What is Space: Definition and 1000 Discussions

Space is the boundless three-dimensional extent in which objects and events have relative position and direction. In classical physics, physical space is often conceived in three linear dimensions, although modern physicists usually consider it, with time, to be part of a boundless four-dimensional continuum known as spacetime. The concept of space is considered to be of fundamental importance to an understanding of the physical universe. However, disagreement continues between philosophers over whether it is itself an entity, a relationship between entities, or part of a conceptual framework.
Debates concerning the nature, essence and the mode of existence of space date back to antiquity; namely, to treatises like the Timaeus of Plato, or Socrates in his reflections on what the Greeks called khôra (i.e. "space"), or in the Physics of Aristotle (Book IV, Delta) in the definition of topos (i.e. place), or in the later "geometrical conception of place" as "space qua extension" in the Discourse on Place (Qawl fi al-Makan) of the 11th-century Arab polymath Alhazen. Many of these classical philosophical questions were discussed in the Renaissance and then reformulated in the 17th century, particularly during the early development of classical mechanics. In Isaac Newton's view, space was absolute—in the sense that it existed permanently and independently of whether there was any matter in the space. Other natural philosophers, notably Gottfried Leibniz, thought instead that space was in fact a collection of relations between objects, given by their distance and direction from one another. In the 18th century, the philosopher and theologian George Berkeley attempted to refute the "visibility of spatial depth" in his Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision. Later, the metaphysician Immanuel Kant said that the concepts of space and time are not empirical ones derived from experiences of the outside world—they are elements of an already given systematic framework that humans possess and use to structure all experiences. Kant referred to the experience of "space" in his Critique of Pure Reason as being a subjective "pure a priori form of intuition".
In the 19th and 20th centuries mathematicians began to examine geometries that are non-Euclidean, in which space is conceived as curved, rather than flat. According to Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, space around gravitational fields deviates from Euclidean space. Experimental tests of general relativity have confirmed that non-Euclidean geometries provide a better model for the shape of space.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. N

    I Exploring Einstein's theory about the curvature of space

    Einstein's theory states that curvature of space (created by a celestial body around itself) determines the orbital path of other celestial bodies around it within that curved space by a constant lateral force acting towards the centre upon that revolving body. Then why is that a similar force...
  2. N

    A Why do space translations satisfy the Wigner's Theorem?

    Some books argue that typical coordinate transformations such as space translations and rotations are represented in quantum mechanics by unitary operators because the Wigner's theorem. However I do not find any clear proof of this. For instance, suppose 1D for the sake of simplicity, by...
  3. E

    B Optimizing Stick Rotation in Space: Ideal Center of Mass Placement

    Let's say I have a 10 cm long stick in space. If I want it's right side to rotate as much as possible (even go backwards) by pushing on it's left end, where would the ideal position of the center of mass of the stick be? Would it be the middle, or closer to the right or left? And by how many...
  4. amjad-sh

    I Hilbert space and conjugate of a wave function

    Take a wavefunction ##\psi## and let this wavefunction be a solution of Schroedinger equation,such that: ##i \hbar \frac{\partial \psi}{\partial t}=H\psi## The complex conjugate of this wavefunction will satisfy the "wrong-sign Schrodinger equation" and not the schrodinger equation,such that ##i...
  5. B

    What are the probabilities for events A and B in a set of 10 cards?

    I need some help in checking my work, especially #4. Problem: You have a set of 10 cards numbered 1-10. You choose a card at random. Event A is choosing a number less than 8. Event B is choosing an even number. Draw a Venn Diagram and calculate each of the following probabilities: 1) P(A)...
  6. Urs Schreiber

    Mathematical Quantum Field Theory - Reduced Phase Space - Comments

    Greg Bernhardt submitted a new PF Insights post Mathematical Quantum Field Theory - Reduced Phase Space Continue reading the Original PF Insights Post.
  7. Rednecknav

    I Calculating Energy to Remove Space Debris from Earth Orbit

    How much energy needs to be be expended to throw a non operating satellite (or other space trash) out of orbit (L4 or L5) or L2 into deeper space... thus minimizing space debris in Earth orbit. I could only find formulas for getting an object INTO orbit... Background of question: we were...
  8. F

    Temperature of Space: Atomic/Molecular Motion & Equilibria

    Temperature is atomic/molecular motion. However, the temperature of planetary surfaces without an atmosphere are often quoted. For example, the temperature of the lunar surface ranges from about -200 F to +200 F depending on whether or not the surface is exposed to the sun or is in shadow...
  9. S

    A Operator mapping in Hilbert space

    Hi, I have an operator given by the expression: L = (d/dx +ia) where a is some constant. Applying this on x, gives a result in the subspace C and R. Can I safely conclude that the operator L can be given as: \begin{equation} L: \mathcal{H} \rightarrow \mathcal{H} \end{equation} where H is...
  10. DAirey

    I What is the acceleration of expanding space?

    If me and my pet duck, who weighs next to nothing, were placed far away from any gravity source and in such a way that our mutual attraction was negligible, would I see my duck accelerate away from me? If so, how fast?
  11. S

    How to calculate ambient temperature in space or in orbit?

    How would I go about calculating the ambient temperature in low Earth orbit (LEO) at approximately 400 km? What equations should I be referencing to determine the temperature of sun light side and/or eclipse side? Thanks!
  12. N

    B What is the physics of motion through space?

    The metric expansion of the Universe does not seem to cause some of the mechanical effects typically associated with motion (commute) of massive objects through space. For example, distant galaxies can be "flying away" from each other at speeds exceeding the speed of light. It seems that space...
  13. A

    I How long would it take for gas to leak out of a space box?

    I could not find an easy or believable source on this question on the internet. Anyway, if I had a box (volume V) in space full of gas (density N) and a hole suddenly appeared, how long would it take all of the air to completely leave the box out into space? I would assume the air would be at...
  14. J

    I Line Element in Minkowski Space: Geometric Meaning

    Hello, how can you imagine the geometrically meaning of the minus sign in ds2=-dx02+dx12+dx22+dx32, maybe similar to ds2=x12+dx22 is the length in a triangle with the Pythagoras theorem?
  15. Mcbleak

    B Expanding space time and Virtual particles

    If space time (the universe) is infinitely expanding what happens when it rips? Have we observed Virtual particles in an area and counted them? Does the expansion of space time affect the amount of Virtual particles in a particular area? Is it theoretically possible to expand space time to a...
  16. F

    Calculating the Length of a Space Elevator Rope

    Homework Statement The following task causes me problems: The science fiction writer R.A. Heinlein describes in the novel "Friday" a satellite ("space elevator"), which consists of a long rope, placed directly above the equator. The rope is aligned along the Earth's radius. It moves so that...
  17. P

    Maintaining interest in the new 'private' space race

    It's said that expectations drive the economy. So, how do you maintain interest in something that has no immediate bearing/benefit/utility of a population? I would think the answer to that question is to manifest a 'goal', in this case being an interplanetary species or even just building a...
  18. wukunlin

    I Putting a point inside a triangle in 3D space

    This may belong to the computing subforum, let me know if this is more true than having it here in the math forum :) My questions are 1) Suppose there is a plane in 3D space and I have 3 points to define it: p1 = {x1, y1, z1} p2 = {x2, y2, z2} p3 = {x3, y3, z3} and I want to put a particular...
  19. Jenna

    Conservation of Angular Momentum and Energy in a Rotating Space Station

    Homework Statement A space station (moment of inertia 5,000,000 kg•m2) is rotating with angular speed 0.30 rad/s when the 10 inhabitants are in the outer ring (radius 100 m). One half of the inhabitants move to the inner ring (radius 50 m). The average mass of each inhabitant is 70 kg. a...
  20. I like Serena

    MHB What is the basis of the trivial vector space {0}

    It makes me wonder... wikipedia says about a basis: In mathematics, a set of elements (vectors) in a vector space V is called a basis, or a set of basis vectors, if the vectors are linearly independent and every vector in the vector space is a linear combination of this set.[1] So what is the...
  21. Mayed Al-Tunaiji

    I Time & Space Expansion: High Schooler Qs

    Before I get to a question that's been on my mind for a while, I would like to make it clear that I am a high school student with no understanding of physics beyond my school's curriculum and some books that I've read, so excuse me if this sounds rather absurd. I know that the expansion of...
  22. JTC

    I Coordinate systems vs. Euclidean space

    Good Morning I am having some trouble categorizing a few concepts (I made the one that is critical to this post to be BOLD) Remote parallelism: the ability to move coordinate systems and frames around in space. Euclidean Space Coordinate systems: Cartesian vs. cylindrical I am aware that if...
  23. K

    I What is the Cause of Space Expansion?

    Does space expand only at the outer edges of the universe? What is the mechanism that creates more space particles? Is the huge volume of outer space pulling our universe apart? Please enlighten or comment. Kurt Ludwig
  24. Urs Schreiber

    Mathematical Quantum Field Theory - Phase Space - Comments

    Greg Bernhardt submitted a new PF Insights post Mathematical Quantum Field Theory - Phase Space Continue reading the Original PF Insights Post.
  25. wolram

    B Is Scale Invariance the Key to Understanding the Expansion of the Universe?

    https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/11/171122113013.htm A University of Geneva researcher has recently shown that the accelerating expansion of the universe and the movement of the stars in the galaxies can be explained without drawing on the concepts of dark matter and dark energy…...
  26. S

    B Exploring Einstein's Field Equations: Space Density

    Hi, I'm trying to understand Einstein's field equations conceptually, does it describe space density in a region of space by any chance? Like there is more space in this region compared to this other region. Thanks.
  27. Jamz

    I Map from space spanned by 2 complex conjugate vars to R^2

    Hello, I would like your help understanding how to map a region of the space \mathbb{C}^2 spanned by two complex conjugate variables to the real plane \mathbb{R}^2 . Specifically, let us think that we have two complex conugate variables z and \bar{ z} and we define a triangle in the...
  28. B

    Finding Angles of Triangle Given Two Points on Earth and One in Space

    Hello Folks, I have two points on Earth at each end of a great circle path, for which I know the length in km and direction in degrees True. Also I have the RA and DEC of an object in space as seen from one of the previous points. The RA and DEC come from the setting circles of a telescope...
  29. S

    I How to check if a matrix is Hilbert space and unitary?

    I have a matrix, [ a, ib; -1 1] where a and b are constants. I have to represent and analyse this matrix in a Hilbert space: I take the space C^2 of this matrix is Hilbert space. Is it sufficient to generate the inner product: <x,y> = a*ib -1 and obtain the norm by: \begin{equation}...
  30. T

    I Where in our solar system are asteroids that contain ammonia

    Hi! I'm doing a research project titled "Is it possible to colonise Mars?" I'm currently researching how to raise the temperature and pressure - and I've discovered to do this that re-directing asteroids towards Mars containing Ammonia would be vital. However, where do these asteroids that...
  31. K

    Potential and kinetic force of an arrow shot at space.

    Assume a person is at space, and assume there's no friction or gravitational force in that space. The person has a bow and arrow. He stretches the arrow on the bow, and then shots the arrow out in the space. Since there are no friction and gravitational force in that space, the arrow will have...
  32. S

    Continuity and discrete space

    Homework Statement Find ##f:R \to X##, f-continuous, where X is the discrete space. Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a Solution f is continuous at p if for any ##\epsilon > 0## there is ##\delta >0## such that ##d(f(x),f(p))<\epsilon## for all x such that ##d(x,p)<\delta##. Let ##\epsilon =...
  33. S

    I How to study an ODE in matrix form in a Hilbert space?

    Hello, I have derived the matrix form of one ODE, and found a complex matrix, whose phase portrait is a spiral source. The matrix indicates further that the ODE has diffeomorphic flow and requires stringent initial conditions. I have thought about including limits for the matrix, however the...
  34. PsychonautQQ

    A Orbit space of a covering map

    Suppose ##q: E-->X## is a covering map (not necessarily normal). Let ##E' = E/ Aut_{q}(E)## be the orbit space, and let ##\pi: E-->E'## be the quotient map. Then there is a covering map ##q': E' --->X## such that ##q' * \pi = q## where ##*## is composition of functions. I am confused why ##E'##...
  35. H

    A Derivation of the Casimir energy in flat space

    I am trying to understand the derivation of the Casimir energy from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Derivation_of_Casimir_effect_assuming_zeta-regularization. At one point, the derivation writes the following: The vacuum energy is then the sum over all possible excitation modes...
  36. G

    I Does Gravity Change Space Density? Exploring Everything and Nothing

    I was watching a movie called Everything and Nothing. It got me thinking. For the sake of argument pretend that you could make the sun pop in and out of existence. If you were to measure the distance between two points on the other side of the solar system with no sun, then if the sun were to...
  37. R

    Space Travel with balloon assist

    Near space travels with balloons. http://edition.cnn.com/2015/03/05/tech/balloons-fly-edge-of-space/index.html look at above link. balloons goes just 36 km above Earth surface. but Earth orbit is 100 km away. so my thinking is if we pump oxygen outside near helium balloon artificially when u...
  38. ISamson

    The Future of Space Exploration

    Hello. As many theories and hypotheses that there are about a secure, reliable and effective future space exploration and colonisation that there are, I would like to dedicate this thread to the discussion of this topic. Some of the suggestions are: Von Neumann probes are an effective strategy...
  39. Drakkith

    Does the Null Space of a 2x3 Matrix Determine its Column Space?

    Homework Statement Let ##A## be a 2x3 matrix. If Nul(##A##) is a line through the origin in ℝ3, then Col(##A##) = ℝ2. Explain why. Hint: Think about the number of pivots in ##A##. Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a Solution So, Nul(##A##) is the set of all solutions to the equation ##Ax=0##...
  40. S

    I Generating a Hilbert space representation of a wavefunction

    Hello, I Have a particle with wavefunction Psi(x) = e^ix and would like to find its Hilbert space representation for a period of 0-2pi. Which steps should I follow? Thanks!
  41. Poetria

    Tension Ratio in a Uniformly Distributed Rope System

    Homework Statement [/B] A rope with uniform mass distribution is attached to a spaceship. At the end of this rope, there is a mass, m. The length of the rope - l. Point A - where the rope is attached to a spaceship Point B - in the middle of the rope. The whole system moves with the same...
  42. R

    B 2 clocks -- Using orthogonal light path detectors in a space ship

    Hi I can't see the error in this can someone please explain where I went wrong? A man is in a spaceship traveling at a constant velocity He makes 2 identical tubes of length L with a mirror at one end, tube a and tube b He has a single light bulb. Next to the bulb is a detector. He carefully...
  43. S

    What is 'phase space in chaos theory and nonlinear dynamics?

    The term 'phase space' is often used in the study of nonlinear dynamics.What is it.
  44. S

    No sublimation for human body in vacuum? [Thermodynamics]

    In my Thermodynamics course, we recently learned about the saturation pressure and saturation temperature of different substances -mainly water. As you know, the saturation temperature at which a substance begins to boil is specific to a fixed saturation pressure. Water only boils at 100...
  45. S

    I What is the difference between phase space and state-space?

    In state space, the coordinates are the state variables of a system.So,each point in state space represents a specific value of state variables.Thus,state space representation represents the changes in a dynamical system. The state variables are the minimum number of variables which uniquely...
  46. weezy

    I Explore Homogeneity of Space: Effects on Relativity Theory

    This is a basic assumption that's made during the derivation of results of special theory of relativity is that space is homogeneous i.e. space intervals shouldn't be given preference based on our choice of origin. However I want to understand more about this assumption and its importance...
  47. R

    Resultant Force and Acceleration of Space craft

    Homework Statement https://isaacphysics.org/questions/gcse_ch2_13_q10 https://www.physicsforums.com/attachments/213735 https://i.imgur.com/WnZkt83.jpg The thrust generated by a rocket engine is equal to the mass of propellant burnt each second multiplied by the exhaust velocity of the gas...
  48. nmsurobert

    I Nuclear batteries on space probes

    I've been reading about this a bit and stumbled across something that said its desirable that the heat source not be something that emits a lot of gamma radiation. Other than hazards to a technician, does this have any effect on the device its being used on? Why would it require extra shielding...
  49. B

    Closure of Connected Space is Connected

    Homework Statement If ##C## is a connected space in some topological space ##X##, then the closure ##\overline{C}## is connected. Homework EquationsThe Attempt at a Solution Suppose that ##\overline{C} = A \cup B## is separation; hence, ##A## and ##B## are disjoint and do not share limit...
  50. Andrea Vironda

    Exploring the Homogeneity of Space & Time in Lagrangian Mechanics

    Hi, i know that The homogeneity of space and time implies that the Lagrangian cannot contain explicitly either the radius vector r of the particle or the time t, i.e. L must be a function of v only but the lagrangian definition is ##L=\int L(\dot q,q,t)##, so velocity appears in the definition...
Back
Top