Calculating Beam Deflection using Double Integration

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating beam deflection at point D after removing a distributed force. Participants clarify the use of boundary conditions (BCs) for a simply supported beam, noting that deflection at both ends (A and B) must be zero. There is confusion regarding the slope BC, as it cannot be specified for simply supported beams without additional information. The correct reactions at supports A and B are established as P/4 and 3P/4, respectively, after realizing the distributed load should be ignored. Ultimately, the participants emphasize that only two BCs are needed to solve for the constants of integration, despite uncertainties about the slope.
mm391
Messages
65
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



If the distributed force is removed from the beam in the picture attached and not considered, calculate the deflection at point D.

Homework Equations



Double integration for deflection [V]


The Attempt at a Solution



Moment = Ra*x-P(x-3*L) =

Slope = 1/EI*((7p/4)*(x^2/2)-(Px^2/2)-(3PL)+c1)
Deflection = 1/EI*((7p/4)*(x^3/6)-(Px^3/6)-(3PL)+(c1*x)+c2)

Boundary Conditions to calculate c1 and c2
x=0=4L V=0

I am not sure of another boundary condition. I thought maybe

x=2L Slope=0 but I do not think this is right.
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.jpg
    Untitled.jpg
    9.7 KB · Views: 528
Physics news on Phys.org
Your boundary conditions at A and B are very curious.

Since the beam is simply supported at both A and B, what BC must apply?
(Hint: they will both be the same)
 
When x=0 V=0
or
When x=4L V=0

This is because they are simply supported so therefore there can be no deflection at either end. But don't I need a BC for the slope. As there is an unknown slope at A and B how can I find one to use?
 
I'm confused. V usually represents the shear force. Are you using it to denote deflection?
 
I reread your OP.

You can still use the BCs for deflection at A and B since you have only two unknown constants of integration.
 
Sorry out lecturer started using V for deflection but I see in most textbooks it is U.

How can i calculate C1 if I don't have a boundary condition for a slope?
 
You can't specify a slope for a simply supported beam.

Your two BCs are the deflections at A and B, both of which are zero.
 
From my boundary conditions I have:
c1=-PL^2/8
c2= 3PL

Using these I still have the wrong answer for the defelction at D. Can anyone see where I maybe going wrong?
 
What reactions did you calculate at A and B?
 
  • #10
I made a mistake. I worked out the reactions which included the Distributed load. The question asks us to ignore the distributed load.

In which case my reactions are:

Reactions@A= P/4
Reactions @B=3P/4

The of the beam from the left hand side of P is (P/4)*x = M1
The moment from 3L<x<4L is (p/4)*(x)-P(x-3L) = M2

Boundary conditions I can see are (now using U as the deflction):

x=0 U=0
x=3L Slope=0 (although I am not sure this is correct as we are given no info about the slope)
x=4L U=0

Is this correct?

Sorry I am struggling to see where I am going wrong.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Two boundary conditions are sufficient, since there are only two constants of integration. The BCs at the ends are easily determined by inspection. Although there is a point of zero slope somewhere between A and B, it may not necessarily be at x = 3l.
 
Back
Top