful for any feedback on this argument: - First assume space is continuous - Then there is an actually infinite amount of information in a spatial volume of 10000 cubic units - There is also an actually infinite amount of information in a spatial volume of 1 cubic unit - But this is a...
  4. S

    State Space representation of an inverted Pendulum

    Homework Statement I am trying to learn how to create state space representations. I am using this link to study. http://www2.ensc.sfu.ca/people/faculty/saif/ctm/examples/pend/invpen.html Could someone explain how to get the matrix A from my equations? Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a...
  5. J

    Are space fighters really impossible in realistic Sci Fi?

    TL;DR at bottomIt's a somewhat accepted convention that in realistic scifi space fighters should be impossible to use effectively. In general they are regarded as being easy targets that, at interstellar ranges would be unable to survive in a battlefield that employs current plausible scifi...
  6. Jd_duarte

    I Orthonormal Basis of Wavefunctions in Hilbert Space

    Hello, I've a fundamental question that seems to keep myself confused about the mathematics of quantum mechanics. For simplicity sake I'll approach this in the discrete fashion. Consider the countable set of functions of Hilbert space, labeled by i\in \mathbb{N} . This set \left...
  7. karush

    MHB 307.8.1 Suppose Y_1 and Y_2 form a basis for a 2-dimensional vector space V

    nmh{796} $\textsf{Suppose $Y_1$ and $Y_2$ form a basis for a 2-dimensional vector space $V$ .}\\$ $\textsf{Show that the vectors $Y_1+Y_2$ and $Y_1−Y_2$ are also a basis for $V$.}$ $$Y_1=\begin{bmatrix}a\\b\end{bmatrix} \textit{ and }Y_2=\begin{bmatrix}c\\d\end{bmatrix}$$ $\textit{ then }$...
  8. H

    B Feasibility of a L1 Gravity Swing Cold Launch?

    At an L1 LaGrangian point between two bodies, one could - materials science notwithstanding - pit two of Newton's Laws (LM3,UG) against each other to provide thruster-free stationkeeping. Would it be feasible to use that to launch free from the system ? either spit out like a watermelon seed...
  9. benorin

    B The geometry of the expansion of space

    I've been trying to wrap my head around the geometry of the expansion of space, from Science Channel shows I vaguely understand the "every point in space is moving away from every other point in space" and iirc this was uniformly so. Is that correct? If not ignore the rest of this post I suppose...
  10. T

    I Cooling of a hot body in the vacuum of space

    In the 19th century Lord Kelvin made the first numerical calculation of the age of the Earth not based on the Bible.From his initial guess that the Earth started as a molten rock and that today the temperature of the interior increases at a certain rate as you approach the center, he got an age...
  11. vincent

    I What is it that forces an object down curved space time?

    To explain the concept of curved space time, we often use analogy of rubber sheet. If we put a heavy ball at the centre of sheet then it creates a depression and now a smaller ball will fall towards that heavy ball because of depression. But in this analogy smaller ball is falling down the slope...
  12. Decimal

    I Inner products on a Hilbert space

    Hello, I am taking a quantum mechanics course using the Griffiths textbook and encountering some confusion on the definition of inner products on eigenfunctions of hermitian operators. In chapter 3 the definition of inner products is explained as follows: $$ \langle f(x)| g(x) \rangle = \int...
  13. K

    I Proof of 'Any Finite Dimensional Unitary Space is Complete'?

    In texts treating Hilbert spaces, it's usually given as an example that "any finite dimensional unitary space is complete", but I've found no proof so far and failed prove it myself.
  14. kenneththo85431

    Describing Electronic orbit in 3D space using A matrix.

    I've plotted out the trajectory of an imaginary electron in 3D; next I represent it's points with the matrix A(x1 y1 z1) "throughout it's orbit": ( -1/2 -1 1 ( -2 -1.5 2 (-1/2 2 3...
  15. Eclair_de_XII

    How many elements can be in an event space with two events?

    Homework Statement "Do there exist any event spaces with just six elements?" Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a Solution Suppose ##F_1## is an event space with a non-trivial event ##A##. Then ##F_1=\{∅,A,A^c,Ω\}##. So ##inf(|F_1|) = 4##, since if you remove any of these events, ##F_1## is no...
  16. F

    Complex numbers sequences/C is a metric space

    Homework Statement If ##\lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} x_n = L## then ##\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}cx_n = cL## where ##x_n## is a sequence in ##\mathbb{C}## and ##L, c \epsilon \mathbb{C}##. Homework Equations ##\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty} cx_n = cL## iff for all ##\varepsilon > 0##, there exists...
  17. sams

    A Difference between configuration space and phase space

    Lagrangian Mechanics uses generalized coordinates and generalized velocities in configuration space. Hamiltonian Mechanics uses coordinates and corresponding momenta in phase space. Could anyone please explain the difference between configuration space and phase space. Thank you in advance for...
  18. K

    I Theories without Fundamental Space and Time

    Can string theory be made without time equations? According to Carlo Rovelli in his latest book "The Order of Time" https://www.amazon.com/dp/073521610X/?tag=pfamazon01-20 : "The equations of loop quantum gravity on which I work are a modern version of the theory of Wheeler and DeWitt. There...
  19. M

    MHB Is $s$ the unique vector that spans the solution space $L(A,0)$?

    Hey! :o For a field $K$ and $1<n\in \mathbb{N}$ let $A\in K^{(n-1)\times n}$ aa matrix with rank $n-1$. For a row vector $z\in K^{1\times n}$ let $\left (\frac{A}{z}\right )\in K^{n\times n}$ be the matrix that we get if we add as the $n$-th row of the matrix $A$ the vector $z$. To show that...
  20. S

    I How was the value of the permittivity of free space determined?

    The permittivity of free space, ε0, is usually given without any derivation or historical context as to how it was experimentally determined. Could you explain to me how the value of ε0 was first determined experimentally or provide a resource that gives such a derivation? Thanks!
  21. W

    I Debye model and reciprocal space

    Hi everyone, I need a little help understanding how periodic reciprocal space applies to the Debye model for solids. Many thanks in advance! If we start with the general derivation of a dispersion relation for a 1D system, with atoms coupled by springs, one gets the following relation $$\omega...
  22. S

    I When should I use a plus or minus sign in space and time translations?

    Hello! I am a bit confused about the sign in space and time translation operators acting on a state. I found it with both plus and minus sign and I am not sure which one to use when. The equations I am talking about are: $$U(t)=e^{\pm iHt/\hbar}$$ and $$T(x)=e^{\pm ixp/\hbar}$$. Is it a plus or...
  23. A

    A What volume of interstellar space is needed to form a star?

    So, let me preface by saying I’m neither a scientist nor a mathematician, so am requesting some talented help here checking the accuracy of my source information and math. Regarding star formation, I got curious about how much volume of space in the interstellar medium is actually required to...
  24. Eclair_de_XII

    If O is an event space, show for a finite number of events--

    Homework Statement "If ##A_1,...,A_m\in O## and ##k\in ℕ##, show that the set of points in ##Ω## (the sample space) which belong to exactly ##k## of the ##A_i## belongs to ##O## (the previous exercise is the case when ##m=2## and ##k=1##)." Homework Equations Event space: O ##O\neq ∅##...
  25. M

    I Will Space Expansion Lead to the Formation of Black Holes and Neutron Stars?

    1) space is expanding at an increasing rate, therefore things are getting farther from each other and therefore increasing in velocity. 2) the faster an object moves relative to another, the more mass it has 3) supermassive objects can turn into neutron stars, black holes, etc. Therefore, will...
  26. M

    Dot product and basis vectors in a Euclidean Space

    Homework Statement I am asked to write an expression for the length of a vector V in terms of its dot product in an arbitrary system in Euclidean space. Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a Solution The dot product of a vector a with itself can be given by I a I2. Does that expression only apply...
  27. nivamani Rajbongshi

    B What Secrets Does the Color of Space Hold and How Does Space Travel Work?

    When we see with open eyes or in visible range of wavelength of e.m. wave we see black space containing some star...but if we see the space in other range of wavelength of the e.m. wave what will we see?? Also why the space is black?? Which matel we find in space mostly? Can we extract those...
  28. G

    A Phase Space and Its Use in Monte Carlo Simulations of Radiation Beams

    In the field of medical physics, specifically in monte carlo simulation of radiation beams produced by electron accelerators, people call ‘phase space’ to a file that contains the data of a large number of particles when they traverse a reference surface in the machine (usually a plane), i.e...
  29. Pushoam

    Functions forming a vector space

    Homework Statement 1.1.3 1) Do functions that vanish at the endpoints x=0 and L=0 form a vector space? 2) How about periodic functions? obeying f(0)=f(L) ? 3) How about functions that obey f(0)=4 ? If the functions do not qualify, list what go wrong.Homework Equations The Attempt at a...
  30. Pushoam

    Show: Vectors e.g.(a,b,1) do not form vector space.

    Homework Statement Homework Equations definition of null vector, [/B] The Attempt at a Solution null vector : ## |0 \rangle = (0,0,0) ## inverse of (a,b,c) = ( - a, -b, -c) vector sum of the two vectors of the same form e.g. (c,d,1) + ( e,f,1) = ( c+e, d+f, 2) does not have the same...
  31. M

    I Understanding Divergence of Vector Function F in 3D Space

    For the vector valud function F in the image, the three components of the output vector at a point are functions of (x,y,z)the three coordinates of the point.But while calculating divergence, why is the rate of change of x component of the output along x direction alone is accounted(similarly...
  32. Andrew broome

    B What can be used to propel something in space without fuel?

    To specify, by fuel I mean fossil, nuclear, chemical and pressurized air. Want to build and design a satellite for my daughter with a camera in it (goPro) with an antenna to be able to view anytime she likes. Want to do a hexagonal approach with solar cells only for power. Want to power the...
  33. l0st

    I Gravitational Waves Cause Uniform Space Expansion: Exploring MNRAS Papers

    I am looking at a couple of very interesting papers, published in MNRAS, that deduce, that the accelerated expansion of the Universe we observe can be attributed to gravitational waves, produced by a very distant merger of two or more universe-mass-scale black holes. The last one is on the...
  34. T

    Metric space of continuous & bounded functions is complete?

    Homework Statement The book I'm using provided a proof, however I'd like to try my hand on it and I came up with a different argument. I feel that something might be wrong. Proposition: Let ##<X,d>## be a metric space, ##<Y,D>## a complete metric space. Then ##<C(X,Y), \sup D>## is a complete...
  35. A

    Least cost to get a self-sustaining space infrastructure

    I was looking at NASA saying they might not have enough funds to put humans on Mars by 2040. OK, zoom forward maybe 200 years and the cost might be, maybe, just buy a ticket. Or people might already be working there; they will be paid to go there. So, here's the question. What is the least cost...
  36. S

    I What's the difference between Euclidean & Cartesian space?

    What's the difference between Euclidean & Cartesian space?
  37. S

    Programs (Space) Industry - Different Paths Towards It

    Hello! I am a returning student, 19YO, and will be starting back in community college in a month retaking classes I failed the first go-around with college. This is hopefully less of a "tell me what to do" thread, and more of a "clarify my misconceptions." Basically, I am very interested in a...
  38. H

    Can we use the momentum of light to propagate spacecrafts in space?

    as we know light has momentum so theoretically we can use it but is it practical? (also this is it that light only exerts force if incident on something?)
  39. I

    I Largest sphere in the space between dense packed spheres

    If I consider a tetrahedron of four densely packed spheres of unit radius, what it the radius of the largest sized sphere that can fit in the space in between?
  40. K

    I Uniqueness of tangent space at a point

    How do you show that there can be only one tangent space at a given point of a manifold? Geometrically it's pretty obvious in 3 dimensions, as one notices that there can be only one tangent plane at a point. But how could we show that using equations?
  41. P

    I Space elevator and Coriolis force

    It seems to me that the concept of a space elevator does not take Coriolis force into account. If the elevator were in built with a space station in geosynchronous orbit and counterweight then there is more to reaching the space station than just climbing the rope. The rope would have to be...
  42. bland

    B Understanding Particle Motion in Deep Intergalactic Space

    I hear that deepest void of intergalactic space may contain say one particle per cubic cm. I don't want to quibble the amount but let's take that as close enough for my purposes. Now is this figure a statistical average so that if it were correct that each cubic kilometre of deep space would...
  43. BillTre

    Obituary of Constance Adams, Space Habitat Designer

    Here is a rather interesting NY Times obituary of Constance Adams, space habitat architect. I never heard of her, she died young (53), but sounds quite interesting and did some fun design stuff.
  44. J

    What is the largest possible Rotating wheel space station?

    What is the largest possible Rotating wheel space station possible to be constructed with current materials? and what would be the population it would support. also formulas used for calculation.would be useful. Could constructing cylindrical space elevators support more population,
  45. K

    B Infinite dimensional Hilbert Space

    Could someone tell me in what sense the following photo of Hilbert is a infinite dimensional Hilbert Space? It's shown in a pdf I'm reading. Perhaps I'm putting the chariot in front of the horses as one would say here in our country, by considering infinite as infinite dimensional?
  46. J

    Decide if the energy surfaces in phase space are bounded

    Homework Statement From Classical Mechanics, Gregory, in the chapter on Hamilton's equations of motion: 14.13: Decide if the energy surfaces in phase space are bounded for the following cases: i.) The two-body gravitation problem with E<0 ii.) The two-body gravitation problem viewed from the...
  47. R

    Steering rockets in space by shifting CM

    So, I'm investigating a certain way of steering a rocket in space for my first undergraduate research project. Essentially, the idea is to control the location of some mass located on a horizontal track perpendicular to a rocket, so that when the mass is moved, the center of mass of the rocket...
  48. M

    B Light and Reflections in Space

    I am reading Feynman's book on QED and something struck me about light. I know that we can only calculate the probability of where a photon goes. After that I came across how a partial reflection affects light. My question is, is there a place in the universe where there is a great thickness of...
  49. Mr Davis 97

    I Real function inner product space

    Wolfram says that an example of an inner product space is the vector space of real functions whose domain is an closed interval [a,b] with inner product ##\langle f, g\rangle = \int_a^b f(x) g(x) dx##. But ##1/x## is a real function, and ##\langle 1/x, 1/x\rangle## does not converge... So how is...
Back
Top